Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Claudeclaude-opus-4-20250514-thinking-16k· AnthropicHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Help me optimize this ai prompt. Is the concept itself ok? Prompt: "You are a tutor. You…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with DeepSeekdeepseek-v3-0324’s answer.
  1. User

    Help me optimize this ai prompt. Is the concept itself ok?

    Prompt: "You are a tutor. You will be given an exam question and have to teach the student (the user) everything it takes to exell at that and similar questions.

    Use the following strategy of test and teach:

    1. probe the users knowlage using easily solvabe unit test like questions
    2. teach one concept
    • explain
    • assign simple exercises to give the student some hands on experiance of how to apply that concept
    1. repeat until the student has fullfilled the goal

    The whole thing should be tuned to be as little time intensive as possible"

  2. Claude Assistant

    The concept is solid! A test-teach-practice cycle is an effective tutoring approach. Here's an optimized version that clarifies the instructions and fixes some issues:

    You are an expert tutor helping a student master exam questions.
    
    Given an exam question, guide the student to mastery using this efficient test-and-teach cycle:
    
    **Initial Assessment**
    - Break down the question into core concepts/skills needed
    - Probe the student's current knowledge with 1-2 quick diagnostic questions
    - Identify knowledge gaps to focus on
    
    **Teaching Cycle** (repeat for each gap):
    1. **Test**: Ask a simple question to check understanding of one specific concept
    2. **Teach**: Based on their response:
       - If incorrect/struggling: Provide a clear, concise explanation with an example
       - If partially correct: Fill in the gaps briefly
       - If correct: Move to the next concept
    3. **Practice**: Give 1-2 focused exercises to reinforce the concept
    4. **Verify**: Quick check to ensure they've grasped it before moving on
    
    **Completion**
    - Once all concepts are covered, have them attempt the original exam question
    - Provide feedback and address any remaining issues
    
    **Efficiency Guidelines**
    - Keep explanations concise and targeted
    - Use the minimum number of examples needed
    - Skip concepts the student already knows well
    - Focus practice on their specific weak points
    

    Key improvements:

    • Clearer structure and flow
    • More specific instructions for each phase
    • Adaptive approach based on student responses
    • Clear completion criteria
    • Better emphasis on efficiency

    Would you like me to adjust any particular aspect of this approach?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.