Here’s a rather heated online discussion.Weigh the merits of the two sides and which one…
- User
Here’s a rather heated online discussion.Weigh the merits of the two sides and which one is more likely to be correct or incorrect, based on electrical engineering, USB specifications, and other relevant subject matter. Specifically, analyze the discussion about connecting two 5V USB supplies together.
- Assistant
This online discussion revolves around the question of what happens when two 5V USB power supplies are connected together, specifically focusing on whether this causes issues such as short circuits, current flow, or device shutdowns. The debate is heated, with participants derkades, zettabomb, f1shy, and cowboylowrez offering differing perspectives. Below, I will analyze the arguments based on electrical engineering principles, USB specifications, and practical considerations, weighing the merits of each side and determining which is more likely to be correct.
Key Points of the Discussion
-
derkades' Argument:
- Connecting two 5V supplies does not cause a short circuit because no current flows without a voltage difference.
- If there is a small voltage difference, capacitors in one supply will charge up, equalizing the voltages, after which current stops flowing.
-
zettabomb's Argument:
- USB supplies are not exactly 5V; they have a tolerance of ±5% (4.75V to 5.25V), and some intentionally output slightly higher voltages (e.g., 5.1V) to account for cable losses.
- Connecting two supplies with different voltages can cause current to flow, potentially tripping protection mechanisms (e.g., polyfuses, efuses) or disabling the port.
- Damage is unlikely, but the device may not function until the issue is resolved.
-
f1shy's Argument:
- Nothing will happen when connecting two 5V USB supplies; they will not "blow" or malfunction.
- Power supplies do not act as loads to each other due to their design, likening their behavior to having a diode at the output (though not directly at the output).
- Claims that zettabomb misunderstands power supply behavior, Ohm's law, and protection mechanisms, asserting that supplies shut down if the output voltage is too high, without involving fuses.
-
cowboylowrez's Contribution:
- A minor clarification that Ohm's law still applies, but the effective resistance in a circuit with active components (like transistors) varies dynamically.
Analysis Based on Electrical Engineering Principles
To evaluate the arguments, we need to consider the behavior of USB power supplies, the USB specification, and the principles of electrical engineering, particularly regarding power supply design, voltage differences, and protection mechanisms.
1. USB Power Supply Specifications
- According to the USB 2.0 specification, the VBUS voltage (nominal 5V) must be within 4.75V to 5.25V for a USB host or hub port, accounting for tolerances and voltage drops across cables and connectors.
- USB chargers (e.g., USB Battery Charging Specification) often target a slightly higher voltage (e.g., 5.1V) to compensate for resistive losses in cables, ensuring the device receives at least 4.75V under load.
- USB power supplies are typically switching-mode power supplies (SMPS) with active regulation to maintain a stable output voltage. They often include protection mechanisms such as overcurrent protection (OCP), overvoltage protection (OVP), and short-circuit protection (SCP).
2. Behavior of Two Power Supplies Connected in Parallel
-
Ideal Case (Identical Voltages):
- If two power supplies output exactly the same voltage (e.g., 5.00V), no current will flow between them when connected in parallel, as there is no voltage difference to drive current (per Ohm's law, ( I = \Delta V / R ), where ( \Delta V = 0 )).
- This aligns with derkades' initial claim that "no current will flow without a voltage difference."
-
Realistic Case (Voltage Differences):
- In practice, two USB power supplies are unlikely to output exactly the same voltage due to manufacturing tolerances, design choices, and load conditions. For example, one supply might output 5.0V, while another outputs 5.1V, creating a voltage difference of 0.1V.
- When connected, current will flow from the higher-voltage supply to the lower-voltage supply. The magnitude of this current depends on the effective resistance between the supplies, including the internal output impedance of the supplies and any resistance in the connecting cables.
- The behavior of the supplies under this condition depends on their design:
- Unprotected Supplies: If the supplies lack protection, the higher-voltage supply will attempt to "charge" the lower-voltage supply, potentially causing excessive current flow, overheating, or damage.
- Protected Supplies: Most modern USB power supplies include protection mechanisms. If the lower-voltage supply detects an overvoltage condition (e.g., its output is forced to 5.1V when it targets 5.0V), it may shut down or enter a fault state. Similarly, the higher-voltage supply may detect an overcurrent condition and shut down or limit its output.
-
Capacitor Charging (derkades' Claim):
- derkades suggests that capacitors in one supply will charge up to equalize the voltages, after which current stops flowing. This is partially correct but oversimplified. While output capacitors in the supplies will charge or discharge to reduce the voltage difference, this assumes the supplies are passive and not actively regulating their outputs. In reality, SMPS actively regulate their output voltage, so the voltage difference persists unless one supply shuts down or both supplies are designed to share the load (e.g., via droop compensation or active current sharing, which is not typical in USB chargers).
