Okay, let's derive the Modified Cam Clay (MCC) model.
The MCC model is an elastoplastic constitutive model for saturated soils, particularly clays, based on the concept of a Critical State. It's a 'critical state model' because it describes soil behavior leading towards a unique critical state under continuous shearing. It's 'modified' compared to the original Cam Clay primarily due to its elliptical yield surface, which provides a better fit to experimental data, especially near the origin of the stress space.
The derivation involves defining the following components:
Stress and Strain Measures: Defining the relevant stress and strain invariants.
Elastic Component: Describing the reversible, elastic deformation.
Plastic Component: Describing the irreversible, plastic deformation.
Yield Surface: The boundary in stress space separating elastic and elastoplastic behavior.
Hardening Law: How the yield surface changes size (hardens or softens) with plastic strain.
Flow Rule: Relating the direction of plastic strain increment to the stress state (specifically, the normal to the yield surface).
Consistency Condition: The condition that the stress state remains on the yield surface during plastic loading.
Assumptions:
Effective stress principle holds.
Soil is isotropic.
Elastic strains are small and reversible. Bulk and shear moduli may depend on stress (specifically, mean effective stress).
Plastic flow is associative (plastic potential surface is the same as the yield surface), implying the normality principle.
A unique Critical State exists.
1. Stress and Strain Measures
The model is formulated in terms of effective stress invariants:
Mean effective stress: p′=3σx′+σy′+σz′=3σ1′+σ2′+σ3′
Deviatoric stress invariant: q=23sijsij=21[(σ1′−σ2′)2+(σ2′−σ3′)2+(σ3′−σ1′)2]
where sij=σij′−p′δij is the deviatoric stress tensor.
Strain measures:
Volumetric strain: εv=εx+εy+εz=ε1+ε2+ε3 (compression is usually positive in soil mechanics)
Shear strain (octahedral shear strain): εs=32eijeij=32(ε1−ε2)2+(ε2−ε3)2+(ε3−ε1)2
where eij=εij−31εvδij is the deviatoric strain tensor.
Note: Sometimes εs is defined differently, e.g., related to engineering shear strains γ. Here we use the form conjugate to q in terms of work.
Specific volume: v=1+e, where e is the void ratio. dεv=−dv/v (if εv is positive for compression, v decreases, so dv is negative).
2. Elastic Component
Elastic deformation is stress-dependent.
Volumetric elastic strain is related to mean effective stress: dεve=K′dp′
Shear elastic strain is related to deviatoric stress: dεse=3Gdq (The factor 3G is used for conjugation with q).
The bulk modulus K′ and shear modulus G for soils are often taken as proportional to p′. In MCC, K′ is derived from the elastic swelling/recompression line in v-lnp′ space, which has a slope −κ.
dve=−κd(lnp′)=−κp′dp′
Since dεve=−dve/v, dεve=−(−κp′dp′)/v=vp′κdp′.
Thus, K′=κvp′. G is often treated as constant for simplicity in the basic model.
The elastic strain increments are:
dεve=vp′κdp′dεse=3G1dq
3. Plastic Component
a) Critical State Line (CSL)
In v-lnp′ space, the CSL is a straight line with slope −λ:
vCS=Γ−λlnp′ (where Γ is the specific volume at p′=1 kPa on the CSL).
In p′-q space, the CSL is a straight line passing through the origin:
qCS=Mp′ (where M is the slope of the CSL).
b) Yield Surface
The MCC yield surface is an ellipse in the p′-q plane, symmetric about the p′-axis. It passes through the origin (p′=0,q=0) and intersects the p′-axis at a point (pc′,0). pc′ is the 'pre-consolidation pressure' or the size of the yield surface, acting as the hardening parameter.
The equation of the ellipse is:
(ap′−pc′/2)2+(bq)2=1
For it to pass through (pc′,0), we need (apc′−pc′/2)2+0=1⟹(apc′/2)2=1⟹a=pc′/2.
For it to pass through (0,0), we need (pc′/20−pc′/2)2+(b0)2=1⟹(−1)2+0=1, which is satisfied for any b.
The relationship between the ellipse and the CSL is crucial. The ellipse touches the CSL at its highest point. At this point, p′=pc′/2 and q=b. Also, q=Mp′.
So, b=M(pc′/2).
Substituting a=pc′/2 and b=Mpc′/2 into the ellipse equation:
(pc′/2p′−pc′/2)2+(Mpc′/2q)2=1(pc′2p′−pc′)2+M2(pc′)24q2=1(pc′)2(2p′−pc′)2+M2(pc′)24q2=1(2p′−pc′)2+M24q2=(pc′)24p′2−4p′pc′+(pc′)2+M24q2=(pc′)24p′2−4p′pc′+M24q2=0
Divide by 4:
p′2−p′pc′+M2q2=0
Rearranging, the yield surface equation F(p′,q,pc′)=0 is:
F(p′,q,pc′)=q2−M2p′(pc′−p′)=0
This can be written as q2=M2p′(pc′−p′).
c) Hardening Law
The size of the yield surface pc′ is the hardening parameter. It evolves with plastic volumetric strain εvp.
The plastic volume change is related to the change in position relative to the Critical State Line.
