Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Where should I go to buy blackout curtains? I also am unsure if blinds can be as effective

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-5-sonnet-20241022’s answer.
  1. User

    Where should I go to buy blackout curtains? I also am unsure if blinds can be as effective

  2. Assistant

    1. Where to Shop for Black-Out Curtains

    If you like…Try these retailersWhy they’re handyTypical price range
    “See it in person” (big-box)• Home Depot / Lowe’s • Target • Walmart • IkeaStock sizes on display, you can feel fabric weight25–25 – 80 per panel
    Designer patterns & custom lengths• Pottery Barn • West Elm • AnthropologieStylish prints, wider width choices, better hardware80–80 – 200+ per panel
    Budget & widest size selection• Amazon • Wayfair • OverstockThousands of options, frequent coupons18–18 – 70 per panel
    UK / EU options• Dunelm • John Lewis • B&Q • ArgosGood in-store displays for measuring help£20 – £90 per panel
    Truly bespoke sizes• Local drapery shops • Online custom sites (Smith & Noble, Blinds.com)Perfect fit, choice of lining weights$150+ per window

    🛒 Quick-buy “fan favorites”
    • NICETOWN Thermal Insulated Blackout Curtains (Amazon) – wallet-friendly, 42+ colors
    • IKEA MAJGULL or MARJUN – heavy, affordable, easy to hem
    • Pottery Barn Emery Linen/Cotton with Blackout Lining – luxe look, blocks 100% light


    2. Curtains vs. Blinds — Which Blocks Light Better?

    FactorBlackout CurtainsBlackout Blinds (roller, cellular, etc.)Winner
    Light eliminationExcellent if they extend 8-12 in past frame & touch floor; side wrap-around rods helpCan hit 100 % darkness if mounted inside + light-block side channelsSlight edge to blinds (with side channels)
    Gap problemsPotential light “halo” at top & sides unless over-sizedSmall gaps at edges; side-channel kits fix thisTie
    Insulation & noiseThick fabrics add thermal + acoustic bufferCellular shades insulate well; rollers not as muchTie
    AestheticsSofter, more décor options, can layer sheer + blackoutSleek, minimal profileDepends on style
    Ease of cleaningMachine-washable or dry-cleanWipe with cloth; some fabrics vacuumTie
    Cost (good blackout)30–30–150 per window45–45–200 per windowComparable

    Bottom line:
    • Absolute darkness – go with blackout roller or cellular blinds plus side-rail light blockers or layer blinds under blackout curtains.
    • “Mostly dark + cozy vibe” – good curtains alone usually satisfy 95 % of sleepers.


    3. What Makes a Curtain Truly “Blackout”?

    1. Fabric weight ≥ 250 gsm or triple-weave backing.
    2. “100 % blackout” label (versus “room-darkening,” which is ~75–90 %).
    3. Extra width (1.5–2× rod length) to drape fully closed.
    4. Length that kisses the floor (or at least 6 in below sill).
    5. Matte / tightly woven face fabric—shiny fabrics can leak light through weave.

    Pro tip: If you already own drapes you love, add an aftermarket blackout liner (IKEA RIKTIG, Amazon’s “Eclipse” liners) with clip rings—cheaper than buying new.


    4. Measuring & Installation Cheat-Sheet

    • Rod height: mount 4–6 in above window frame (or just below crown molding) to stop top seepage.
    • Rod width: at least 8 in past each side for full overlap.
    • Inside-mount blinds: measure exact width × three heights (top/mid/bottom) – order to smallest ⅛″.
    • Consider wrap-around or “return” rods; they curve toward wall so fabric hugs side.


    5. Quick Decision Flow

    1. Need cinema-level dark for shift work, nursery, or projector room?
      → Roller blackout blind w/ side channels + optional curtains for looks.
    2. Want dark bedroom but still pretty décor?
      → Over-sized blackout curtains (double rods let you add sheers).
    3. Renting and can’t drill?
      → Tension-rod blackout curtains or stick-on cellular shades (Redi-Shade) you can trim with scissors.
    4. On a tight budget?
      → Amazon Basics or IKEA MAJGULL curtains, hem with iron-on tape.

    6. Extra Hacks for Total Darkness 🌑

    • Add adhesive foam weather-strip behind rod brackets to close top gap.
    • Use Velcro dots along window sides to attach curtain edge to wall.
    • Layer: inside-mount blackout shade + outside-mount blackout curtain = hotel-suite dark.
    • For odd-shaped windows, blackout film (static-cling) can be a last-resort.


    Feel free to let me know your style (minimalist, boho, modern) or room dimensions and I can point you to a few specific items that’ll fit perfectly!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.