Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

how to fine tune whisper with only audio files and without transcripts, just in case it…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-flash-lite-preview-06-17-thinking’s answer.
  1. User

    how to fine tune whisper with only audio files and without transcripts, just in case it was not available?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    You've hit upon a critical challenge in ASR: traditional supervised fine-tuning of models like Whisper fundamentally requires paired audio-text data. The model learns to map specific sound patterns (from the audio) to their corresponding written representation (the text transcript). Without those transcripts, it doesn't know what it's supposed to be predicting.

    Therefore, it's not possible to fine-tune Whisper for speech-to-text with only audio files and no transcripts in the conventional sense.

    However, there are semi-supervised techniques that can leverage large amounts of untranscribed audio, typically by generating "pseudo-labels" or through more complex unsupervised pre-training, followed by supervised fine-tuning.

    Here's how you might approach this, understanding that it's a compromise and will likely yield lower performance than a fully supervised approach with high-quality human transcripts:

    The Pseudo-Labeling / Self-Training Approach (The Most Feasible)

    This is the most common technique for utilizing untranscribed audio when some initial ASR capability exists.

    1. Initial Pass with a Pre-trained Whisper Model:

      • Take your untranscribed Cypriot audio files.
      • Run them through the best available pre-trained Whisper model (e.g., openai/whisper-large). This model has seen a lot of data, including some Greek, and will attempt to transcribe your Cypriot audio.
      • Result: You will get automatically generated transcripts. Crucially, these transcripts will contain errors, especially because the Cypriot dialect has phonetic and lexical differences from standard Greek, and the pre-trained Whisper model wasn't specifically trained on it.
    2. Quality Control and Filtering of Pseudo-Labels (CRITICAL STEP):

      • This is the most important part to avoid "garbage in, garbage out."
      • Confidence Scores: If your ASR tool provides confidence scores for its predictions, filter out transcripts with low confidence.
      • Length Filtering: Discard very short or very long transcripts, as they often indicate ASR errors (e.g., misidentifying background noise as speech, or missing large chunks).
      • Language Model Scoring: If you can train a simple language model on any available Cypriot text (even if it's just a small amount, or related Greek text), you can use it to score the perplexity of the generated pseudo-labels. Higher perplexity might indicate a poorer transcription.
      • Deduplication: Remove duplicate audio/text pairs if they exist.
      • Manual Review (Even Partial): Even if you can't manually transcribe everything, try to spot-check a random sample of the pseudo-labeled data. This helps you understand the types of errors the model is making and might guide your filtering strategy. If you can manually correct even a small portion (e.g., 1-2 hours), it would be incredibly valuable for later steps.
    3. Fine-Tuning with Pseudo-Labels:

      • Treat the filtered, automatically generated transcripts as your "ground truth."
      • Use these audio-pseudo-text pairs to fine-tune your chosen Whisper model (e.g., whisper-base or whisper-small). Follow the standard Whisper fine-tuning process as described in the previous answer, but using your pseudo-labeled dataset.
    4. Iterative Refinement (Self-Training Loop):

      • After the first round of fine-tuning, your model should be slightly better at understanding Cypriot dialect than the initial pre-trained Whisper model.
      • Re-generate Pseudo-Labels: Run your newly fine-tuned model over the entire untranscribed Cypriot audio dataset again. Because the model has now learned some Cypriot nuances, its new pseudo-labels should be more accurate than the first set.
      • Refine and Filter: Apply the same quality control and filtering steps.
      • Further Fine-Tuning: Use these improved pseudo-labels to fine-tune the model again.
      • Repeat: You can repeat this process a few times. Each iteration, the model potentially generates better pseudo-labels, leading to further improvement.

    Limitations of Pseudo-Labeling:

    • Error Propagation: If the initial pseudo-labels are poor, the model can learn and reinforce those errors.
    • Performance Ceiling: This method will almost certainly not reach the performance level of a model fine-tuned on high-quality, human-transcribed data. It can improve, but it's limited by the initial quality of the auto-generated transcripts.
    • Domain Shift: If your initial Whisper model performs very poorly on Cypriot dialect, the pseudo-labels might be too noisy to be useful for fine-tuning.

    Other Less Direct Approaches (More Complex, Less Likely for Whisper Fine-tuning):

    • Unsupervised Pre-training (e.g., Wav2Vec 2.0, HuBERT):
      • This is a different beast. You could pre-train a model like Wav2Vec 2.0 or HuBERT from scratch on your massive untranscribed Cypriot audio dataset. These models learn rich audio representations without any text.
      • The Catch: After pre-training, you still need a small amount of transcribed data to fine-tune it for the ASR task (i.e., mapping the learned audio features to text). This wouldn't be "fine-tuning Whisper without transcripts" but rather building a separate ASR system. Whisper's architecture isn't typically used for unsupervised pre-training in the same way these models are.

    Conclusion and Recommendation:

    If you absolutely have zero human-transcribed Cypriot audio:

    1. Start with the Pseudo-Labeling / Self-Training approach. This is your best bet for improving Whisper's performance on Cypriot dialect using only untranscribed audio.
    2. Prioritize Quality Control: Spend significant effort on filtering and cleaning your pseudo-labels. Bad data is worse than no data.
    3. Even a small amount of human transcription is invaluable. If you can get even 1-5 hours of highly accurate human-transcribed Cypriot audio, use it for initial fine-tuning, and then use the pseudo-labeling technique for the rest of your untranscribed data. This small, high-quality seed dataset can significantly bootstrap the process and guide the model better than purely noisy pseudo-labels.

    In essence, while you can't fine-tune Whisper directly without transcripts, you can use the model itself to generate the transcripts, and then use those generated transcripts to fine-tune it in a semi-supervised fashion.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.