Consider the specific volume v at a state (p′,q). If the soil were normally consolidated at this p′, its specific volume would be vNCL(p′). The difference is related to the current pc′.
The specific volume v is related to p′ and pc′ via the swelling line concept. Imagine unloading from the current state (v, p') back to p'=1 kPa along a swelling line. The volume would be vk=v+κlnp′. Now imagine loading from a normally consolidated state at p'=1 kPa (vλ=Γ) up to the pressure pc′. The volume would be vλ−λlnpc′.
Thus, the current state (v,p′) is on a swelling line that would intersect the NCL at pc′:
v+κlnp′=Γ−λlnpc′+κlnpc′ (This is the equation of the state boundary surface in v-ln p' - ln p_c' space)
v=Γ−(λ−κ)lnpc′−κlnp′v−κlnp′=Γ−(λ−κ)lnpc′.
Differentiating this at constant p′ gives dv=−(λ−κ)d(lnpc′)=−(λ−κ)pc′dpc′.
The total change in v is dv=dve+dvp. At constant p′, dve=0. So dv=dvp.
dvp=−vdεvp.
Thus, −vdεvp=−(λ−κ)pc′dpc′.
Rearranging gives the hardening law:
pc′dpc′=λ−κvdεvpNote: Some texts use λ instead of λ−κ in the denominator, often when defining plastic volume strain differently or simplifying assumptions are made. The standard formulation based on state boundary surface uses λ−κ. Let's use the λ−κ form.
d) Flow Rule
Associative flow rule states that the plastic strain increment vector is proportional to the gradient of the yield surface in stress space.
(dεvp,dεsp)∝(∂p′∂F,∂q∂F)dεvp=dΛ∂p′∂Fdεsp=dΛ∂q∂F
where dΛ is a non-negative plastic multiplier.
Partial derivatives of F=q2−M2p′pc′+M2p′2:
∂p′∂F=−M2pc′+2M2p′=M2(2p′−pc′)=−M2(pc′−2p′)∂q∂F=2q∂pc′∂F=−M2p′
The ratio dεsp/dεvp=−M2(pc′−2p′)2q. This ratio determines the dilation/contraction behavior. Dilation (dεvp<0) occurs when pc′−2p′<0, i.e., p′>pc′/2. Contraction (dεvp>0) occurs when p′<pc′/2. The line p′=pc′/2 is called the Phase Transformation Line (PTL), where dεvp=0. On the yield surface, p′=pc′/2 corresponds to q2=M2(pc′/2)(pc′−pc′/2)=M2(pc′/2)2, so q=±Mpc′/2. This means the PTL predicted by associative MCC is at q/p′=±M, which coincides with the CSL. This is a known limitation, as real soils tend to start dilating at q/p′<M.
e) Consistency Condition
During plastic loading (F=0 and dF=0), the stress state must remain on the yield surface.
dF=∂p′∂Fdp′+∂q∂Fdq+∂pc′∂Fdpc′=0
From these, we can express dp′ and dq in terms of total and plastic strain increments:
dp′=κvp′(dεv−dΛ∂p′∂F)dq=3G(dεs−dΛ∂q∂F)
Substitute these into the consistency equation:
∂p′∂F[κvp′(dεv−dΛ∂p′∂F)]+∂q∂F[3G(dεs−dΛ∂q∂F)]+∂pc′∂Fdpc′=0
Now substitute the hardening law dpc′=λ−κvpc′dεvp=λ−κvpc′dΛ∂p′∂F:
∂p′∂Fκvp′dεv−dΛ∂p′∂Fκvp′∂p′∂F+∂q∂F3Gdεs−dΛ∂q∂F3G∂q∂F+∂pc′∂Fλ−κvpc′dΛ∂p′∂F=0
Rearrange to solve for dΛ:
dΛ[κvp′(∂p′∂F)2+3G(∂q∂F)2−∂pc′∂Fλ−κvpc′∂p′∂F]=∂p′∂Fκvp′dεv+∂q∂F3Gdεs
Let the term in square brackets be DMCC (the plastic hardening modulus scaled by material properties and partial derivatives):
DMCC=κvp′(∂p′∂F)2+3G(∂q∂F)2−λ−κvpc′∂pc′∂F∂p′∂F
dΛ=DMCC∂p′∂Fκvp′dεv+∂q∂F3GdεsdΛ is non-zero only during plastic loading (F=0 and dΛ>0, or more strictly, the numerator must be positive). If the numerator is negative, it's elastic unloading, and dΛ=0. If F<0, it's elastic state and dΛ=0.
Substituting the partial derivatives of F:
∂p′∂F=−M2(pc′−2p′)∂q∂F=2q∂pc′∂F=−M2p′
Numerator:
Num = [−M2(pc′−2p′)]κvp′dεv+[2q]3Gdεs
The elastoplastic stress-strain relationship can be written by substituting dΛ back into the equations for dp′ and dq:
dp′=K′dεv−K′∂p′∂FdΛ=κvp′dεv−κvp′[−M2(pc′−2p′)]dΛdq=3Gdεs−3G∂q∂FdΛ=3Gdεs−3G[2q]dΛ
Where dΛ=DMCCNum.
These equations, along with the definitions of K′, G, the yield surface F, and the hardening law for pc′, constitute the Modified Cam Clay model.