Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o3-mini· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

What does smoothing factor do in Blender's smooth modifier?

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Qwenqwen3-30b-a3b’s answer.
  1. User

    What does smoothing factor do in Blender's smooth modifier?

  2. Assistant

    In Blender's Smooth modifier, the smoothing factor controls how much each vertex's position is shifted toward the smoothed (averaged) location. In other words, it scales the displacement that is computed by the smoothing algorithm:

    • If the smoothing factor is low (e.g., near 0): The vertices will only move slightly toward their averaged positions. This produces a gentle or subtle smoothing effect.
    • If the smoothing factor is high (e.g., up to 1): The vertices will move much more toward—and eventually fully to—the averaged positions, resulting in a more pronounced smoothing effect.

    This factor essentially blends between the original geometry and the fully smoothed geometry. When used in combination with multiple iterations, even a small smoothing factor applied repeatedly can produce strong smoothing, while a high factor applied in a single iteration will have a more immediate and dramatic impact.

    This parameter thus gives you fine control over how “strongly” the smooth modifier affects your mesh.

  3. User

    How does it change a smooth modifier if the vertice's own position is averaged along with its neighbors?

  4. Assistant

    When Blender’s smooth modifier computes a new position for a vertex, it generally uses some form of averaging of the positions of nearby (neighboring) vertices. How the calculation is done—and what influence the vertex’s own current position has on that average—can significantly affect the smoothing result. Here’s how including the vertex’s own position (along with its neighbors) changes the behavior:

    1. Less Aggressive Smoothing:

      • Without Including Own Position: If the new position is computed solely from the neighbors’ positions, the vertex is moved entirely toward what the surrounding vertices “suggest.” This can lead to a more aggressive smoothing effect, especially on irregular or noisy geometry.
      • With Including Own Position: By also averaging in the vertex’s own current position, the computed average is pulled back closer to where the vertex originally was. This has a damping or stabilizing effect, making the smoothing more gentle. In effect, the vertex isn’t completely “taken over” by the neighbor positions; it retains a bit of its original identity.
    2. Control over Detail Preservation:
      When the vertex’s position contributes to the average, fine details or sharp features can be preserved better. Without self-inclusion, the vertex might shift too far toward the neighbor average, potentially erasing features that you might want to keep.

    3. Behavior with the Smoothing Factor:

      • The smoothing factor in Blender’s modifier determines the interpolation between the original and the computed (averaged) positions.
      • With self-inclusion, the computed average is already “closer” to the original vertex. When you then interpolate using the smoothing factor, the overall movement is more subdued. This combination gives you finer control over the degree of smoothing.
      • If you prefer a more uniform blending that completely follows the neighbors, excluding the vertex’s own position from the average could be the way to go.
    4. Mathematical Perspective:
      Conceptually, if you denote the vertex’s current position as P and the positions of its N neighbors as {P₁, P₂, …, Pₙ}, then:

      • Without self-inclusion:
        The new target might be computed as:
        Target = (P₁ + P₂ + … + Pₙ) / N
      • With self-inclusion:
        The new target becomes:
        Target = (P + P₁ + P₂ + … + Pₙ) / (N + 1)

      Notice that the inclusion of P in the average means that even if the neighbors are very different from P, the target won’t stray too far from P, leading to a smoother, less drastic change.

    In summary, averaging in the vertex’s own position along with its neighbors moderates the smoothing operation. It ensures that the vertex doesn’t march entirely in the direction dictated by the neighbors, making the overall effect less jarring and often resulting in a more controlled and aesthetically pleasing smoothing effect.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.