Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Metallama-4-maverick-03-26-experimental· MetaHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Lets assume I hold a zero coupon sovereign bond with 10 years to maturity and I hedge it…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-7-sonnet-20250219’s answer.
  1. User

    Lets assume I hold a zero coupon sovereign bond with 10 years to maturity and I hedge it now with a short forward sale. What is the net return of the combined position at maturity?

  2. Meta Assistant

    A lovely question in fixed income!

    Let's break it down step by step.

    Assumptions:

    1. You hold a zero-coupon sovereign bond (ZCB) with 10 years to maturity. This means:
      • You bought the bond at a discount to its face value (also called par value, e.g., $100).
      • There are no coupon payments over the 10-year life of the bond.
      • At maturity (in 10 years), the bond will pay its face value (e.g., $100) with no interest.
    2. You hedge this bond position now (at time 0) with a short forward sale. This means:
      • You enter into a forward contract to sell the bond (or an equivalent notional amount) at a predetermined price (the forward price, (K)) at maturity (in 10 years).
      • Since it's a short forward, you're committing to sell the bond in the future.

    Notation:

    • (P_0): Today's price (time 0) of the 10-year zero-coupon bond.
    • (F_0): Forward price (at time 0) for selling the bond at maturity (time 10). This is the price (K) agreed upon today for the future sale.
    • (Z(0,10)): The 10-year zero-coupon discount factor at time 0. This is the factor by which you'd discount $1 received in 10 years to get its present value. Essentially, (P_0 = 100 \times Z(0,10)).
    • (FV): Face value of the bond = $100 (assumed for simplicity).

    Step 1: Understand the Zero-Coupon Bond's Payoff at Maturity

    At maturity (time 10), the zero-coupon bond pays its face value: $100.

    Step 2: Understand the Short Forward Sale's Payoff at Maturity

    In the forward contract, you've agreed to sell the bond (or equivalent notional) at the forward price (F_0) at time 10.

    The forward price (F_0) is determined today (time 0) using the cost-of-carry relationship, which for a zero-coupon sovereign bond simplifies to:

    [ F_0 = \frac{P_0}{Z(0,10)} = \frac{100 \times Z(0,10)}{Z(0,10)} = 100 ]

    Why? Because there are no carry costs (no coupons to reinvest, no funding costs for a sovereign bond in this idealized case). The forward price is simply the face value of the bond.

    Intuition: If you buy the bond today for (P_0) and hold it 10 years, you'll get $100. The forward price is set so that there's no arbitrage: if (F_0 < 100), I'd buy the bond and short the forward, guaranteeing a profit. If (F_0 > 100), I'd short the bond and buy the forward. Equilibrium (\Rightarrow F_0 = 100).

    Step 3: Payoffs at Maturity (Year 10)

    1. From the Zero-Coupon Bond: You receive $100 (the face value).
    2. From the Short Forward Contract: You deliver the bond (or equivalent) and receive (F_0 = 100).

    Here's the key insight:

    • You get $100 from the maturing bond.
    • You get $100 from the forward sale (because (F_0 = 100)).

    Net Cash Flow at Maturity:

    [ \underbrace{+100}{\text{Bond matures}} + \underbrace{+100 - 100}{\text{Forward settlement}} = +100 ]

    The (+100 - 100) from the forward comes from:

    • You deliver the bond (worth $100)
    • And receive $100 (the forward price (F_0)).

    Net result: You're left with $100.

    Interpretation:

    You started with a bond worth (P_0) (e.g., $46.32 if the 10-year yield is 8%).

    By hedging with a short forward, you've locked in the sale price at $100.

    At maturity:

    • The bond pays $100.
    • The forward contract means you "sell" that 100for...100 for... 100.

    Net return of the combined position:

    Since you started with (P_0) (the bond's present value) and ended with $100, your net return is:

    [ \text{Net Return} = \frac{100 - P_0}{P_0} ]

    This is exactly the yield to maturity (YTM) of the bond at inception (when you bought it 10 years ago).

    Why? Because the YTM (y) of a zero-coupon bond is defined as:

    [ P_0 = \frac{100}{(1 + y)^{10}} ]

    Rearranging:

    [ 1 + y = \left(\frac{100}{P_0}\right)^{1/10} ]

    [ y = \left(\frac{100}{P_0}\right)^{1/10} - 1 ]

    And the return over 10 years is:

    [ \frac{100 - P_0}{P_0} = \frac{100}{P_0} - 1 ]

    This compounded annually gives back (y).

    In short (heh):

    By shorting the forward, you've locked in the initial YTM as your net return.

