in my mysql enviroment, the id numbers are shown with , seperator, so when I advance…
- User
in my mysql enviroment, the id numbers are shown with , seperator, so when I advance copy them to return a list of doc ids as a string with , separator between each document id, the result would not be good, what u suggest to resolve the issue
- Assistant
There are two different “places” where the commas can sneak in, and the fix depends on which of them is responsible:
A. the MySQL server / query (rare)
B. the client tool you’re using to look at the result set (very common: Workbench, phpMyAdmin, DataGrip, HeidiSQL, DBeaver, Excel-like grids, etc.)──────────────────────────────────
A) If the query itself is adding the commas
────────────────────────────────── That would only happen if you (or someone before you) wrote the query withFORMAT()or similar, e.g.SELECT FORMAT(id,0) AS id -- turns 12345 into 12,345 FROM documents;or
SELECT LPAD(id,10,',') … -- anything that injects commasHow to fix ☑️
• Remove theFORMAT(),LPAD(),CONCAT(',', id, …)etc.
• Or, if you need the formatted version for a report but now want the plain one for your list, just cast the number to a string:SELECT CAST(id AS CHAR) AS id_plain FROM documents;──────────────────────────────────
B) If it’s only the client UI that shows the commas (most likely)
────────────────────────────────── MySQL stores numbers without any thousands separator. Many GUI tools display them with a thousands separator for readability, and when you copy-paste the grid you end up with 1,234 instead of 1234.
The server never sent the commas; your client added them on the fly.Three ways to deal with this:
1️⃣ Tell the client not to format numbers
• MySQL Workbench → Preferences → SQL Editor → Data Formatter → un-tick “Show Thousands Separator”.
• phpMyAdmin → Settings (gear icon) → “Numbers” → Set “Thousands separator” to blank.
• DBeaver → Preferences → Result Sets → Data Format → un-tick “Use thousands separator”.
(Every tool has an equivalent switch; search for “thousand(s) separator” or “data formatter”.)2️⃣ Run a “helper” query that already gives you the final comma-separated list you want (no UI formatting involved):
-- Make sure you’re on the right DB first USE my_database; -- Increase length if you expect a very long list SET SESSION group_concat_max_len = 1000000; SELECT GROUP_CONCAT(id ORDER BY id SEPARATOR ',') AS doc_id_list FROM documents WHERE … ; -- your filtering conditionResult: a single row with
doc_id_list -------------------------- 1234,5678,9012,3456,…Just copy that text—no formatting, no thousand separators.
3️⃣ Strip the commas in SQL before you copy (quick & dirty)
SELECT REPLACE(GROUP_CONCAT(id), ',', '') -- removes thousands sep’s FROM ( SELECT FORMAT(id,0) AS id -- whatever your tool is sending FROM documents ) AS t;But in practice option 1 or 2 is cleaner.
──────────────────────────────────
Quick checklist 🔍
────────────────────────────────── ⛨ If you SELECTidin the mysql CLI (mysql -u user …) and you don’t see commas ➜ it’s the client UI, not MySQL.
⛨ If you see commas even in plain CLI ➜ your query is formatting them.──────────────────────────────────
Recommended solution (TL;DR)
────────────────────────────────── UseGROUP_CONCATto let MySQL build the comma-separated string for you:SET SESSION group_concat_max_len = 1000000; -- if needed SELECT GROUP_CONCAT(id ORDER BY id) AS ids FROM documents WHERE … ;or just disable the “show thousands separator” option in your GUI tool.
Either way, you’ll be able to copy a clean list like:1,2,3,4,5,6instead of
1,234, 5,678, …Happy querying! 🎉
- User
im using dbeaver Version 24.1.2.202407071610
- Assistant
Below are three practical ways to get rid of the thousands-separator in DBeaver 24.1.2 so you can copy a clean, comma-separated list of IDs.
━━━━━━━━━━
- Turn the separator off globally
━━━━━━━━━━
-
Open the Preferences dialog
• Windows/Linux :Window ▸ Preferences
• macOS :DBeaver ▸ Preferences -
Navigate to
Editors ▸ Data Editor ▸ Data Formats
(in some themes it isEditors ▸ Data Editor ▸ Formatting). -
In the right pane pick “Number” and UN-tick
▢ Use thousand separator / Use grouping -
Press “Apply and Close”.
-
Re-run your query (or just reopen the tab) → IDs show as
123456instead of123,456.
Tip: You can always re-enable the option if you miss the visual commas.
━━━━━━━━━━ 2) Toggle it only when you need to copy
━━━━━━━━━━ In the result-grid toolbar there is a small button that looks like1 000(tooltip: “Show thousands separator”).
Click it once → separators disappear.
Click again → they’re back.(If the toolbar is hidden, right-click the grid header and enable “Toolbar”.)
━━━━━━━━━━ 3) Let MySQL build the list for you (never formatted)
━━━━━━━━━━/* enlarge buffer if the list may be long */ SET SESSION group_concat_max_len = 1000000; SELECT GROUP_CONCAT(id ORDER BY id SEPARATOR ',') AS doc_id_list FROM documents -- your table WHERE …; -- your filterThe result is a single, ready-to-paste string:
doc_id_list ------------------------------ 1234,5678,9012,3456,…No GUI formatting can interfere, so this also works if you share the query with colleagues who use different tools.
━━━━━━━━━━ Which one should I use? ━━━━━━━━━━ • If you never want to see the thousands separator again → method 1 (global).
• If you like the separator for browsing but not for copying → method 2 (toggle).
• If you regularly need long lists and want to automate the process → method 3 (GROUP_CONCAT).Happy copy-pasting! 🎉
- Turn the separator off globally
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.