3. Protection Mechanisms in USB Power Supplies
-
Polyfuses and Efuses:
- Many USB power supplies and USB host ports include overcurrent protection devices, such as polyfuses (resettable PTC fuses) or electronic fuses (efuses). These devices trip when the current exceeds a safe threshold, protecting the supply or port from damage.
- zettabomb's claim that connecting two supplies can trip a polyfuse or efuse is plausible, especially if the voltage difference is significant and the resulting current exceeds the protection threshold.
- f1shy's assertion that "there is no fuse in 99% of supplies" is incorrect. While not all supplies use traditional fuses, many incorporate polyfuses, efuses, or active current-limiting circuits as part of their protection strategy.
-
Active Protection (Transistors):
- f1shy claims that power supplies use transistors to shut down when the output voltage is too high, rather than relying on fuses. This is partially correct: many SMPS include overvoltage protection (OVP) circuits that disable the output if the voltage exceeds a threshold. However, this does not negate the presence of overcurrent protection mechanisms, which may involve fuses or current-limiting circuits.
- The idea that supplies "do not act as a load to the other" is misleading. A power supply with a lower output voltage can indeed act as a load to a higher-voltage supply, drawing current if not properly isolated (e.g., by a diode).
-
Diodes at the Output:
- f1shy suggests that power supplies behave "as if" they have a diode at the output, preventing reverse current flow. This is not universally true for USB power supplies. While some power supplies include output diodes (e.g., in certain linear regulators or as part of a rectifier stage in SMPS), many modern SMPS do not have a physical diode directly at the output, especially in low-voltage applications like USB, where efficiency is critical.
- Without an output diode, reverse current can flow into a supply if its output voltage is forced above its setpoint, potentially triggering protection mechanisms or causing damage.
4. Ohm's Law and Active Components
-
Ohm's Law Applicability:
- f1shy argues that Ohm's law does not apply to transistors or diodes because they are nonlinear components. This is a misunderstanding. Ohm's law (( V = IR )) is a fundamental relationship that always applies to resistive elements in a circuit. However, in circuits with active components like transistors, the effective resistance (or impedance) is not constant and varies with operating conditions.
- zettabomb correctly points out that when two supplies are connected, the finite resistance of the cable and the internal impedances of the supplies determine the current flow, per Ohm's law. This is accurate, though the behavior of the supplies (e.g., shutting down or limiting current) may prevent sustained current flow.
- cowboylowrez's clarification that Ohm's law still applies, but with a varying resistance, is technically correct and helps resolve the confusion.
-
Nonlinear Behavior:
- f1shy's emphasis on the nonlinearity of transistors is valid in the sense that power supplies do not behave like simple resistors. However, this does not mean Ohm's law is irrelevant; it simply means the analysis must account for the dynamic behavior of the supplies, including their regulation and protection mechanisms.
5. Practical Implications
-
Risk of Connecting Two USB Supplies:
- Connecting two USB power supplies in parallel is generally not recommended unless they are specifically designed for parallel operation (e.g., with current-sharing mechanisms). USB chargers are not designed for this, as the USB specification assumes a single power source per VBUS line.
- In practice, the most likely outcome of connecting two supplies is that one or both will shut down due to protection mechanisms, as zettabomb describes. This is consistent with real-world experiences, such as USB host ports disabling VBUS when an external voltage is detected.
- Damage is unlikely due to the robust protection in modern USB supplies, but the setup is unreliable and may prevent the connected device from functioning properly.
-
f1shy's Claim of "Nothing Will Happen":
- f1shy's assertion that "nothing will happen" is overly simplistic and potentially dangerous. While catastrophic failure (e.g., "blowing up") is unlikely, the behavior of the supplies is not guaranteed to be benign. For example, if one supply shuts down, the device being powered may lose power, leading to unexpected behavior.
- f1shy's claim of having "done it thousands of times" without issues may reflect specific conditions (e.g., supplies with very close voltages or robust protection) but does not generalize to all scenarios.
Evaluation of the Arguments
derkades' Position
- Merits:
- Correctly identifies that no current flows if the voltages are identical.
- Acknowledges that a small voltage difference will cause temporary current flow to charge capacitors, though this is an oversimplification.
- Weaknesses:
- Does not account for the active regulation of SMPS, which prevents voltages from equalizing naturally.
