Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwq-32b· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

let's say that I am running a brushed motor with no load but constant voltage, what will…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with o3-mini’s answer.
  1. User

    let's say that I am running a brushed motor with no load but constant voltage, what will happen eventually?

  2. Qwen Assistant

    When a brushed motor is run with no external load but a constant voltage applied, it will eventually reach a steady-state speed determined by the balance between the applied voltage and the motor's characteristics. Here's a detailed breakdown:

    Key Concepts:

    1. Back Electromotive Force (Back EMF):

      • As the motor spins, it generates a back EMF ((E_{\text{back}})) proportional to its angular velocity ((\omega)):
        [ E_{\text{back}} = K_e \cdot \omega ]
        where (K_e) is the motor’s back EMF constant.
    2. Voltage Equation:

      • The applied voltage ((V)) must overcome both the back EMF and the voltage drop across the motor’s internal resistance ((R)) due to current ((I)):
        [ V = I \cdot R + E_{\text{back}} ]
    3. Torque and Current:

      • The motor’s torque ((T)) is proportional to current:
        [ T = K_t \cdot I ]
        where (K_t) is the torque constant.
      • At no load, the external torque demand ((T_{\text{load}})) is zero, but the motor must still produce torque to overcome internal losses (e.g., friction, windage). This requires a small current ((I)).

    What Happens Over Time:

    1. Initial Acceleration:

      • When voltage is first applied, the motor starts spinning. Initially, (E_{\text{back}}) is low, so most of the voltage drops across (R), causing a high current ((I)). This high current generates significant torque, accelerating the motor.
    2. Approaching Steady State:

      • As the motor speeds up, (E_{\text{back}}) increases. This reduces the voltage available to drive current ((I)), slowing the acceleration.
      • The motor continues accelerating until (E_{\text{back}} + I \cdot R = V).
    3. Steady-State Speed:

      • At equilibrium, the motor reaches a constant speed where:
        [ E_{\text{back}} = V - I \cdot R ]
        The current (I) is just enough to produce torque ((T = K_t \cdot I)) to counteract internal losses (friction, etc.).
      • The no-load speed ((N_{\text{no-load}})) is given by:
        [ N_{\text{no-load}} \approx \frac{V}{K_v} ]
        where (K_v) ((= K_e / (2\pi))) is the motor’s speed constant (in RPM/Volt). This assumes negligible resistance and losses.

    Special Cases:

    • Ideal Motor (No Friction/Losses):
      If there are zero losses, (T_{\text{required}} = 0), so (I = 0). Thus, (E_{\text{back}} = V), and the motor spins at the theoretical maximum speed (N_{\text{max}} = V / K_v). It would continue indefinitely at this speed with no current draw.

    • Real Motor (With Losses):
      In practice, small currents ((I)) are needed to overcome friction and windage. The steady-state speed is slightly lower than (N_{\text{max}}), but very close to it.


    Final Outcome:

    The motor will accelerate until it reaches a constant no-load speed, where the back EMF plus the voltage drop across its resistance equals the applied voltage. It will then spin at this speed indefinitely, drawing a small current to maintain motion against internal losses. The speed is maximized by the applied voltage and the motor’s (K_v) constant.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.

Identical first prompt