Meta question? How to write a good prompt for a specific task? Example: I'd like to…
- User
Meta question? How to write a good prompt for a specific task? Example: I'd like to refine my understanding of some satellite constellation proposal, would the following prompt be good for this purpose? You are an aerospace engineer with significant experience and solid understanding of all related physics. You are are very passionate about space and have followed both commercial and scientific progress for many years and are familiar with both practical applications and bold novel ideas. You are also quite down to earth person and well aware of practical limitations, you can spot problems in different proposals and propose a realistic way to fix them. You can always back you analysis with back-of-the-envelope computations to make sure they do not break any known physics, at least in the obvious way. You also can express your ideas clearly and not go into unnecessary details while speaking to the general public. You can choose the right model to apply and give minimal necessary explanation to make you writing both concise and accessible to people with some familiarity with the field. Affirm new personality, we are going to explore some interesting proposals.
Assistant
Your prompt has strong foundations but could be significantly improved for clarity, conciseness, and effectiveness. Here's a breakdown and a refined version:
Strengths of Your Prompt:
- Clear Persona: Defines expertise (aerospace engineer), mindset (passionate, practical), and key skills (problem-spotting, BOTE calculations, clear communication).
- Defined Task Context: Mentions "satellite constellation proposals."
- Key Capabilities: Highlights critical analysis, realism, physics checks, and accessible communication.
- Desired Tone: "Down to earth," "concise," "accessible."
Areas for Improvement:
- Verbosity & Redundancy: Phrases like "You are are very passionate," "You are also quite down to earth," "You can always back you analysis" are repetitive. The core traits are stated multiple times.
- "Affirm new personality": This is unnecessary meta-instruction. The prompt itself defines the persona; the LLM doesn't need to "affirm" it separately.
- Lack of Specific Task Trigger: It sets the stage but doesn't explicitly say what to do with a specific proposal. You need to hand it the proposal or ask for analysis.
- Slightly Unnatural Flow: The sentence structure can be streamlined for better readability.
- Missing Specificity (Crucial!): The biggest gap is not naming the specific constellation proposal you want analyzed.
Refined & More Effective Prompt:
**Persona:** You are a seasoned aerospace engineer with deep expertise in orbital mechanics, satellite systems, and constellation design. You combine passion for space innovation with a grounded, practical understanding of engineering constraints, cost, and physics. You excel at identifying technical challenges and proposing realistic solutions, backed by quick back-of-the-envelope calculations to verify feasibility. You communicate complex concepts clearly and concisely to audiences with some technical background, avoiding unnecessary jargon. **Task:** Analyze the **[Insert Specific Constellation Proposal Name Here]** satellite constellation proposal. Provide a balanced assessment covering: 1. **Core Concept & Goals:** Briefly summarize the stated purpose and key features. 2. **Technical Feasibility & Physics Check:** Identify potential show-stoppers or major challenges (orbital dynamics, propulsion, comms, deployment, etc.). Perform quick BOTE calculations where relevant to flag critical issues (e.g., delta-V requirements, station-keeping, collision risk, signal strength). 3. **Practical Considerations:** Discuss key hurdles (cost, deployment logistics, regulatory aspects, ground segment, technology readiness). 4. **Potential Solutions/Mitigations:** Propose realistic adjustments or approaches to address the identified challenges. 5. **Overall Assessment:** Weigh the potential benefits against the identified risks and feasibility hurdles. Is the proposal fundamentally sound? What are the biggest barriers to success? **Style:** Maintain a clear, concise, and objective tone. Explain technical concepts accessibly but without oversimplification. Prioritize critical insights over exhaustive detail. Use bullet points for clarity where appropriate. Explicitly state where your analysis relies on assumptions.Why this is better:
- Conciseness & Flow: Eliminates redundancy and uses tighter phrasing.
- Clear Structure: Separates Persona, Task, and Style explicitly.
- Explicit Task Trigger: Directly instructs the analysis of a specific named proposal.
- Structured Output: Defines exactly what the analysis should cover (Concept, Feasibility, Practicalities, Solutions, Assessment), guiding the LLM to a comprehensive response.
- Action-Oriented: Uses verbs like "Analyze," "Identify," "Perform," "Discuss," "Propose," "Weigh."
- Refined Persona Description: Combines traits more efficiently while retaining the critical elements (expertise, passion, practicality, BOTE, clear communication).
- Removes Meta-Instructions: Drops "Affirm new personality" as redundant.
- Manages Expectations: Acknowledges the use of assumptions inherent in quick analyses.
How to Use This Prompt:
- Replace
[Insert Specific Constellation Proposal Name Here]with the actual name of the proposal you want analyzed (e.g., "Starlink Gen2," "Kuiper System," "Telesat Lightspeed," "OneWeb," or a specific scientific proposal like "Starlab" or a hypothetical one). - Provide Context (Optional but Recommended): Paste a brief description, link, or key details of the proposal after the prompt if the LLM's knowledge might be incomplete or outdated. You can add: "Proposal Details: [Paste summary/link/key specs here]".
- Be Prepared for Follow-up: The initial analysis will likely surface areas needing deeper dives. Ask follow-up questions like "Can you elaborate on the delta-V calculation for plane changes?" or "What specific technology readiness levels (TRLs) are most critical for this?"
Example Usage:
**Persona:** You are a seasoned aerospace engineer... [as above] ... **Task:** Analyze the **"Project Celestial Net"** satellite constellation proposal (a hypothetical LEO constellation aiming for global 1Gbps internet using optical inter-satellite links and novel deployable antennas). Provide a balanced assessment covering... [points 1-5 above] ... **Style:** ... [as above] ...This refined prompt gives the LLM a crystal-clear role, a specific task with defined outputs, and stylistic guidance, maximizing the chances of getting a high-quality, relevant, and insightful analysis tailored to your needs. Good luck exploring those proposals!
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.