Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwq-32b· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

How much VRAM does qwen3-235b-a22b require to run fast and reliably with a token length…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-pro’s answer.
  1. User

    How much VRAM does qwen3-235b-a22b require to run fast and reliably with a token length of about 8K?

  2. Qwen Assistant

    To run the Qwen3-235B-A22B model with an 8K token length reliably and efficiently, the VRAM requirements depend on factors like precision (FP32/FP16), quantization, and optimization techniques. Here's a breakdown:


    Estimate for Standard Precision (FP16/FP32):

    • Without Quantization or Model Parallelism:

      • Model Parameters (FP16): 235B parameters × 2 bytes = ~450GB VRAM (for weights alone, which is impractical on a single GPU).
      • Activations for 8K Tokens: Attention matrices and intermediate activations for an 8K context add significant memory. For a 4096-hidden-size model, this could require ~100–200GB VRAM depending on layer count and architecture.

      Total VRAM Needed (Theoretical): Over 300–500GB (impossible on a single GPU).


    Practical Recommendations:

    1. Quantization (e.g., 4-bit):

      • Reduces model weight storage to ~112.5GB (for 4-bit quantization).
      • Activations and context still dominate, requiring ~80–120GB VRAM for 8K tokens.
      • Recommended Setup: A GPU with 120–160GB VRAM (e.g., NVIDIA A100/H100 or equivalent).
    2. Model Parallelism (Multi-GPU):

      • Distribute the model across multiple GPUs to handle large parameters and activations.
      • Requires ~80–120GB VRAM per GPU for a 4-GPU setup.
    3. Mixed Precision (FP16 + Activation Checkpointing):

      • Reduces VRAM usage compared to FP32 but still requires ~120–160GB VRAM for 8K tokens.

    Key Takeaways:

    • Minimum VRAM for Single-GPU (Quantized): ~80–120GB (e.g., NVIDIA H100 80GB/120GB).
    • Optimal Setup: Use 4-bit quantization and/or model parallelism for reliability.
    • Avoid FP32: The model’s size makes FP32 impractical without specialized hardware.

    Notes:

    • Check Official Documentation: Alibaba Cloud may provide specific guidelines for Qwen3-235B-A22B.
    • Software Optimizations: Tools like DeepSpeed or FasterTransformer can reduce VRAM needs further.

    If you prioritize speed and reliability, aim for at least 120GB VRAM with quantization or multi-GPU support.

  3. User

    Did you now see the "a22b" part? It's a mixture of models thing. Please try better.

  4. Qwen Assistant

    You're absolutely right—I should have considered the "A22B" suffix more carefully. Let’s re-examine the model name Qwen3-235B-A22B and its implications for VRAM requirements. Here’s a refined breakdown:


    Understanding "A22B" in Qwen3-235B-A22B:

    The suffix "A22B" likely refers to a model variant optimized for inference (or a specific quantization/optimization configuration). In Alibaba's model naming conventions, such suffixes often denote:

    1. Quantization: E.g., 4-bit, 8-bit, or mixed-precision optimizations.
    2. Model architecture tweaks: Such as sparsity, pruning, or a mixture of experts (MoE).
    3. Inference acceleration: Techniques like activation checkpointing or model parallelism baked into the variant.

    For example:

    • "A" might stand for "Accelerated" or "Advanced."
    • "22B" could imply a 22-bit quantization or a specific optimization level.
    • "B" might indicate a sub-variant (e.g., version B of the optimized model).

    Revised VRAM Estimates for Qwen3-235B-A22B:

    Assuming "A22B" includes quantization or model optimizations (common in Alibaba's large models), here’s a more accurate breakdown:

    1. Quantization (e.g., 4-bit or 8-bit):

    • Model Weights (Quantized):
      • If "A22B" uses 4-bit quantization, the model size drops to ~58GB (235B params × 0.5 bytes).
      • If "A22B" uses 8-bit quantization, it’s ~116GB.
    • Activations (for 8K tokens):
      • For an 8K context length, activations (attention matrices, hidden states) dominate VRAM usage.
      • A 235B model with 4096 hidden dimensions would require ~60–80GB VRAM for activations at inference time (depending on layer count and architecture).

    Total VRAM Required (Quantized):

    • 4-bit quantization + 8K tokens: ~58GB (weights) + ~60–80GB (activations) = ~120–140GB VRAM.
    • 8-bit quantization + 8K tokens: ~116GB (weights) + ~60–80GB (activations) = ~180–200GB VRAM.

    2. Model Parallelism (Multi-GPU):

    If "A22B" includes model parallelism (splitting the model across GPUs), the VRAM per GPU drops significantly:

    • 4-GPU Setup:
      • Weights: ~58GB (4-bit) / 4 GPUs = ~14.5GB per GPU.
      • Activations: ~60–80GB / 4 GPUs = ~15–20GB per GPU.
      • Total per GPU: ~30–35GB VRAM (e.g., NVIDIA A100 40GB or H100 80GB).

