Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash-preview-04-17· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

On an idealized 3 phase AC motor spinning at the target speed with no load, would it use…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Qwenqwq-32b’s answer.
  1. User

    On an idealized 3 phase AC motor spinning at the target speed with no load, would it use no power because the back EMF would always equal the input?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Yes, in a strictly idealized 3-phase AC motor spinning at synchronous speed (which is the "target speed" at no load for an ideal motor) with no load, it would consume no real power (Watts).

    Here's why:

    1. Idealized Motor: An idealized motor has no winding resistance, no core losses (hysteresis, eddy currents), and no mechanical losses (friction, windage).
    2. No Load: The motor is not doing any mechanical work. There are no internal losses to overcome.
    3. Synchronous Speed: At synchronous speed, the magnetic field of the rotor is perfectly aligned and rotating at the same speed as the rotating magnetic field produced by the stator.
    4. Back EMF vs. Input Voltage: The rotating rotor magnets (or induced field in an induction motor near synchronous speed) generate a voltage in the stator windings, called the back EMF (counter-EMF). At synchronous speed under no load, this back EMF is almost exactly equal in magnitude to the applied input voltage and is in direct phase opposition (180 degrees out of phase) with it.
    5. Net Voltage: The current flowing through the stator windings is driven by the difference between the applied voltage and the back EMF. Since the back EMF is equal in magnitude and opposite in phase to the input voltage in this idealized scenario, the net voltage driving current is effectively zero (V_supply + E_back = 0 as phasors, or V_supply - |E_back| = 0 in terms of magnitude difference driving resistive current).
    6. Zero Current (for Real Power): With no net voltage driving current through the (zero) resistance, there is no current flow related to real power consumption. The only current that flows is the magnetizing current needed to establish the magnetic field, which is purely inductive.
    7. Real Power Calculation: Real power (P) consumed by an AC circuit is given by P = V * I * cos(phi), where V is voltage, I is current, and phi is the phase angle between voltage and current. For a purely inductive current (like the magnetizing current in an ideal motor), the phase angle phi is 90 degrees (current lags voltage). cos(90) = 0. Therefore, P = V * I * 0 = 0.

    So, you are correct. In the idealized scenario, the back EMF exactly balancing the input voltage (in terms of magnitude and phase opposition for the resistive component) means no net voltage is available to drive current through the zero resistance, and any current is purely reactive (lagging by 90 degrees), resulting in zero real power consumption. The motor only draws reactive power (VARs) to maintain its magnetic field, but no real power (Watts) is converted from electrical to mechanical energy or heat.

    In a Real Motor:

    A real motor does consume a small amount of real power at no load because:

    • Windings have resistance (I²R losses).
    • The core has hysteresis and eddy current losses.
    • There is friction in bearings and windage (air resistance).

    These losses require a small amount of torque to overcome, which means the back EMF is slightly less than the input voltage, allowing a small net voltage to drive a current through the winding resistance to produce that necessary (small) torque and overcome the losses.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.

Identical first prompt