Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwq-32b· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Let's assume I make a 3D building game. Everything is based on a grid. The walls are…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-7-sonnet-20250219’s answer.
  1. User

    Let's assume I make a 3D building game. Everything is based on a grid. The walls are aligned to the grid lines. Objects like beds and tables are aligned to the fields and the size of a field (or multiple fields together). Considering the walls have some width of their own, what are some good ways to prevent objects clipping halfway into the walls when they are next to one?

  2. Qwen Assistant

    To prevent objects from clipping into walls in a grid-based 3D building game, here's a structured solution:

    1. Grid and Wall Representation

    • Grid Cells: Each cell is a unit square (e.g., 1x1 unit).
    • Wall Thickness: Define a fixed thickness (e.g., T = 0.5 units) for all walls.
    • Wall Placement: Walls are placed along grid edges. Each wall occupies space on both adjacent cells, extending inward by T/2 (e.g., 0.25 units).

    2. Usable Area Calculation

    For each grid cell, compute its usable area based on adjacent walls:

    • Edges with Walls: Subtract T/2 from the cell’s edge boundaries.
    • Usable Area Dimensions:
      • Width: cell_width - (west_wall_contribution + east_wall_contribution)
      • Height: cell_height - (north_wall_contribution + south_wall_contribution)
    • Formulas:
      • x_min = cell_x + (west_wall ? T/2 : 0)
      • x_max = cell_x + cell_width - (east_wall ? T/2 : 0)
      • y_min = cell_y + (south_wall ? T/2 : 0) (assuming walls on the south edge affect the lower boundary)
      • y_max = cell_y + cell_height - (north_wall ? T/2 : 0)

    3. Object Placement Validation

    When placing an object:

    • Spanning Cells: Determine all grid cells the object would occupy.
    • Intersection of Usable Areas:
      1. For each cell in the span, retrieve its usable area rectangle.
      2. Compute the intersection of all these rectangles (the overlapping region where all cells’ usable areas overlap).
    • Check Fit: Ensure the object’s bounding box fits entirely within this intersection.

    4. Implementation Steps

    • Wall Updates:
      • When a wall is added/removed on an edge between two cells, update both cells’ usable areas.
      • Store per-cell edge wall status (e.g., has_west_wall, has_east_wall).
    • Collision Detection (Fallback):
      • For non-axis-aligned objects, perform AABB checks against wall collision volumes (extending inward by T/2 from each edge).
    • Snap Points:
      • Snap objects to grid-aligned positions but offset by T/2 near walls to respect usable areas.

    5. Example Workflow

    • Place a Wall:
      • A wall on the west edge of cell (x, y) reduces its usable area’s west boundary to x + T/2.
    • Place a Bed:
      • If the bed spans cells (x,y) and (x+1,y), check the intersection of their usable areas. If a wall exists on (x,y)’s west edge and (x+1,y)’s east edge, the combined usable width is (cell_width - T).

    6. Optimizations

    • Spatial Partitioning: Use a grid-based spatial hash to quickly find nearby walls for collision checks.
    • Precompute Usable Areas: Store usable areas for each cell and update them incrementally when walls change.

    Key Advantages:

    • Efficiency: Precomputed usable areas enable fast placement checks without per-object collision scans.
    • Precision: Ensures objects stay clear of walls by accounting for thickness.
    • User Guidance: Snap points and visual feedback help players intuitively avoid clipping.

    This approach balances performance and accuracy, providing a robust solution for grid-based object placement near walls.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.