    3. Mixture of Experts (MoE):

    If "A22B" uses an MoE architecture, the model splits computation across experts, reducing VRAM per GPU:

    • Experts are activated dynamically, so only a subset runs at any time.
    • VRAM per GPU: ~40–60GB (depending on expert count and parallelism).

    Key Recommendations Based on "A22B":

    1. Minimum VRAM for Single-GPU (Quantized):

      • ~120–140GB (e.g., NVIDIA H100 80GB/120GB if 4-bit quantized).
      • Lower if "A22B" includes sparsity or other optimizations.
    2. Optimal Setup:

      • Use model parallelism (4 GPUs) for smoother inference.
      • Prioritize 4-bit quantization (e.g., via FasterTransformer or DeepSpeed).
    3. Avoid FP32: The "A22B" suffix likely avoids FP32 for efficiency, so stick to quantized variants.


    Final Notes:

    • Check Alibaba’s Documentation: The "A22B" variant may have specific requirements (e.g., 4-bit quantization baked in).
    • Test with Tools: Use frameworks like TensorRT or PyTorch’s quantization modules to verify VRAM usage.

    If you’re using the A22B variant, 120–140GB VRAM (single-GPU) or 4x 40GB GPUs (multi-GPU) should suffice. Let me know if you need further clarification!

  5. User

    Let's assume Q8

  6. Qwen Assistant

    To clarify, "Q8" refers to 8-bit quantization of the model weights. Here’s a detailed analysis of the VRAM requirements for Qwen3-235B-A22B with an 8K token length, assuming 8-bit quantization (Q8) and considering the "A22B" optimizations:


    1. Model Weights (Q8 Quantization):

    • Parameters: 235B (235,000,000,000 parameters).
    • 8-bit Quantization: Each parameter requires 1 byte (8 bits).
    • Total Weight Storage:
      ( 235 \text{B} \times 1 \text{ byte} = 235,000 \text{ MB} = \textbf{235 GB} ).

    2. Activation Memory for 8K Tokens:

    The dominant VRAM consumer for long contexts (8K tokens) is the attention cache (key and value matrices) and intermediate activations. Here’s the breakdown:

    a. Attention Cache (Key and Value Matrices):

    • Hidden Size: Assume ( 4096 ) (common for large models like Qwen3).
    • Number of Heads: ( 64 ) (e.g., ( 4096 / 64 = 64 ) heads).
    • Sequence Length: ( 8192 ) tokens.
    • Storage per Head (8-bit):
      • Key: ( 8192 \text{ tokens} \times 64 \text{ (head size)} \times 1 \text{ byte} = 524,288 \text{ bytes} \approx 0.5 \text{ MB} ).
      • Value: Same as key (( \approx 0.5 \text{ MB} )).
      • Total per Head: ( 1 \text{ MB} ).
    • Per Layer (64 Heads):
      ( 64 \text{ heads} \times 1 \text{ MB} = 64 \text{ MB} ).
    • Total Across All Layers (Assume 48 Layers):
      ( 48 \text{ layers} \times 64 \text{ MB} = 3,072 \text{ MB} \approx \textbf{3 GB} ).

    b. Intermediate Activations (e.g., Feed-Forward Layers):

    • Hidden Size: ( 4096 ).
    • Expansion Ratio: Assume ( 4x ) for the feed-forward layer (common in transformers).
    • Storage per Layer (8-bit):
      ( (4096 \times 4 \times 8192 \text{ tokens}) \times 1 \text{ byte} = 134,217,728 \text{ bytes} \approx 128 \text{ MB} ).
    • Total Across All Layers (48 Layers):
      ( 48 \times 128 \text{ MB} = 6,144 \text{ MB} \approx \textbf{6 GB} ).

    Total Activation Memory:

    ( 3 \text{ GB (attention)} + 6 \text{ GB (activations)} = \textbf{9 GB} ).


    3. Total VRAM Required (Q8 + 8K Tokens):

    • Weights (Q8): 235 GB.
    • Activations: ~9 GB.
    • Overhead (Buffers, Optimizers, etc.): ~5–10 GB.

    Total VRAM:
    ( 235 \text{ GB} + 9 \text{ GB} + 10 \text{ GB} = \textbf{254–259 GB} ).


    Practical Considerations (Due to "A22B" Optimizations):

    The "A22B" suffix likely includes optimizations to reduce VRAM usage further, such as:

    1. Sparsity/MoE (Mixture of Experts): Only a subset of parameters are active at any time (e.g., 10% sparsity reduces weights to ~23.5 GB).
    2. Activation Checkpointing: Recomputes activations on the fly to save memory.
    3. Kernel Fusion: Reduces intermediate tensor storage.

    Estimated VRAM with "A22B" Optimizations:

    • Weights (with Sparsity): ~23.5–47 GB (if 10–20% sparsity).
    • Activations (with Checkpointing): ~4–6 GB.
    • Total: ~30–50 GB VRAM (possible with 8-bit quantization + optimizations).

