Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Kimikimi-k2-0711-preview· Moonshot AIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Is it possible to create proxy geometry from a fractured object in Houdini?

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Googlegemma-3-27b-it’s answer.
  1. User

    Is it possible to create proxy geometry from a fractured object in Houdini?

  2. Kimi Assistant

    Yes, absolutely — in Houdini, you can create proxy geometry from a fractured object, and it's a common workflow for optimization, collision, or rendering purposes.

    Here’s a general approach using RBD Fracture or Voronoi Fracture:


    ✅ Method 1: Use the "Assemble" SOP to Create Packed Primitives

    1. Fracture your object (e.g., using a Voronoi Fracture SOP).
    2. Add an Assemble SOP:
      • Enable "Create Packed Geometry".
      • This turns each piece into a packed primitive, which is essentially a proxy.
    3. You can now:
      • Use these packed pieces as low-res proxies in simulations.
      • Swap them with high-res geometry at render time using material stylesheets or instance attributes.

    ✅ Method 2: Use "Convex Decomposition" for Collision Proxies

    1. After fracturing, use the RBD Convex Decomposition SOP:
      • This generates convex hulls (low-res proxies) for each fractured piece.
      • Ideal for collision geometry in RBD sims.
    2. You can export these convex hulls as your proxy geometry.

    ✅ Method 3: Manually Create Low-Res Proxies

    1. After fracturing, use a PolyReduce SOP or Remesh SOP to simplify each piece.
    2. Use Name or piece attributes to keep track of which proxy belongs to which high-res piece.
    3. Use Packed Edit or Transform Pieces to align proxies with high-res geometry later.

    ✅ Bonus: Use "Packed Edit" for Proxy Swapping

    • You can use Packed Edit SOP or s@instancefile attribute to swap between high-res and low-res versions at render or sim time.

    Summary Table

    PurposeTool/Node UsedOutput Type
    Sim proxyRBD Convex DecompositionConvex hulls
    Render proxyAssemble + Packed PrimsPacked geometry
    Manual proxyPolyReduce / RemeshLow-res meshes
    Proxy swappingPacked Edit / instancefileAttribute-driven

    Let me know if you're using Karma, Mantra, or USD — the proxy workflow can vary slightly depending on the renderer.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.