In Python I am subclassing from a generic class. To the sub-class I'd like to add…
- User
In Python I am subclassing from a generic class. To the sub-class I'd like to add another Generic. May I do it like this:
X = TypeVar("X") Y = TypeVar("Y") class Super(Base[X], Generic[Y]):
Assistant
In Python, when you're subclassing from a generic class and want to add another generic type parameter, your approach is almost correct, but there's a more conventional way to do it. Here's how you should structure it:
from typing import Generic, TypeVar X = TypeVar("X") Y = TypeVar("Y") class Base(Generic[X]): pass class Super(Base[X], Generic[Y]): passThis is correct and will work as expected. However, there's a more common pattern where you combine all the generic parameters in a single
Genericat the subclass level:class Super(Base[X], Generic[X, Y]): passThis second approach is often preferred because:
- It makes all generic parameters explicit in the subclass
- It's more consistent with how generic classes are typically defined
- It makes it clearer that the subclass is generic over both X and Y
Both approaches are technically correct, but the second one is more conventional. The choice between them depends on whether you want to:
- Keep X as inherited from the base class (first approach)
- Explicitly declare all generic parameters in the subclass (second approach)
If you're using Python 3.7+, you can also use the more concise syntax:
class Super(Base[X], Generic[X, Y]): ...Or if you're using Python 3.12+, you can use the even simpler:
class Super[X, Y](Base[X]): ...
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.