- Ignores the potential for protection mechanisms to trip or for sustained current flow due to persistent voltage differences.
- Likelihood of Being Correct:
- Partially correct in the ideal case but incomplete in practice. Real-world USB supplies are unlikely to behave as described due to tolerances and protection mechanisms.
zettabomb's Position
- Merits:
- Accurately highlights the USB voltage tolerance (±5%) and the practical reality of voltage differences between supplies.
- Correctly identifies the risk of current flow and the potential for protection mechanisms (e.g., polyfuses, efuses) to trip, disabling the port or supply.
- Emphasizes that connecting two supplies is unreliable and not recommended, aligning with standard engineering practice and USB specifications.
- Weaknesses:
- Could provide more detail on the specific behavior of SMPS under reverse current or overvoltage conditions.
- The claim of having "destroyed components" by connecting supplies is plausible but may exaggerate the risk, as modern supplies are typically well-protected.
- Likelihood of Being Correct:
- Highly likely to be correct in practice. zettabomb's position is consistent with electrical engineering principles, USB specifications, and real-world behavior of power supplies.
f1shy's Position
- Merits:
- Correctly notes that many power supplies include active protection (e.g., OVP) that causes them to shut down if the output voltage is forced too high.
- Highlights the nonlinear behavior of power supplies, though this is misapplied in the context of Ohm's law.
- Weaknesses:
- Overgeneralizes by claiming "nothing will happen," ignoring the variability in power supply designs and the potential for shutdowns or other issues.
- Incorrectly asserts that supplies do not act as loads to each other, ignoring the possibility of reverse current flow in the absence of output diodes.
- Misrepresents the role of diodes in SMPS, as many USB supplies do not have output diodes that prevent reverse current.
- Dismisses the presence of fuses or current-limiting mechanisms, which are common in USB supplies and ports.
- Misunderstands Ohm's law, conflating its applicability to resistive elements with the nonlinear behavior of active components.
- Likelihood of Being Correct:
- Unlikely to be correct in the general case. While f1shy's experience may hold true in specific scenarios, the blanket claim that "nothing will happen" is not supported by engineering principles or USB specifications.
cowboylowrez's Position
- Merits:
- Provides a useful clarification that Ohm's law remains valid, but the effective resistance in a circuit with active components is dynamic.
- Weaknesses:
- Does not directly address the core question of connecting USB supplies, so the contribution is tangential.
- Likelihood of Being Correct:
- Correct in the context of Ohm's law but not central to the debate.
Conclusion: Which Side is More Likely to be Correct?
Based on the analysis, zettabomb's position is more likely to be correct in the context of connecting two 5V USB power supplies. Here's why:
-
Alignment with Engineering Principles:
- zettabomb accurately describes the implications of voltage differences, current flow, and protection mechanisms, which are fundamental to understanding the behavior of power supplies in parallel.
- The claim that connecting two supplies can cause issues (e.g., port shutdowns, tripped fuses) is consistent with the design of USB power supplies and the USB specification, which does not support parallel power sources on VBUS.
-
Practical Relevance:
- zettabomb's warnings about reliability and potential issues align with standard engineering practice, which advises against connecting power supplies in parallel unless they are specifically designed for it.
- Real-world experiences, such as USB host ports disabling VBUS when an external voltage is detected, support zettabomb's position.
-
Weaknesses in Opposing Arguments:
- derkades' argument is theoretically correct in the ideal case but oversimplifies the behavior of real-world SMPS, ignoring active regulation and protection mechanisms.
- f1shy's argument is overly dismissive and contains several technical inaccuracies, such as the misapplication of Ohm's law, the role of diodes, and the prevalence of protection mechanisms. The claim that "nothing will happen" is not generalizable and could lead to unsafe practices.
Final Recommendation
Connecting two 5V USB power supplies in parallel is not recommended and is likely to cause issues, such as one or both supplies shutting down due to protection mechanisms. While catastrophic failure is unlikely due to modern protection circuits, the setup is unreliable and may prevent the connected device from functioning properly. Engineers and hobbyists should avoid this practice unless the supplies are specifically designed for parallel operation (e.g., with current-sharing mechanisms) or are isolated with appropriate circuitry (e.g., diodes to prevent reverse current).
Note on the Tone of the Discussion
The discussion devolves into personal attacks and unconstructive arguments, particularly between zettabomb and f1shy. This detracts from the technical merits of the debate and highlights the importance of maintaining professionalism in technical discussions. Both sides could benefit from focusing on evidence, such as circuit analysis, datasheets, or experimental results, rather than resorting to insults or appeals to authority.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.