    Recommended Setup:

    • Single-GPU (Optimistic): NVIDIA H100 80GB or 120GB (if sparsity + MoE).
    • Multi-GPU (Recommended): Use model parallelism (e.g., 4x NVIDIA A100 40GB GPUs) to split the model and activations across GPUs.
    • Framework Optimizations: Use FasterTransformer or DeepSpeed for quantization and memory management.

    Key Takeaways:

    • Without "A22B" optimizations (pure Q8): ~250+ GB VRAM (impractical for most setups).
    • With "A22B" optimizations: ~30–50 GB VRAM (feasible with high-end GPUs).
    • Prioritize: Use the "A22B" variant’s built-in optimizations and multi-GPU setups for 8K contexts.

    Let me know if you need further clarification!

  7. User

    Let's assume Q8

  8. Qwen Assistant

    Given the assumption of Q8 (8-bit quantization) for the Qwen3-235B-A22B model, here’s a detailed breakdown of VRAM requirements for running it with an 8K token length:


    1. Key Assumptions for Q8 (8-bit Quantization):

    • Model Parameters (Weights):

      • 235 billion parameters × 1 byte (8-bit) = ~235 GB (weights alone).
      • This is already too large for a single GPU (even the NVIDIA H100 80GB/120GB falls short).
    • Activations for 8K Tokens:

      • Hidden size: Assume 4,096 dimensions (common in large models like Qwen3).
      • For an 8K token sequence:
        • Attention Matrices:
          • Q/K/V matrices: (8,192 \text{ tokens} \times 4,096 \text{ dims} \times 2 \text{ bytes (FP16)} \times 3 \text{ (Q/K/V)}) = ~200 MB * number of attention heads.
          • For 32 attention heads: ~6.4 GB per layer.
        • Feed-Forward Layers:
          • Intermediate hidden states (e.g., 11,008 dimensions): ~(8,192 \times 11,008 \times 2 \text{ bytes}) ≈ 178 MB per layer.
      • Total Activations (Estimate):
        • For 48 layers (common in large models), activations could require ~50–100 GB (depending on optimization techniques like activation checkpointing).

    2. Total VRAM Requirements:

    Single-GPU Setup (Unrealistic for Q8):

    • Weights: 235 GB (already exceeds single-GPU capacity).
    • Activations: ~50–100 GB.
    • Result: Impossible on a single GPU (even with 80–120GB VRAM).

    3. Practical Multi-GPU Setup (Recommended):

    To run Qwen3-235B-A22B with 8K tokens and 8-bit quantization, you’ll need model parallelism across multiple GPUs. Here’s how it breaks down:

    Example: 4-GPU Setup (8-bit Quantization):

    • Weights:
      • Split the 235 GB model across 4 GPUs: ~58.75 GB per GPU (feasible on NVIDIA A100 80GB or H100 80GB).
    • Activations:
      • Split activations across GPUs or use activation checkpointing to reduce peak memory.
      • Total activation memory per GPU: ~12.5–25 GB (assuming 50–100 GB total).
    • Total VRAM per GPU: ~70–80 GB (e.g., NVIDIA H100 80GB or A100 80GB).

    Example: 8-GPU Setup (for lower VRAM per GPU):

    • Weights: ~29.4 GB per GPU.
    • Activations: ~6.25–12.5 GB per GPU.
    • Total VRAM per GPU: ~40 GB (e.g., NVIDIA A100 80GB or H100 80GB for redundancy).

    4. Optimizations to Reduce VRAM:

    • Mixed Precision:
      • Use FP16 for activations (default) or FP8 for further savings.
    • Activation Checkpointing:
      • Re-compute activations during backward passes to save memory (useful for training, but also applicable to inference).
    • Sparse Attention:
      • Techniques like local attention or block sparse attention reduce memory for long sequences.
    • Layer-wise Parallelism:
      • Split the model into shards (e.g., embeddings, attention layers, FFNs) across GPUs.

    5. Key Takeaways for Q8 (8-bit):

    • Single-GPU Impossible: 235 GB weights alone exceed even the largest GPUs (e.g., H100 120GB).
    • Minimum Multi-GPU Setup:
      • 4x NVIDIA H100 80GB (total ~320 GB VRAM) for 8-bit quantization.
      • 8x NVIDIA A100 80GB for redundancy and lower VRAM per GPU.
    • Optimal Configuration:
      • Use model parallelism + activation checkpointing + sparse attention.

    Final Notes:

    • Check Documentation: Alibaba Cloud may provide specific guidelines for Qwen3-235B-A22B (e.g., if "A22B" implies further optimizations like 4-bit quantization or MoE).
    • Test with Tools: Use frameworks like DeepSpeed (Zero-3) or FasterTransformer to validate VRAM usage.

    If you’re using Q8 (8-bit quantization), a 4-GPU setup with H100 80GB GPUs is the most practical solution for 8K tokens. Let me know if you need help with implementation details!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.