Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Metallama-3.3-70b-instruct· MetaHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

make a osce template and table for me consisting of common diagnosis, differntial…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Mistralmistral-medium-2505’s answer.
  1. User

    make a osce template and table for me consisting of common diagnosis, differntial diagnosis, investigations, mamangment plans, their rationale and what questions to aks in history specifically. Include red flags as well and make it really good for me

  2. Meta Assistant

    Here is a comprehensive OSCE template and table for a patient presenting with a common condition. I'll use a patient with abdominal pain as an example.

    OSCE Template:

    1. Introduction and Icebreaker (30 seconds)
      • Introduce yourself and the patient
      • Ask the patient to describe their main complaint
    2. History Taking (4-5 minutes)
      • Ask specific questions to gather information about the patient's condition
      • Use the table below to guide your questioning
    3. Physical Examination (4-5 minutes)
      • Perform a focused physical examination to gather more information
      • Use the table below to guide your examination
    4. Investigations and Management (2-3 minutes)
      • Discuss potential investigations and management plans with the patient
      • Use the table below to guide your discussion
    5. Conclusion and Safety Netting (1-2 minutes)
      • Summarize the patient's condition and management plan
      • Provide safety netting advice and follow-up instructions

    Table: Abdominal Pain

    SectionCommon DiagnosisDifferential DiagnosisInvestigationsManagement PlanRationaleHistory QuestionsRed Flags
    IntroductionAcute appendicitisGastroenteritis, constipation, ovarian cystNoneNoneNoneCan you describe your pain? Where is it located?Severe pain, vomiting, fever
    HistoryPeptic ulcer diseaseGastritis, gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD)Endoscopy, blood testsAntacids, proton pump inhibitorsReduce acid production, protect stomach liningWhat triggers your pain? Do you have a history of ulcers?Black tarry stools, difficulty swallowing
    Physical ExamInflammatory bowel disease (IBD)Irritable bowel syndrome (IBS), celiac diseaseColonoscopy, blood testsAminosalicylates, corticosteroidsReduce inflammation, induce remissionDo you have any abdominal tenderness? Have you noticed any changes in your bowel habits?Weight loss, blood in stool, fever
    InvestigationsKidney stonesUrinary tract infection (UTI), pyelonephritisUrine analysis, imaging studies (CT, ultrasound)Pain management, hydrationRelieve pain, promote stone passageHave you had any previous kidney stones? Do you have a history of UTIs?Severe pain, vomiting, fever
    ManagementDiverticulitisDiverticulosis, colon cancerColonoscopy, blood testsAntibiotics, bowel restTreat infection, prevent complicationsDo you have a history of diverticulitis? Have you noticed any changes in your bowel habits?Fever, abdominal tenderness, blood in stool

    History Questions:

    1. Can you describe your pain? Where is it located?
    2. What triggers your pain? Do you have a history of similar pain?
    3. Do you have any abdominal tenderness? Have you noticed any changes in your bowel habits?
    4. Have you had any previous surgeries or medical conditions that may be related to your pain?
    5. Do you have a family history of similar conditions?
    6. Have you noticed any other symptoms such as nausea, vomiting, or fever?
    7. Do you have any allergies or sensitivities to medications?
    8. Have you traveled recently or been exposed to anyone with a similar illness?

    Red Flags:

    1. Severe pain
    2. Vomiting
    3. Fever
    4. Black tarry stools
    5. Difficulty swallowing
    6. Weight loss
    7. Blood in stool
    8. Abdominal tenderness
    9. Recent travel or exposure to someone with a similar illness

    Rationale:

    1. Acute appendicitis: The patient's symptoms and physical examination findings suggest acute appendicitis, which requires prompt surgical intervention.
    2. Peptic ulcer disease: The patient's history of peptic ulcers and symptoms suggest a recurrence, which can be managed with antacids and proton pump inhibitors.
    3. Inflammatory bowel disease (IBD): The patient's symptoms and physical examination findings suggest IBD, which requires a colonoscopy and treatment with aminosalicylates and corticosteroids.
    4. Kidney stones: The patient's symptoms and imaging studies suggest kidney stones, which can be managed with pain management and hydration.
    5. Diverticulitis: The patient's symptoms and physical examination findings suggest diverticulitis, which requires antibiotics and bowel rest.

    Note: This is just a sample template and table, and you should adjust it according to the specific patient and condition you are presenting. Additionally, this is not an exhaustive list of questions or red flags, and you should always consider the patient's individual needs and circumstances.

  3. User

    summarise the text for me; “Before you can have the procedure, you must give your written consent. This will confirm that you understand the risks and agree to proceed with the procedure.”

    “Before the procedure, you will be offered a local anaesthetic throat spray or a sedative to make you more comfortable.”

    “A local anaesthetic throat spray will make your throat and mouth feel numb, it will reduce the gag reflex and make the procedure easier and more comfortable.”

    “If you have a sedative, you are awake, but it relaxes you and helps you to feel calm. This will be given through an intravenous needle in your arm. You shouldn’t drive for 24 hours after, so make sure you have someone to pick you up and can stay with you after the procedure until the effects have fully worn off.”

  4. Meta Assistant

    Here's a summary:

    Before undergoing the procedure, you'll need to give written consent, confirming you understand the risks. To make the procedure more comfortable, you'll be offered:

    • A local anaesthetic throat spray to numb your throat and mouth, reducing the gag reflex
    • A sedative to help you relax and feel calm, given through an IV needle (note: if you choose this option, you won't be able to drive for 24 hours and will need someone to pick you up and stay with you until the effects wear off)

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.