Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Let's say I have a convex function L that is not globally lipschitz on the whole domain…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-5-haiku-20241022’s answer.
  1. User

    Let's say I have a convex function L that is not globally lipschitz on the whole domain \Theta but Lipschitz on every \epsilon-shrinkage. I want an algorithm that can provably optimize such a function with the best possible rate. In 1D I know that computing the argmin and projecting it into an appropriate r_n-shrinkage where r_n\to 0 attains rate O(n^{-1/2-\alpha}) for any \alpha > 0, but I do not know if this translates to higher dimensions or if another algorithm is required

  2. Qwen Assistant

    You're considering a convex function LL that is:

    • Not globally Lipschitz over the entire domain Θ⊆Rd\Theta \subseteq \mathbb{R}^d,
    • Lipschitz on every ϵ\epsilon-shrinkage of Θ\Theta, i.e., on Θϵ={x∈Θ:dist(x,∂Θ)≥ϵ}\Theta_\epsilon = \{x \in \Theta : \text{dist}(x, \partial\Theta) \ge \epsilon\} for any ϵ>0\epsilon > 0,
    • And you're interested in optimization algorithms with provable convergence rates.

    You also mention that in 1D, projecting the argmin of the empirical loss onto a shrinking sequence Θrn\Theta_{r_n} with rn→0r_n \to 0 gives a rate better than O(n−1/2)O(n^{-1/2}), specifically O(n−1/2−α)O(n^{-1/2 - \alpha}) for any α>0\alpha > 0.

    Let’s unpack this and discuss how this idea might extend to higher dimensions, and what algorithms and guarantees exist in that setting.


    📌 Key Concepts

    1. Lipschitz Continuity on Shrunk Domains

    This is a common structure in nonparametric statistics and shape-constrained estimation. For example:

    • The log-likelihood of a convex density is not Lipschitz near the boundary but is Lipschitz on compact subsets.
    • Similarly, maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) over convex densities or shape-constrained models often involves such structure.

    2. Empirical Risk Minimization (ERM) and Projections

    In 1D, you mentioned that projecting the ERM onto a shrinking domain Θrn\Theta_{r_n} improves the rate. This is related to localized complexity and entropy conditions.


    🧠 Intuition Behind the 1D Result

    In 1D:

    • The function LL is not globally Lipschitz, so the usual ERM bounds (which depend on global Lipschitz constants) don't apply directly.
    • But if you shrink the domain slightly (removing a small neighborhood of the boundary), the function becomes Lipschitz there.
    • Then, projecting the ERM onto this shrunken domain controls the complexity and allows for faster rates.

    The key idea is that the empirical process is well-behaved on compact subsets, and by shrinking the domain you avoid pathological behavior near the boundary.


    📐 Extension to Higher Dimensions

    In higher dimensions, similar ideas apply, but the geometry becomes more complex. Here are the main considerations:


    ✅ Possible Algorithms in Higher Dimensions

    1. Projected Empirical Risk Minimization (ERM)

    Let’s generalize your 1D idea:

    • Define a sequence of shrunk domains Θn=Θrn\Theta_n = \Theta_{r_n}, where rn→0r_n \to 0 as n→∞n \to \infty,
    • Define the projected ERM: θ^n=arg⁡min⁡θ∈ΘnL^n(θ)\hat{\theta}_n = \arg\min_{\theta \in \Theta_n} \hat{L}_n(\theta) where L^n(θ)\hat{L}_n(\theta) is the empirical loss.

    If LL is convex and Lipschitz on each Θn\Theta_n, and Θn↑Θ\Theta_n \uparrow \Theta as n→∞n \to \infty, then under suitable entropy conditions, you can show that:

    L(θ^n)−inf⁡θ∈ΘL(θ)=O(n−1/2−α)L(\hat{\theta}_n) - \inf_{\theta \in \Theta} L(\theta) = O(n^{-1/2 - \alpha})

    for some α>0\alpha > 0, even in higher dimensions.


    2. Stochastic Gradient Descent (SGD) with Shrinking Projections

    Alternatively, you can use projected stochastic gradient descent (SGD) where at each step you project onto a shrinking domain Θn\Theta_n.

    • At iteration tt, project the iterate onto Θt\Theta_t,
    • This ensures that the iterates stay in a region where LL is Lipschitz,
    • Under convexity and suitable noise conditions, SGD can achieve similar rates as ERM.

    This is especially useful when the full ERM is computationally expensive.


    3. Mirror Descent or Dual Averaging with Shrinking Domains

    These are generalizations of gradient descent for non-Euclidean geometries and can be used with shrinking domains as well.

    They are particularly useful when the domain has a non-Euclidean structure (e.g., simplex, entropy geometry, etc.).


    📈 Rate Analysis in Higher Dimensions

    In general, the rate of convergence for ERM over a class F\mathcal{F} is governed by:

    Excess risk≲log⁡N(F,ϵ)n\text{Excess risk} \lesssim \sqrt{\frac{\log \mathcal{N}(\mathcal{F}, \epsilon)}{n}}

    where N\mathcal{N} is the covering number.

    If LL is only Lipschitz on Θn\Theta_n, and the covering number of Θn\Theta_n grows polynomially in 1rn\frac{1}{r_n}, then:

    • The local entropy becomes manageable,
    • And you can get faster rates by choosing rnr_n to trade off between approximation error and estimation error.

    For instance, if the covering number of Θr\Theta_r is ∼r−d\sim r^{-d}, and the approximation error is ∼r\sim r, then balancing:

    rn+rn−dn⇒rn=n−1/(d+2)r_n + \sqrt{\frac{r_n^{-d}}{n}} \quad \Rightarrow \quad r_n = n^{-1/(d+2)}

    yields a rate of:

    O(n−1/(d+2))O(n^{-1/(d+2)})

    This is slower than the 1D result you mentioned, but it's a dimension-dependent rate, which is unavoidable without additional structure.

    However, if the function LL has higher smoothness, or the domain has special structure (e.g., convexity, entropy constraints), you can get faster rates even in high dimensions.


    🧮 Summary

    DimensionAlgorithmRateNotes
    1DProjected ERMO(n−1/2−α)O(n^{-1/2 - \alpha})Any α>0\alpha > 0
    dd-DProjected ERM or SGDO(n−1/(d+2))O(n^{-1/(d+2)})General convex case
    dd-DSmooth LLO(n−1/2)O(n^{-1/2})If Lipschitz gradients
    dd-DWith structure (e.g., entropy)O(n−1/2−α)O(n^{-1/2 - \alpha})Requires special conditions

    🧠 Final Thoughts

    • Yes, the 1D idea does extend to higher dimensions, but the rate degrades with dimension unless you have additional structure.
    • The projected ERM or projected SGD approach with shrinking domains is a valid and effective strategy.
    • To achieve faster than O(n−1/2)O(n^{-1/2}) rates in high dimensions, you need stronger assumptions on LL or Θ\Theta (e.g., smoothness, entropy constraints, self-concordance, etc.).

    🔍 References

    Here are some relevant references for further reading:

    • van de Geer, S. (2000). Empirical Processes in M-Estimation.
    • Wainwright, M. J. (2019). High-Dimensional Statistics: A Non-Asymptotic Viewpoint.
    • Chatterjee, S. (2014). A new perspective on least squares under convex constraint.
    • Balázs, G., György, A., & Szepesvári, C. (2015). Near-optimal max-affine estimators for convex regression.

    Let me know if you'd like help applying this to a specific function or optimization problem!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.