Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Metallama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct· MetaHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

example of steel beam with torsion design AISC- SI units?

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4.1-2025-04-14’s answer.
  1. User

    example of steel beam with torsion design AISC- SI units?

  2. Meta Assistant

    Here is an example of a steel beam design with torsion according to AISC (American Institute of Steel Construction) specifications, using SI units:

    Problem Statement

    Design a simply supported steel beam with a span of 6 meters, subjected to a uniformly distributed load of 10 kN/m and a concentrated torsional moment of 5 kN.m at mid-span. The beam is laterally supported at both ends. Use AISC specifications and SI units.

    Given Data

    • Span (L) = 6 m
    • Uniformly distributed load (w) = 10 kN/m
    • Concentrated torsional moment (T) = 5 kN.m
    • Steel grade: A992 ( Fy = 345 MPa, Fu = 450 MPa)
    • Beam section: W310x33 (a commonly used section in Canada and the US, with a depth of 313 mm, a flange width of 166 mm, and a weight of 33 kg/m)

    Step 1: Calculate the factored loads

    Using the AISC load combinations, we can calculate the factored loads:

    • Factored uniformly distributed load (wu) = 1.2 x 10 kN/m = 12 kN/m
    • Factored concentrated torsional moment (Tu) = 1.6 x 5 kN.m = 8 kN.m

    Step 2: Calculate the bending moment and shear force

    Using basic beam theory, we can calculate the bending moment and shear force:

    • Maximum bending moment (M) = wu x L^2 / 8 = 12 kN/m x (6 m)^2 / 8 = 54 kN.m
    • Maximum shear force (V) = wu x L / 2 = 12 kN/m x 6 m / 2 = 36 kN

    Step 3: Check the beam section for bending

    Using the AISC specifications, we can check the beam section for bending:

    • Plastic section modulus (Zx) = 641 x 10^3 mm^3 (from AISC manual)
    • Moment capacity (Mn) = Fy x Zx = 345 MPa x 641 x 10^3 mm^3 = 221 kN.m
    • Factored moment resistance (Mr) = 0.9 x Mn = 0.9 x 221 kN.m = 199 kN.m
    • Check: M / Mr = 54 kN.m / 199 kN.m = 0.27 < 1.0 (OK)

    Step 4: Check the beam section for shear

    Using the AISC specifications, we can check the beam section for shear:

    • Shear area (Aw) = d x tw = 313 mm x 6.6 mm = 2068 mm^2 (from AISC manual)
    • Shear capacity (Vn) = 0.6 x Fy x Aw = 0.6 x 345 MPa x 2068 mm^2 = 428 kN
    • Factored shear resistance (Vr) = 0.9 x Vn = 0.9 x 428 kN = 385 kN
    • Check: V / Vr = 36 kN / 385 kN = 0.09 < 1.0 (OK)

    Step 5: Check the beam section for torsion

    Using the AISC specifications, we can check the beam section for torsion:

    • Torsional constant (J) = 134 x 10^3 mm^4 (from AISC manual)
    • Torsional capacity (Tn) = (J / (L/2)) x (Fy / √3) = (134 x 10^3 mm^4 / (6 m / 2)) x (345 MPa / √3) = 12.3 kN.m
    • Factored torsional resistance (Tr) = 0.9 x Tn = 0.9 x 12.3 kN.m = 11.1 kN.m
    • Check: Tu / Tr = 8 kN.m / 11.1 kN.m = 0.72 < 1.0 (OK)

    Step 6: Check the interaction between bending and torsion

    Using the AISC specifications, we can check the interaction between bending and torsion:

    • Check: (M / Mr)^2 + (Tu / Tr)^2 = (0.27)^2 + (0.72)^2 = 0.58 < 1.0 (OK)

    The W310x33 beam section is adequate for the given loads, satisfying both bending and torsion requirements according to AISC specifications.

    Keep in mind that this is a simplified example and actual design may require additional checks and considerations, such as deflection, lateral-torsional buckling, and local buckling. Consult the AISC specifications and relevant design codes for more detailed guidance.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.