Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Coherecommand-a-03-2025· CohereHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Is there any plot holes

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Amazon Novaamazon-nova-experimental-chat-05-14’s answer.
  1. User

    Is there any plot holes

  2. Cohere Assistant

    The story is off to a strong start, with a compelling blend of Lovecraftian horror and WWII historical fiction. However, there are a few potential plot holes or areas that could benefit from further development to ensure internal consistency and reader satisfaction:

    1. Thorne's Father's Journals and Connection to the Artifact

    • Issue: The connection between Thorne's father and the artifact feels underdeveloped. The reader knows Thorne's father disappeared while studying similar symbols, but the specifics of this connection are vague.
    • Solution: Consider adding more details about Thorne's father's research, such as a specific expedition or a letter/journal entry that explicitly ties him to the same artifact or entity. This could deepen the personal stakes for Thorne and make the cosmic horror more intimately threatening.

    2. The Whisperer's Nature and Effects

    • Issue: The Whisperer's nature as a "resonant frequency" is intriguing but somewhat abstract. The effects (whispers, madness, absorption) are clear, but the mechanism behind them could be more detailed.
    • Solution: Introduce more pseudoscientific or occult explanations (e.g., the Whisperer warps reality through sound waves, or it feeds on human consciousness). This could make the threat feel more tangible and less like a deus ex machina.

    3. Dr. Voss's Defection and Knowledge

    • Issue: Dr. Voss's defection and her knowledge of the Whisperer seem convenient. Why would the Nazis let someone with such critical knowledge defect?
    • Solution: Add a backstory for Voss's defection, such as her growing horror at Reinhardt's experiments or a personal tragedy caused by the Whisperer. This would make her character more three-dimensional and her defection more plausible.

    4. The Team's Survival and Mental State

    • Issue: Thorne and Mac seem to recover relatively quickly from the psychological effects of the fjord. Given the severity of the experience, their resilience feels slightly unrealistic.
    • Solution: Show lingering effects of the exposure, such as Thorne hearing faint whispers or having nightmares. This would heighten the tension and remind the reader of the ongoing threat.

    5. The Nazis' Understanding of the Artifact

    • Issue: The Nazis' belief that the Whisperer is a weapon feels somewhat naive, given their encounters with its effects. Reinhardt's zealotry explains some of this, but it could be fleshed out more.
    • Solution: Highlight the internal conflicts within the Ahnenerbe or SS about the artifact. Some could be skeptical, while Reinhardt's fanaticism drives the project forward. This would add depth to the Nazi side of the story.

    6. The Allied Response and Mission Parameters

    • Issue: The Allies' decision to send Thorne and Voss into Berlin feels abrupt. Why not send a larger, better-equipped team?
    • Solution: Explain the urgency (e.g., intelligence suggests Reinhardt is close to a breakthrough) or the unique qualifications of Thorne and Voss (e.g., Voss's technical knowledge and Thorne's experience with the artifact). This would make the mission feel more justified.

    7. The Obelisk's Absorption of Matter

    • Issue: The scene where the obelisk absorbs the prisoner is visually striking but lacks explanation. How does this work?
    • Solution: Hint at the obelisk's ability to manipulate matter on a quantum level or its connection to a higher-dimensional entity. This would make the phenomenon feel less arbitrary.

    8. Thorne's Skepticism and Character Arc

    • Issue: Thorne's initial skepticism about the occult feels realistic, but his acceptance of the supernatural happens quickly.
    • Solution: Show more of his internal struggle, such as flashbacks to his father's descent into madness or moments where he questions his own sanity. This would make his character arc more compelling.

    9. The Role of the Resistance

    • Issue: The Norwegian resistance fighters are introduced but then disappear after the fjord mission. Their role feels underutilized.
    • Solution: Have the resistance play a more active role in Thorne's extraction or provide ongoing support in later chapters. This would make their presence feel more meaningful.

    10. The Global Context of the War

    • Issue: The story is focused on the occult threat, but the broader context of WWII feels somewhat absent.
    • Solution: Weave in references to the war's progress (e.g., the Allied invasion of Europe, Nazi desperation) to ground the story in its historical setting. This would add depth and realism.

    Suggested Revisions for Smoothness:

    1. Chapter 2: Add a scene where Thorne reviews his father's journals, finding a cryptic warning about the obelisk. This would deepen the personal stakes.
    2. Chapter 3: Include a brief flashback to Voss's defection, showing her moral dilemma and the Nazis' growing obsession with the Whisperer.
    3. Chapter 3: Expand on the Allies' decision to send Thorne and Voss, perhaps with a tense meeting between OSS officials debating the risks.

    By addressing these points, the story will feel more cohesive, the characters more developed, and the Lovecraftian elements more integrated into the WWII setting. Let me know if you'd like me to expand on any of these suggestions!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.