Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

What is better, 6 tanukis or 5 tanukis and 1 nihonzaru in grow a garden

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14’s answer.
  1. User

    What is better, 6 tanukis or 5 tanukis and 1 nihonzaru in grow a garden

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Excellent question! This gets to the core strategy of how to efficiently run your garden in the game.

    For almost every situation and player, 5 tanukis and 1 nihonzaru is the better choice.

    Here’s the quick breakdown, followed by a more detailed explanation.

    Quick Answer (TL;DR)

    • 6 Tanukis: This setup has the highest potential to make money, but only if you are actively watering all your flowers yourself, constantly. If you stop watering, the flowers dry up and your 6 tanukis have nothing to do.
    • 5 Tanukis + 1 Nihonzaru: This setup provides consistent, automated income. The nihonzaru (macaque) keeps your flowers watered, ensuring your 5 tanukis always have pollen to collect. This is far more efficient, especially for AFK (Away From Keyboard) play.

    Detailed Breakdown

    Let's look at the role of each animal and how the two setups compare.

    The Role of Each Animal

    • Tanuki (狸): The income generator. It collects pollen from flowers and takes it to the hive to be converted into honey, which you sell for money. More tanukis = more pollen collection.
    • Nihonzaru (日本猿 - Japanese Macaque): The support unit. It acts as an automatic gardener, watering your flowers. Watered flowers produce pollen continuously. Unwatered flowers dry out and stop producing pollen.

    Analyzing the Setups

    Scenario A: 6 Tanukis (The "Brute Force" Method)

    • Pros:

      • Maximum Collection Power: With six animals all dedicated to collecting pollen, you have the highest possible rate of income generation in a perfectly maintained garden.
    • Cons:

      • Requires Constant Manual Labor: You are the gardener. You must run around watering every single flower patch yourself. This is tedious and time-consuming.
      • Huge Inefficiency: The moment a flower dries out, any tanuki assigned to it becomes idle. If you get distracted or leave the game for a few minutes, your entire production line can grind to a halt.
      • Terrible for AFK: This setup is completely useless if you want to leave the game running to earn money while you're away. You'll come back to a dry garden and no new income.

    Scenario B: 5 Tanukis and 1 Nihonzaru (The "Automated" Method)

    • Pros:

      • Automation & Consistency: The nihonzaru ensures your flowers are always watered. This creates a steady, reliable stream of pollen for your 5 tanukis to collect.
      • AFK-Friendly: This is the ideal setup for passive income. You can leave the game running and know that your garden will continue to produce honey without any input from you.
      • Frees You Up: With watering taken care of, you can focus on more important tasks like planting higher-tier flowers, rearranging your garden, completing quests, or just relaxing.
      • Higher Overall Profit: While the peak collection rate is slightly lower (5 collectors vs 6), the actual profit over time will be much higher because there is zero downtime from dry flowers.
    • Cons:

      • Slightly Lower Peak Potential: In a theoretical world where you could water every plant instantly, this setup would be about 17% slower at collecting pollen than the 6-tanuki setup. However, this perfect scenario is impossible to maintain.

    Final Verdict

    Think of the nihonzaru not as a replacement for a tanuki, but as a force multiplier. The work it does by keeping the flowers alive allows the other five tanukis to work at 100% efficiency, 100% of the time.

    The loss of one pollen collector is a tiny price to pay for having a fully automated and consistently productive garden.

    Go with 5 tanukis and 1 nihonzaru. You will make more money, save yourself a lot of tedious work, and be able to effectively earn money while AFK.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.