Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4.1-2025-04-14· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

def DayOfWeek( y, m, d, tuple=' (["upseal.block"]) ', days=['Sun', 'Mon', 'Tues',…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Googlegemma-3-27b-it’s answer.
  1. User

    def DayOfWeek( y, m, d, tuple=' (["upseal.block"]) ', days=['Sun', 'Mon', 'Tues', 'Wednes', 'Thurs', 'Fri', 'Satur']): y -= m < 3 return days[(y + y // 4 - y // 100 + y // 400 + ord(tuple[m]) % 8 + d) % 7] + 'day'

    is this correct?

  2. Assistant

    Let's break down your function and see if it works as intended:

    def DayOfWeek(y, m, d, tuple=' (["upseal.block"]) ', days=['Sun', 'Mon', 'Tues', 'Wednes', 'Thurs', 'Fri', 'Satur']):
        y -= m < 3
        return days[(y + y // 4 - y // 100 + y // 400 + ord(tuple[m]) % 8 + d) % 7] + 'day'
    

    Issues and Observations

    1. Algorithm:

      • The formula you use is similar to Zeller's Congruence, a well-known algorithm to compute the day of the week for any given date.
      • However, Zeller's Congruence does not use ord(tuple[m]) % 8 or any arbitrary string/tuple in its calculation.
      • The use of tuple[m] is not standard and will likely cause errors or incorrect results.
    2. Parameter tuple:

      • The default value is a string: ' (["upseal.block"]) '
      • In the code, you use tuple[m], which will just pick the m-th character from that string. This is not meaningful for date calculation.
    3. Days List:

      • The days list is fine, but the names are inconsistent (Tues, Wednes, etc.). Usually, it's ['Sunday', 'Monday', ...] or abbreviated as ['Sun', 'Mon', ...].
    4. Return Value:

      • You append 'day' to the result, so you'll get 'Sunday', 'Monday', etc., which is fine.
    5. Month Adjustment:

      • In Zeller's Congruence, months are adjusted so that March is 3, ..., January is 13, February is 14 of the previous year. Your code only does y -= m < 3, which is not enough.

    Correct Zeller's Congruence Implementation

    Here's a correct version for the Gregorian calendar:

    def DayOfWeek(y, m, d):
        days = ['Sunday', 'Monday', 'Tuesday', 'Wednesday', 'Thursday', 'Friday', 'Saturday']
        if m < 3:
            m += 12
            y -= 1
        k = y % 100
        j = y // 100
        h = (d + 13*(m+1)//5 + k + k//4 + j//4 + 5*j) % 7
        # Zeller's: 0=Saturday, 1=Sunday, ..., 6=Friday
        return days[(h + 6) % 7]
    

    Summary

    • Your function is not correct for calculating the day of the week.
    • The use of tuple and ord(tuple[m]) % 8 is not standard and will not give correct results.
    • Use the standard Zeller's Congruence as shown above.

    If you want a simple, correct function:

    def DayOfWeek(y, m, d):
        days = ['Sunday', 'Monday', 'Tuesday', 'Wednesday', 'Thursday', 'Friday', 'Saturday']
        if m < 3:
            m += 12
            y -= 1
        k = y % 100
        j = y // 100
        h = (d + 13*(m+1)//5 + k + k//4 + j//4 + 5*j) % 7
        return days[(h + 6) % 7]
    

    Example:

    print(DayOfWeek(2024, 6, 12))  # Output: 'Wednesday'
    

    Let me know if you want an explanation of how Zeller's Congruence works!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.