Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash-lite-preview-06-17-thinking· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Who would you consider the GOAT of Dota 2?

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4.1-2025-04-14’s answer.
  1. User

    Who would you consider the GOAT of Dota 2?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    That's the million-dollar question in the Dota 2 community, and honestly, there's no single, universally agreed-upon answer! The title of "GOAT" (Greatest Of All Time) is highly subjective and depends heavily on what criteria you value most.

    Here are the players most frequently brought up in the GOAT conversation and the arguments for them:

    1. N0tail (Johan Sundstein):

      • Argument: The only player to win The International twice (TI8 and TI9) as the captain and position 5 support of OG. He built one of the most legendary rosters from scratch, fostering incredible team synergy and resilience. His leadership, game understanding, and ability to elevate his teammates are unparalleled.
      • Counter-argument: While a phenomenal leader and support player, perhaps not as mechanically dominant individually in core roles compared to others at their peak.
    2. ana (Anathan Pham):

      • Argument: The star carry player for both of OG's TI-winning rosters. Known for his incredible mechanical skill, ability to play a vast number of heroes in the carry role, and performing under immense pressure. His unique approach and clutch factor are legendary.
      • Counter-argument: Has taken significant breaks from the professional scene, impacting his longevity compared to others.
    3. JerAx (Jesse Vainikka):

      • Argument: The other half of OG's TI-winning support duo alongside N0tail. Revolutionized the position 4 support role with his aggressive playstyle, innovative item builds, and incredible teamfight impact. Also retired briefly and returned, showcasing immense dedication.
      • Counter-argument: Similar to N0tail, his impact is often seen as enabling the team, potentially overshadowing pure individual "carry" stats.
    4. Topson (Topias Taavitsainen):

      • Argument: The midlaner for OG's TI victories. Famous for his incredibly unconventional, high-risk, high-reward playstyle, often picking "off-meta" heroes and dominating the midlane. His ability to create space and win games seemingly out of nowhere is remarkable.
      • Counter-argument: His style can be volatile, and consistency outside of his peak TI runs is debated by some.
    5. Puppey (Clement Ivanov):

      • Argument: Incredible longevity and consistency. Won the first TI (TI1) with Natus Vincere and has captained Team Secret to numerous major victories over many years. He's known for his drafting prowess, strategic mind, and ability to adapt across different metas and rosters. He's arguably the most influential captain in Dota history.
      • Counter-argument: Only one TI win compared to OG's core, and hasn't won another TI despite many close calls and dominant periods with Secret.
    6. KuroKy (Kuro Takhasomi):

      • Argument: Another player with immense longevity and a TI win (TI1 with Na'Vi). Captained Team Liquid to a dominant TI7 victory and consistently kept his teams competitive for years. Known for his versatility (playing multiple roles at a high level) and calm leadership.
      • Counter-argument: Similar to Puppey, only one TI win as a player, though multiple finals appearances as captain.

    Why it's hard to pick just one:

    • Different Eras: Dota has changed drastically. Comparing players from different metas is difficult.
    • Roles: How do you compare a carry's impact to a position 4 support's impact?
    • Team vs. Individual: Is the GOAT the best individual player, or the best leader who achieved the most?
    • Peak vs. Longevity: Is it the player who reached the highest peak, or the one who stayed at the top the longest?

    Conclusion:

    If you value unprecedented achievement and team success, the OG core of N0tail, ana, JerAx, and Topson have the strongest claim due to their two TI wins.

    If you value longevity, leadership, innovation across eras, and sustained impact, Puppey is arguably the strongest contender. KuroKy also falls into this category.

    Ultimately, it's a debate with several valid viewpoints, and each of these players has etched their name into Dota 2 history in a significant way.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.