Construct a portfolio of vix options that replicates the return of a forward start…
- User
Construct a portfolio of vix options that replicates the return of a forward start variance swap on the S&P 500
- Assistant
Replicating the return of a forward-start variance swap using VIX options is a sophisticated task that involves understanding both the variance swap and VIX option pricing dynamics. Here’s a structured approach to constructing such a portfolio.
🎯 Objective
Construct a static or semi-static portfolio of VIX options that replicates the payoff of a forward-start variance swap on the S&P 500.
🔧 Step 1: Understand the Forward-Start Variance Swap
A variance swap pays off the difference between realized variance over a period and a fixed strike (variance strike). A forward-starting variance swap begins at a future date ( T_1 ) and ends at ( T_2 ).
Payoff at ( T_2 ):
[ \text{Payoff} = N \cdot \left( \frac{1}{T_2 - T_1} \int_{T_1}^{T_2} \sigma_t^2 dt - K^2 \right) ]
Where:
- ( N ): Notional
- ( \sigma_t^2 ): Realized instantaneous variance
- ( K^2 ): Strike variance
- ( T_1 ): Start time
- ( T_2 ): End time
The fair strike for a forward-start variance swap is the implied forward variance, often derived from VIX futures.
📈 Step 2: Relate VIX Options to Variance
The VIX is the square root of the implied 30-day variance. VIX options are European-style and their prices embed expectations of future VIX levels, which relate to SPX variance.
Let:
- ( V(t,T) ): VIX at time ( t ) with expiry ( T )
- ( VIX^2 \approx \sigma^2 )
We can use VIX options to infer expectations about future variances.
🛠️ Step 3: Replication Strategy Using Static Portfolio of VIX Options
We aim to replicate the forward variance ( \mathbb{E}{t}[ \frac{1}{T_2 - T_1} \int{T_1}^{T_2} \sigma_u^2 du ] ), conditional on information at time ( t \leq T_1 ).
Since VIX options are written on VIX (not directly SPX variance), we need to:
✅ Approximate SPX forward variance using VIX futures and options
Method: Static Replication with VIX Call Options
We construct a portfolio of out-of-the-money VIX call options to approximate the integral of expected future variance.
🧮 Framework: Breeden-Litzenberger + VIX Futures
From Breeden-Litzenberger, the risk-neutral density of VIX at maturity ( T ) is:
[ q(VIX_T) = e^{r(T-t)} \cdot \frac{\partial^2 C}{\partial K^2} \bigg|_{K=VIX_T} ]
Where ( C ) is the price of a European call option on VIX.
Expected future VIX squared (variance) is:
[ \mathbb{E}[VIX_T^2] = \int_0^\infty VIX_T^2 \cdot q(VIX_T) dVIX_T ]
But we want expected future SPX variance, not VIX squared. Since VIX ≈ ( \sqrt{\sigma^2} ), we need to carefully translate this.
However, in practice, we assume:
[ \mathbb{E}t[\sigma{T_1:T_2}^2] \approx \mathbb{E}t\left[ \frac{1}{T_2 - T_1} \int{T_1}^{T_2} VIX_u^2 du \right] ]
This is an approximation — a better route is to model the joint dynamics of VIX and SPX, but for replication, we proceed as follows:
🧱 Step 4: Construct the Portfolio
Choose a set of VIX call options expiring at ( T_2 )
Let’s construct a discrete approximation of the integral:
[ \int_{T_1}^{T_2} VIX_u^2 du \approx \sum_{i=1}^n w_i \cdot \mathbb{E}t[VIX{T_i}^2] ]
Where:
- ( T_i ) are dates between ( T_1 ) and ( T_2 )
- Weights ( w_i = \frac{T_{i+1} - T_i}{T_2 - T_1} )
But since we only have VIX options expiring at fixed maturities (e.g., monthly), we approximate:
[ \int_{T_1}^{T_2} VIX_u^2 du \approx (T_2 - T_1) \cdot \mathbb{E}t[VIX{T_1}^2] + \text{adjustments} ]
This is not exact, but we can proxy:
[ \text{Expected forward variance} \approx \mathbb{E}t[VIX{T_1}^2] + \text{convexity adjustment} ]
But this ignores the dynamic evolution of VIX between ( t ) and ( T_1 ). So instead, we use the following practical method:
✅ Practical Static Replication (Harvard-Style Static Replica)
- At time ( t \leq T_1 ), consider VIX options expiring at ( T_2 )
- Buy a strip of VIX call options struck at-the-money (ATM) or slightly out-of-the-money
- Compute the weighted average of their expected payoffs, discounted back
More formally:
- Let ( C(K_i, T_2) ) be the market price of a VIX call option struck at ( K_i ), expiring at ( T_2 )
- The second moment of VIX is inferred from these option prices:
[ \mathbb{E}[VIX_{T_2}^2] \approx \sum_i \Delta K_i \cdot (C(K_i) + C(K_{i-1})) / 2 ]
But we want expectation of ( VIX_u^2 ) for ( u \in [T_1, T_2] ). Since VIX is not Markovian across maturities, this is not exact.
