Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Claudeclaude-3-5-sonnet-20241022· AnthropicHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I want to create an MtG Arena draft helper (to help in the drafting phase by suggesting…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.0-flash-001’s answer.
  1. User

    I want to create an MtG Arena draft helper (to help in the drafting phase by suggesting picks). I want an AI/LLM to read xmage/forge mtg open source implementations (preferably xmage) and either simulate mtg games itself, or create a program that will do that. The AI (or program created by the AI) will not use GUI etc. but rather the code (since xmage/forge are open source) to be able to simulate games faster and should also be able to self-learn (either by starting with the repo AI or with cold-start or something else). Drafts on MtG arena usually consist of single sets of about 220-350 unique cards (if I'm not wrong). Also, I wonder if a draft assistant can be extrapolated purely through simulated games (as opposed to also simulating the drafting section). The games should probably be best-of-1 as well, since I don't think there is any particular reason to have many games with the exact same decks as opposed to random individual games. Keep in mind I have very little computer science knowledge. I won't be using 17lands data. I probably don't want to hard-code any arbitrary heuristic.

    Can you do this?

  2. Claude Assistant

    Let me break this down and explain what I can help with, as well as the challenges involved:

    First, I want to clarify that while I can help you plan this project and provide guidance, I cannot directly read or access the XMage/Forge codebases - you would need to share relevant code snippets with me to help analyze them.

    This is an ambitious project that combines several complex components:

    1. Game Simulation Engine
    • Using XMage's codebase to simulate MTG games
    • Removing GUI elements for faster simulation
    • Handling all game rules and card interactions
    1. Machine Learning Component
    • Training an AI through self-play
    • Learning card evaluations for draft picks
    • Reinforcement learning to improve over time
    1. Draft Assistant Interface
    • Taking the learned card evaluations
    • Providing pick recommendations during actual drafts

    Some key considerations:

    1. Is this feasible? Yes, but it's a significant undertaking. Similar projects exist (like RoboRosewater for card generation), but they typically use large datasets and established heuristics.

    2. Technical Challenges:

    • Extracting game logic from XMage while maintaining functionality
    • Creating an efficient simulation environment
    • Implementing machine learning that can actually learn meaningful card evaluations
    • Handling the complexity of MTG rules and interactions

    Would you like me to elaborate on any of these aspects or focus on a specific part to start with? For someone with limited CS knowledge, we might want to break this down into smaller, more manageable pieces.

    Also, regarding your question about extrapolating draft picks purely through simulated games: While possible, it might be suboptimal because draft decisions involve factors beyond pure game performance (like signals from other drafters, deck composition, etc.). What are your thoughts on this?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.