Skip to content
The Chat Archive
gemini-2.0-flash-001· Google LMArena Human Preference 140K

I want to distill two LLMs, one for doing purely natural conversation and chat, and…

  1. User

    I want to distill two LLMs, one for doing purely natural conversation and chat, and another one for doing heavy reasoning and long time decisions based on the first, as well as managing other parts of the system. What "teacher" models do you think are best for each case?

  2. Assistant

    Okay, let's break down the best teacher models for your two LLM distillation projects. You've got a good strategy: separating natural conversation from heavy reasoning/decision-making is often a smart move.

    1. Natural Conversation/Chat (Student LLM #1)

    The goal here is to create a model that's fluent, engaging, and capable of handling a wide range of conversational topics. You want a model that can understand nuances in tone, maintain a consistent persona (if desired), and respond in a human-like way.

    Top Teacher Model Candidates for Chat/Conversation:

    • GPT-4: This is arguably the gold standard right now. Its conversational abilities are extremely high. It's fluent, creative, understands context very well, and is less prone to generating nonsensical responses compared to older models. It is available through the OpenAI API.
    • Gemini 1.5 Pro (or Ultra): While availability is a consideration, if you have access, the latest Gemini models are competitive with GPT-4 for conversational tasks. They often excel at understanding subtle cues and generating diverse responses. It is available through the Google AI API.
    • Claude 3 Opus: The conversational ability of Claude 3 Opus is top-tier, it understands long contexts well and is very good at natural language. It is available through the Anthropic API.
    • Llama 3 70B: Very powerful model that is also open-source, can be used as a teacher model or trained on your data to become a highly performant agent.

    Why these are good choices:

    • High Fluency: They produce very natural-sounding text.
    • Strong Context Understanding: They are good at remembering past turns in the conversation and using that information to generate relevant responses.
    • Good Persona Maintenance: If you want your distilled model to have a specific personality, these models are good at consistently embodying it in their responses.
    • Safety and Responsibility: While no model is perfect, these models have been generally trained with some safety guardrails to avoid generating harmful or offensive content.

    2. Heavy Reasoning/Long-Term Decision Making/System Management (Student LLM #2)

    This is where you need a model that can go beyond simple conversation and demonstrate strong logical reasoning, planning, and the ability to juggle multiple inputs and outputs to control a larger system.

    Top Teacher Model Candidates for Reasoning/Decision-Making:

    • GPT-4: Still a strong contender. GPT-4's reasoning capabilities are notably better than earlier models, although not its specific expertise. It is excellent for coding tasks and integrating tools through functions calls. Available through the OpenAI API.
    • Gemini 1.5 Pro (or Ultra): Again, if you have access, the Gemini models are known for their reasoning strengths, especially when provided with large amounts of context. They can process long documents and extract relevant information for decision-making. Available through the Google AI API.
    • Claude 3 Opus: Excels at complex reasoning and can handle sophisticated tasks that require both creativity and logic. It is available through the Anthropic API.
    • PaLM 2: While PaLM 2 is the predecessor to Gemini, it still has strong reasoning capabilities and might be more accessible or cost-effective in some cases. Check if it meets your performance needs.
    • Specialized Models (Function Calling/Tool Use): If your system management involves calling specific tools or APIs, consider models specifically trained for function calling. Many of the base models above can be fine-tuned or prompted for this, but you might also find dedicated models that are already good at it. Llama 3 is especially good at this.

    Why these are good choices:

    • Logical Reasoning: They can perform complex deductions and inferences.
    • Planning & Strategy: They can break down complex goals into smaller steps and create plans to achieve them.
    • Contextual Awareness: They can maintain a long-term view of the system state and use that to make informed decisions.
    • Tool Use/Function Calling: Crucial for managing a system – they can interact with external tools, APIs, and databases.
    • Coding Abilities: If your system management involves writing or modifying code, these models generally have good coding skills.

    Important Considerations for Distillation:

    • Data Quality is King: The quality of your training data (generated by the teacher model) is the most important factor for distillation success. You need a large and diverse dataset that covers the types of conversations and reasoning tasks you want your distilled models to handle.
    • Distillation Techniques: Experiment with different distillation techniques, such as:
      • Soft Labels: Use the probability distributions from the teacher model (rather than just the "best" answer) as targets for the student model. This can transfer more subtle knowledge.
      • Hidden State Distillation: Try to match the internal representations (hidden states) of the teacher model.
      • Adversarial Training: Train the student model to fool a discriminator that tries to distinguish between teacher and student outputs.
    • Evaluation Metrics: Carefully choose evaluation metrics that reflect the specific goals of each model. For the chat model, metrics like fluency, coherence, and engagement are important. For the reasoning model, metrics like accuracy, planning success rate, and tool usage correctness are crucial.
    • Iteration: Distillation is an iterative process. You'll likely need to experiment with different teacher models, training data, and distillation techniques to achieve the best results.

    Example Workflow (Simplified):

    1. Chat Model Distillation:

      • Teacher: GPT-4 or Claude 3 Opus.
      • Data Generation: Provide GPT-4 with diverse conversation prompts and scenarios. Ask it to generate high-quality responses. Experiment with different styles and personas.
      • Distillation: Train a smaller student LLM on the generated data using soft labels.
      • Evaluation: Measure fluency, coherence, engagement, and persona consistency.
    2. Reasoning/Decision-Making Model Distillation:

      • Teacher: GPT-4 with function calling capabilities, Gemini 1.5 Pro, or Claude 3 Opus.
      • Data Generation: Create complex scenarios that require reasoning, planning, and tool use. For example:
        • "You are an AI assistant managing a smart home. The user says, 'I'm cold.' You need to determine the best way to warm them up (adjust thermostat, turn on a space heater, suggest a blanket), and then take the necessary actions using the available API calls."
      • Distillation: Train a smaller student LLM on this data, focusing on accurate decision-making and correct tool usage.
      • Evaluation: Measure accuracy of decisions, success rate of plans, correctness of tool calls, and efficiency.

    By carefully selecting your teacher models and using appropriate distillation techniques, you can create two specialized LLMs that work together to provide both engaging conversation and robust reasoning and system management capabilities. Good luck!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.