    No interest rate risk, no surprise: the hedge neutralizes any potential deviation from the yield you implicitly contracted for when buying the bond.

    Example numbers:

    If (P_0 = 46.32) (implying 8% YTM), then:

    [ \text{Net Return} = \frac{100 - 46.32}{46.32} \approx 115.9% ]

    Over 10 years, this compounds to ~8% per annum (the original YTM).

    Conclusion:

    Hedging a zero-coupon bond with a short forward locks in the initial yield as your return. At maturity:

    • The bond pays $100.
    • The forward sale nets zero ((+100 - 100)).
    • Your total proceeds = $100.
    • Return = Initial YTM.

    Perfectly hedged. No surprise. Just the math of arbitrage.

    Now go impress your fixed income friends!

  3. User

    How does the math change if I use rolling 6m futures to hedge the bond

  4. Meta Assistant

    A fantastic follow-up question!

    Now we're venturing into the dynamic hedging territory, where things get a bit more nuanced.

    Scenario Recap:

    1. You still hold that 10-year zero-coupon sovereign bond (maturing in 10 years, face value $100).
    2. Instead of a single 10-year forward (which we showed locks in the initial YTM), you decide to hedge using rolling 6-month futures contracts on the same underlying bond (or a closely correlated instrument).

    What does "rolling" mean?

    • You enter a 6-month futures contract today (time 0) to sell the bond (notional $100).
    • 6 months later, that futures contract expires. You close it out (settle the profit/loss) and immediately enter a new 6-month futures contract (with a new futures price).
    • You repeat this process every 6 months for 10 years: 20 rollovers (since (10 \text{ years} \times 2 \text{ rolls/year} = 20 \text{ rolls})).

    Why roll futures?

    In practice, long-dated futures (e.g., 10-year) might be illiquid or have wider bid-ask spreads than shorter-dated ones. Rolling futures is a common hedging strategy for:

    1. Maintaining liquidity.
    2. Adjusting to changing yield curve dynamics (more on this later).

    Notation & Assumptions:

    • (F(t, t+0.5)): The 6-month futures price at time (t) for delivery at (t+0.5) (i.e., 6 months later).
    • (P_t): The spot price of the 10-year zero-coupon bond at time (t).
    • (y_t): The 10-year yield at time (t). This drives (P_t = \frac{100}{(1 + y_t)^{10-t}}).
    • (\text{PV01}_t): The present value of a basis point (PV01) of the bond at time (t). Measures sensitivity to yield changes.
    • (DV01_f): The dollar value of a basis point for the 6-month futures contract (slightly different from PV01 due to futures margining).

    Key Difference from the Single Forward:

    1. In the single 10-year forward, you locked in (F_0 = 100) (since (F_0 = P_0 / Z(0,10) = 100)). No uncertainty.
    2. With rolling 6-month futures:
      • Each (F(t, t+0.5)) is reset every 6 months based on prevailing market conditions (yields, expectations).
      • Yield changes between rollovers expose you to basis risk and roll yield.

    The Math of Rolling Futures Hedge

    Let's analyze the cash flows over a single 6-month roll, then generalize.

    At Each Roll (every 6 months):

    1. Futures Contract Expiry (Settlement):
      • Suppose at time (t) (e.g., 6 months from now), the then-prevailing 6-month futures price was (F(t-0.5, t)).
      • You sold the futures at (F(t-0.5, t)) (agreed 6 months prior).
      • Now (time (t)), the new spot price of the bond is (P_t).
      • Futures settlement (mark-to-market): You receive (F(t-0.5, t) - F(t, t+0.5)).
        • If yields rose ((P_t < P_{t-0.5})), (F(t-0.5, t) < F(t, t+0.5)), you pay (loss).
        • If yields fell ((P_t > P_{t-0.5})), (F(t-0.5, t) > F(t, t+0.5)), you receive (gain).
    2. Immediately Re-Hedge:
      • Enter a new 6-month futures contract to sell at (F(t, t+0.5)).

    Cumulative P&L from Rolling Futures

    Over 10 years (20 rolls), your total futures P&L is:

    [ \sum_{i=1}^{20} \left[ F(t_{i-1}, t_i) - F(t_i, t_{i+0.5}) \right] ]

    where (t_i = 0.5, 1, 1.5, \dots, 10).

    Bond's Natural Payoff (still $100 at maturity)

    At (t = 10), the bond still pays $100.

    Net Position at Maturity ((t = 10)):

    [ \underbrace{100}{\text{Bond payoff}} + \underbrace{\sum{i=1}^{20} \left[ F(t_{i-1}, t_i) - F(t_i, t_{i+0.5}) \right]}_{\text{Cumulative futures P&L}} ]

    The Million-Dollar Question:

    Does this cumulative futures P&L replicate the locked-in return we got with the single 10-year forward?

