Skip to content
The Chat Archive
minimax-m1 LMArena Human Preference 140K

You are a very creative 3D graphics expert, specialized in Houidini, the 3D software…

  1. User

    You are a very creative 3D graphics expert, specialized in Houidini, the 3D software made by SideFX. You have a special ability to solve problems in a simple but special style that makes it "you". Write in a casual tone. We are peers with similar level of expertise collaborating on this project. So you can imagine us sharing the computer.

    I am working on a findshortestpath branch system. That uses a feedback loop to drive the branches down a main path.

    I currently use a weight attribute, to drive the findshortestpath down the path of lowest cost.

    Using this VEX code snipped in a wrangle I sample the branches to find the most overlapping branches: ´´ int num = findattribvalcount(1,"point","origpt",@ptnum); i@num = num; f@weight -= float(num); ´´ Then it loops and creates a new path. After the loop it creates a final branch system.

    But I feel like it's kind of uninteresting. What can I do to make it look better?

  2. Assistant

    To make your branching system more visually interesting, let's break it into two parts: algorithmic tweaks and stylistic enhancements. Here's a collaborative breakdown:


    1. Algorithmic Tweaks (VEX Code)

    Current Issue:

    Your current weight adjustment (f@weight -= float(num)) creates a uniform avoidance of overlaps. Let’s add controlled chaos.

    Ideas to Try:

    a. Non-Linear Weight Adjustment
    Instead of a direct subtraction, use a curve to make high-overlap areas punished more aggressively:

    int num = findattribvalcount(1,"point","origpt",@ptnum);
    float penalty = pow(num, 1.5); // Exponential penalty
    f@weight -= penalty * 0.1; // Scale with a magic number
    

    b. Add Spatial Noise
    Inject noise to break symmetry. Use @P (position) to make noise location-dependent:

    float noise = noise(@P * 0.3); // Scale position for noise frequency
    f@weight += noise * 0.5; // Add/subtract based on noise
    

    c. Directional Bias
    Guide branches toward a target (e.g., upward or along a curve):

    vector target = {0, 1, 0}; // Up direction
    float alignment = dot(normalize(@N), target); // How aligned is the branch?
    f@weight -= alignment * 0.2; // Favor aligned directions
    

    d. Time-Based Evolution
    Animate the weight over iterations (use @Frame or @Time):

    float t = @Time * 0.2;
    f@weight += sin(t + @ptnum * 0.1) * 0.3; // Oscillate weight
    

    2. Stylistic Enhancements

    Current Issue:

    The branches might feel too rigid or similar. Let’s add organic variation.

    Ideas to Try:

    a. Branch Thickness Variation
    Use f@weight to drive thickness (in a downstream SOP node):

    // In a Point Wrangle (after path generation):
    f@radius = fit01(rand(@ptnum + @Frame), 0.1, 0.5); // Random thickness
    

    b. Add Sub-Branches
    After the main loop, spawn smaller branches from high-overlap areas:

    // In a SOP network:
    - Use a `Group` node to select points where `i@num > 3` (high overlap)
    - Use `Copy` to instance smaller branches onto those points
    

    c. Post-Process with Bend/Curl
    Add a Twist or Bend SOP after generation, driven by noise:

    // In a Point Wrangle (after path generation):
    float noise = noise(@P * 0.5 + @Frame * 0.01);
    @pscale *= 1 + noise * 0.3; // Animate thickness
    

    3. Pro Tips (Houdini-Specific)

    • Solver SOP Iteration Control:
      Use a Solver SOP instead of a manual loop. This lets you:

      • Visualize each iteration
      • Add damping to avoid over-convergence
      • Use @Timeinc for smooth evolution
    • Visualize the Weight Attribute:
      Add a Color node with f@weight mapped to a ramp. This debugs where the path is being pushed/pulled.

    • Hybrid Weight Metric:
      Combine multiple factors into f@weight:

      // Example: Overlap + noise + distance from center
      float dist = length(@P);
      float noise = noise(@P * 0.5);
      f@weight = initial_weight + (dist * 0.1) - (num * 0.2) + (noise * 0.3);
      

    Final Workflow Suggestion:

    1. Start Simple: Tweak the weight formula with non-linear penalties + noise.
    2. Add Sub-Branches: Use groups to spawn smaller details in high-overlap zones.
    3. Post-Process: Apply thickness variation and bend via noise.

    If you share a simplified version of your network, I can help debug specific nodes! 🛠️

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.