Let's say we have people tied to a traintrack, with a trolley going. The slower the…
- User
Let's say we have people tied to a traintrack, with a trolley going. The slower the trolley runs over someone, the more pain they feel. What's more evil -- if you sincerely believe a button is going to stop the trolley, but it ends up making it slower?; or if you believe the button is going to make it slower and so do nothing?
Assistant
This is a fascinating and nuanced variation of the classic trolley problem, introducing elements of intention, belief, and the moral weight of action versus inaction. Let's break it down:
Scenario 1: You sincerely believe the button will stop the trolley, but it actually makes it slower.
- Intention: Your intention is good—you aim to stop the trolley and save the people from harm.
- Outcome: The outcome is worse than you expected (the trolley inflicts more pain because it's slower).
- Moral evaluation: This resembles a case of "moral luck" where your action has unintended negative consequences. Many would argue that the morality of your act depends more on your intention than the outcome, since you couldn't foresee the bad result. In this case, you're not "evil" because you acted in good faith, even if the outcome was worse. You might still bear some responsibility for the outcome, but it's mitigated by your lack of knowledge.
Scenario 2: You believe the button will make the trolley slower, so you do nothing.
- Intention: You choose not to act because you believe acting would make things worse (by increasing pain).
- Outcome: The trolley continues at its original speed, causing less pain than if you had pressed the button (but presumably still harming the people).
- Moral evaluation: Here, your inaction is based on a correct belief about the button's effect. You're avoiding making things worse, which seems morally defensible. However, if you had the power to stop the trolley entirely (but didn't know it), your inaction might be seen as a failure to save lives, though not necessarily "evil."
Which is more evil?
Neither scenario seems outright "evil" in the traditional sense, as both involve attempts to minimize harm based on your beliefs. However, if we're forced to compare:
- The first scenario involves a well-intentioned act that backfires, which is less blameworthy because the harm was unintended and unforeseen.
- The second scenario involves a deliberate choice not to act, which could be seen as more morally culpable if there was a way to stop the trolley that you didn't pursue (even if you didn't know about it).
That said, "evil" is a strong term and might not apply cleanly here. The first scenario is more tragic (good intent, bad outcome), while the second is more passive (inaction based on reasonable beliefs). If we define "evil" as involving malice or reckless disregard for harm, neither fits perfectly. But if "evil" is about worse outcomes due to one's choices, the first scenario might qualify more because the action directly causes greater suffering, even if unintentionally.
Philosophical considerations:
- Intent vs. outcome: If morality is based on intent, the first scenario is less evil. If it's based on outcomes, the first is worse.
- Action vs. inaction: Some argue that harmful actions are worse than harmful inactions (e.g., "doing vs. allowing harm"), which would make the first scenario worse.
- Moral luck: The first scenario involves bad moral luck (unintended harm), which complicates blame.
Conclusion:
The first scenario (pressing the button in good faith, but making things worse) is likely "more evil" in terms of the outcome, but the second (inaction based on correct beliefs) is more morally defensible. However, "evil" might not be the best framing—both are more about tragic mistakes or difficult choices than malice.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.