    Spoiler: Not exactly. Here's why:

    1. Yield Curve Shifts ≠ Parallel

    If the yield curve shifts non-parallel (e.g., short rates change differently than long rates), then:

    • The 10-year bond price (P_t) moves based on (y_t) (10-year yield).
    • But 6-month futures reflect near-term expectations (which may not match 10-year movements).

    Basis Risk emerges: (F(t, t+0.5)) doesn't perfectly track (P_t)'s sensitivity (duration/maturity mismatch).

    2. Roll Yield (aka "Convexity Cost")

    Each roll exposes you to roll yield:

    • If yields are rising (bond prices falling), you lose on each futures settlement (since (F(t-0.5, t) < F(t, t+0.5))).
    • If yields are falling (bond prices rising), you gain.

    Expectations Hypothesis suggests: [ F(t, t+0.5) \approx \mathbb{E}t[P{t+0.5}] ] (the futures price ≈ expected future spot price).

    Under pure expectations theory (no term premium), roll yield ≈ 0 on average.

    BUT, if there's a term premium (long-term bonds yield more than expected future short rates), then:

    • Upward-sloping curve (normal): Futures prices (F(t, t+0.5)) are biased low (you "pay" to roll).
    • Inverted curve: Futures prices are biased high (you "earn" from rolling).

    3. Mark-to-Market Volatility

    With daily margining, interim futures P&L is cash settled every day (not just at expiry). This introduces:

    • Variation margin cash flows (funding costs if yields move against you).
    • Compounding effects: Reinvestment risk on gains/losses.

    Theoretical Result (under simplifying assumptions):

    If:

    1. Expectations hypothesis holds (no term premium).
    2. Parallel yield curve shifts (duration-matched hedging).
    3. Zero transaction costs.

    Then, in theory, the rolling futures strategy should approximate the same net return as the single 10-year forward (i.e., the initial YTM).

    Why? Because futures prices, on average, embed the expected path of bond prices (under risk-neutral measure).

    But in practice:

    • Term premia ≠ 0.
    • Curve twists happen.
    • Liquidity and bid-ask spreads differ across futures expiries.
    • Margining introduces frictions.

    So, your actual return will deviate from the initial YTM. You might:

    • Outperform if rates fall faster than expected (curve steepening helps your short futures rolls).
    • Underperform if rates rise (or if there's persistent roll yield "tax" under an upward-sloping curve).

    Simulation Example (Illustrative)

    Assume:

    • Initial 10-year yield = 3%.
    • (P_0 = 74.41) (10-year ZCB price).
    • You roll 6-month futures perfectly tracking the bond's DV01 (idealized hedge).

    Scenario 1: Yields Stay Flat (3% → 3% over 10 years)

    • Futures rolls ≈ zero-sum (small random noise).
    • Net result ≈ (100 - 74.41 = 25.59) (34.4% total return (\approx) 3% p.a.).

    Scenario 2: Yields Rise 1% (3% → 4% linearly over 10 years)

    • Each futures roll loses (selling low, buying higher).
    • Cumulative roll loss ≈ -5% of notional (illustrative).
    • Bond payoff = $100, but futures P&L drags: Net ≈ (100 - 5 - 74.41 = 20.59) (< 3% p.a.).

    Scenario 3: Yields Fall 1% (3% → 2%)

    • Each futures roll gains.
    • Cumulative roll gain ≈ +5% of notional.
    • Net ≈ (100 + 5 - 74.41 = 30.59) (> 3% p.a.).

    Takeaways:

    1. Rolling futures hedge ≠ Perfect lock-in. Basis risk, roll yield, and curve dynamics matter.
    2. If yield curve expectations are unbiased (no persistent term premia), rolling futures ≈ single forward (YTM return).
    3. In reality:
      • Upward-sloping curves penalize short futures rolls (roll yield "tax").
      • Steepening curves help your short hedge.
    4. Mark-to-market P&L volatility and funding costs ≠ 0.

    When to use rolling futures?

    • When long-dated forwards are illiquid or expensive.
    • If you expect yield curve twists and want dynamic exposure.
    • Accepting basis risk for operational simplicity (frequent, liquid rolls).

    TL;DR: Rolling 6-month futures to hedge a 10-year bond approximates (but doesn't perfectly replicate) the initial YTM return.

    Deviation drivers:

    • Term premium.
    • Curve reshaping.
    • Roll yield.
    • Liquidity frictions.

    Now, go dazzle your swaps desk with this nuanced beauty of dynamic hedging!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.