Instead, assume:
[ \mathbb{E}t \left[ \int{T_1}^{T_2} VIX_u^2 du \right] \approx (T_2 - T_1) \cdot f(T_1, T_2) ]
Where ( f(T_1, T_2) ) is the forward variance implied from VIX futures:
[ f(T_1, T_2) = \frac{F_{T_2}^2 \cdot (T_2 - t) - F_{T_1}^2 \cdot (T_1 - t)}{T_2 - T_1} ]
But this uses VIX futures, not options.
So we refine:
✅ Final Construction via Static VIX Option Portfolio
To replicate forward-start variance swap payoff using only VIX options, do the following:
Step 1: Use VIX options expiring at ( T_2 )
Buy a strip of OTM calls and sell a strip of OTM puts, or vice versa, to match the variance exposure.
Step 2: Construct a portfolio that mimics the integrated variance
Define:
- Buy ( \Delta K ) quantity of call options at strikes ( K_i ), expiring at ( T_2 )
- Price each call ( C(K_i, T_2) )
- Compute the second moment:
[ \widehat{Var}(VIX_{T_2}) \approx \sum (K_i^2 \cdot C(K_i)) - \left( \sum (K_i \cdot C(K_i)) \right)^2 / \sum C(K_i) ]
But again, this is for VIX^2, not SPX variance.
Step 3: Translate to SPX variance via convexity adjustment
Empirical studies (e.g., Carr-Wu) show that:
[ \mathbb{E}t[VIX{T_1}^2] \approx \mathbb{E}t[\sigma{T_1:T_2}^2] + \text{term structure adjustment} ]
Thus, a practical static approximation:
- Compute the implied forward VIX^2 from VIX futures curve:
[ f_{VIX}(T_1, T_2) = \frac{F_{T_2}^2 (T_2 - t) - F_{T_1}^2 (T_1 - t)}{T_2 - T_1} ]
- Use VIX options expiring at ( T_2 ) to compute the variance premium:
Buy ATM VIX calls and puts to replicate variance:
[ \Pi = \sum_{i} C(K_i, T_2) - \text{matching puts or variance swap strike} ]
- Scale by ( (T_2 - T_1) ) and adjust to match the desired variance strike ( K^2 )
✅ Simplified Static Portfolio (Summary)
To replicate a forward-start variance swap with start ( T_1 ) and end ( T_2 ):
-
Compute forward VIX^2 using VIX futures: [ f_{VIX}(T_1, T_2) = \frac{F_{T_2}^2 (T_2 - T_1) - F_{T_1}^2 (T_1 - T_1)}{T_2 - T_1} ] (Simplified; usually ( F_{T_1} ) is known at ( t \leq T_1 ))
-
Buy a calendar spread of VIX options, e.g.:
- Long OTM calls struck near ( \sqrt{f_{VIX}(T_1, T_2) + K^2} )
- Short corresponding puts (or vice versa)
-
Adjust weights to match the variance strike ( K^2 )
-
The present value of this portfolio approximates the forward-start variance swap payoff.
Alternatively, and more accurately:
✅ Dynamic (or Semi-Static) Approach via Variance Futures
If allowed, the best replication is to use VIX variance futures or forward-starting VIX variance swaps, but assuming only VIX options are allowed:
✅ Final Answer: Static Portfolio Construction
Here is a concrete example of a static portfolio:
Inputs:
- Forward start: ( T_1 )
- Maturity: ( T_2 )
- Variance strike: ( K^2 )
- Current time: ( t )
Steps:
-
Observe VIX futures prices: ( F_{T_1}, F_{T_2} )
-
Compute implied forward variance:
[ \hat{K}{VIX}^2 = \frac{F{T_2}^2 (T_2 - t) - F_{T_1}^2 (T_1 - t)}{T_2 - T_1} ]
- Compute the desired forward SPX variance:
[ \hat{K}^2 = \text{Target forward SPX variance} ]
(Note: mapping between VIX^2 and SPX variance requires convexity adjustment.)
-
Construct a VIX option strip:
- Buy calls and puts on VIX expiring at ( T_2 )
- Choose strikes symmetrically around ( \sqrt{\hat{K}_{VIX}^2} )
- Compute the cost of the portfolio that gives exposure to ( \mathbb{E}[VIX_{T_2}^2] )
-
Scale and shift the portfolio to match the variance delta to ( \hat{K}^2 )
-
The initial cost of this portfolio approximates the forward-start variance swap price.
⚠️ Caveats
- Exact replication is not possible due to:
- VIX and SPX not being perfectly correlated
- VIX options being on volatility, not variance
- Stochastic volatility and jumps
- This is an approximation, suitable for trading desk hedging or exotics modeling
📘 References
- Carr & Wu (2004): "Time-changed Lévy processes and option pricing"
- Demeterfi et al. (1999): "How to use variance swaps"
- Dupire (1994): "Pricing with smile"
- Gatheral (2006): "The Volatility Surface"
Would you like a numerical example with real VIX futures and option prices?
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.
Identical first prompt
- claude-3-7-sonnet-20250219-thinking-32kCompare side by side →
- gemini-2.5-pro-preview-05-06Compare side by side →
- mistral-medium-2505Compare side by side →
- claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022Compare side by side →
- qwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinkingCompare side by side →
- o4-mini-2025-04-16Compare side by side →
- qwen3-30b-a3bCompare side by side →
- claude-opus-4-20250514Compare side by side →
- gemma-3-27b-itCompare side by side →