Skip to content
The Chat Archive
deepseek-r1-0528· DeepSeek LMArena Human Preference 140K

I have a new LG G4 OLED TV. How accurate in regards to color accuracy (delta E), gamut…

  1. User

    I have a new LG G4 OLED TV. How accurate in regards to color accuracy (delta E), gamut etc. is filmmaker mode usually out of the box? And what is the general user consensus on the LG Autocal process - does it deliver good results? or is manual calibration preferred?

  2. Assistant

    Here's a breakdown of Filmmaker Mode accuracy on the LG G4 OLED and the consensus on LG's AutoCal vs. manual calibration:

    1. LG G4 Filmmaker Mode Out-of-the-Box Accuracy:

    • Generally Excellent: Filmmaker Mode (FMM) on high-end LG OLEDs like the G4 is renowned for its out-of-the-box accuracy. LG invests significantly in factory calibration for this mode.
    • Delta E (dE): Expect average dE values typically between 1.0 and 3.0 across the greyscale and primary/secondary colors after a brief warm-up period. This is considered outstanding and often below the threshold of visible difference (dE < 3) for most content. Some reviews measure averages closer to 1.5-2.0, which is exceptional.
    • White Balance (Greyscale): Usually very accurate to D65 (6500K), with minimal visible tinting. Delta errors in the greyscale are typically very low.
    • Gamut:
      • Rec.709 (SDR/HDR): Near-perfect tracking, often exceeding 99% coverage with minimal errors.
      • DCI-P3 (HDR): Excellent coverage, typically 98%+ of the P3 gamut volume. Tracking within P3 is also usually very accurate in FMM.
      • BT.2020 (HDR): Coverage is understandably lower (around 75-80% is typical for current OLEDs), but FMM will track the native gamut of the panel accurately within its capabilities.
    • Gamma/EOTF: FMM targets the correct gamma (2.2/2.4 for SDR, ST.2084 PQ curve for HDR) and LG's implementation is generally precise, especially in HDR where tracking the PQ curve is critical.
    • Why it's so good: LG calibrates each high-end OLED panel individually at the factory for FMM using high-end spectroradiometers. This minimizes panel-to-panel variance.
    • The Caveat: While consistently excellent, it's not perfect on every single unit. There can be minor variations:
      • Very slight greyscale drift (usually imperceptible).
      • Minor saturation or hue errors in specific colors (also usually imperceptible).
      • Near-Black Performance: This is the area most likely to benefit from a professional calibration, as handling near-black details and macro-blocking can sometimes be optimized further, though FMM is the best starting point.

    Verdict on FMM: For the vast majority of users, Filmmaker Mode on the LG G4 provides reference-level accuracy out of the box. You can confidently use it for critical viewing knowing the director's intent is being respected with minimal deviation. It's arguably the best "out-of-the-box" accurate mode available on any consumer TV.

    2. LG AutoCal (using Calman) - Consensus & Comparison to Manual Cal:

    • What it is: LG provides an AutoCal workflow integrated with professional calibration software (Calman for LG). It allows users with compatible colorimeters (X-Rite i1Display Pro, Calibrite ColorChecker Display, etc.) and Calman software to perform an automated calibration of Greyscale (2pt & 20pt), Color Management System (CMS), and potentially 3D LUTs for HDR.
    • Pros:
      • Accessibility: Makes advanced calibration more accessible to enthusiasts who aren't professional calibrators.
      • Speed: Significantly faster than a full manual calibration, especially for complex 20pt greyscale and CMS adjustments.
      • Consistency: Removes human error in the measurement-reading-adjustment loop. The software drives everything.
      • Good Results with Good Gear: When used with a high-quality, recently profiled/corrected colorimeter (or better, a spectroradiometer to create the correction), AutoCal can achieve excellent results, often getting very close to what a skilled professional achieves manually.
    • Cons & Consensus:
      • Garbage In, Garbage Out: This is the BIG caveat. AutoCal's accuracy is entirely dependent on the accuracy of the colorimeter used. Entry-level meters (like an uncorrected i1D3) have inherent inaccuracies, especially in saturated colors and near-black. Feeding AutoCal bad measurements leads to bad calibration, potentially making the image worse than FMM.
      • Near-Black Limitations: Like FMM, AutoCal might not always perfectly optimize near-black gamma and details as effectively as a skilled human calibrator who can interpret measurements and make nuanced adjustments in this tricky region. Panel variance plays a role here too.
      • Not "Set and Forget": You still need to understand calibration concepts, ensure the meter is positioned correctly, let the panel warm up, manage ambient light, and critically, have a properly characterized/corrected meter. You also need to buy/rent Calman for LG.
      • Cost: Requires investment in hardware (good meter) and software (Calman license).
      • Consensus: AutoCal is a powerful tool that can deliver professional-level results, BUT only when used with a high-quality, accurately profiled measurement device. For an enthusiast with a top-tier meter (like a Colorimetry Research CR-100/250/300, a profiled Klein K-10, or an i1D3 corrected using a reference spectro), AutoCal is fantastic and highly recommended. For someone using a basic, uncorrected meter, it's risky and likely inferior to just using FMM or hiring a pro. It's not a magic "one-click" solution for beginners.

    3. Manual Calibration (by a Professional):

    • The Gold Standard: A full manual calibration by an ISF or THX certified professional using a high-end spectroradiometer (like a Klein K-80, Murideo Fresco, CR-250/300) remains the absolute best way to achieve peak accuracy.
    • Advantages:
      • Ultimate Accuracy: Can achieve the lowest possible dE values and the most precise tracking, especially in challenging areas like near-black and high saturation.
      • Expertise: Professionals understand how to interpret measurements, account for panel quirks, and make nuanced adjustments beyond just what the software automates. They can fine-tune for specific viewing conditions if needed.
      • Equipment: Pros use the most accurate measurement devices available.
      • Comprehensiveness: Includes optimizing motion settings, noise reduction, sharpness, and potentially multiple picture modes.
    • Disadvantage: Cost (typically 250−250-500+ depending on location and calibrator).

    Recommendation Summary for your LG G4:

    1. Start with Filmmaker Mode: For 95% of users, this is all you need. Its out-of-box accuracy is truly exceptional. Enjoy your stunning TV!
    2. Considering AutoCal? Only pursue this if:
      • You are an enthusiast willing to learn the basics.
      • You are willing to invest in a high-quality colorimeter AND Calman for LG software.
      • You understand the critical importance of meter profiling/correction (ideally using a reference spectro, either your own or via a service like DisplayCal + a community shared correction matrix, though this is less ideal). If you don't have access to a high-end meter and profiling, don't bother – you risk worse results than FMM.
    3. Want the Absolute Best? Hire an ISF/THX Certified Professional Calibrator with a high-end spectroradiometer. This is the best way to extract the absolute maximum reference performance from your G4, especially optimizing near-black and ensuring perfection across all modes (SDR/HDR/Dolby Vision).

    In short: Your LG G4's Filmmaker Mode is stunningly accurate out of the box. AutoCal is a powerful tool if you have pro-level measurement gear; otherwise, stick with FMM or hire a pro for the ultimate result. For most, FMM is perfection. Enjoy your incredible TV!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.