Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.0-flash-001· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I'm working on custom sentence transformer model (also experiment with custom poolers…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-sonnet-4-20250514’s answer.
  1. User

    I'm working on custom sentence transformer model (also experiment with custom poolers like attantion pooling using cls as query). I'm using 'instruct' approach using prefixes for query and passages. currently I have some options: include the instruct part (prefix is structured like "prefix words :\n") in the pooling as normal tokens. exclude everything that came before the ":", or using the embedding of the prefix in some way. please help me to brainstorm ideas for this third option

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, let's brainstorm some ways to leverage the embedding of the prefix in your custom sentence transformer with an instruct approach. We want to go beyond just treating it as regular tokens or ignoring parts of it. Here are some ideas, categorized for clarity:

    I. Direct Embedding Usage (Fusion with Pooled Representation)

    • Concatenation/Combination with Pooled Representation:

      • Concept: Pool the actual passage embeddings as usual (after the prefix), then concatenate or otherwise combine the prefix embedding to the pooled result.
      • Methods:
        • Concatenation: Simplest. final_embedding = torch.cat((prefix_embedding, pooled_passage_embedding), dim=1)
        • Weighted Sum: Learnable weights: final_embedding = alpha * prefix_embedding + (1 - alpha) * pooled_passage_embedding. alpha could be a single scalar learned parameter, or a vector of parameters learned through a small MLP based on the pooled passage embedding.
        • Linear Projection & Addition: Project both prefix and pooled passage embeddings to the same dimensionality and add them: final_embedding = linear_prefix(prefix_embedding) + pooled_passage_embedding. linear_prefix is a linear layer. This allows dimensionality reduction or adjustment.
        • Gated Combination: Use a gate mechanism to control how much of each embedding is used: gate = sigmoid(linear_gate(torch.cat((prefix_embedding, pooled_passage_embedding), dim=1))) then final_embedding = gate * prefix_embedding + (1 - gate) * pooled_passage_embedding. linear_gate is a linear layer.
      • Rationale: Allows the model to explicitly incorporate information about the instruction/task into the final representation. The weighted or gated versions provide a mechanism to dynamically adjust the influence of the prefix based on the content of the passage.
    • Residual Connection:

      • Concept: Similar to a ResNet block, add the prefix embedding to the pooled passage embedding.
      • Method: Project the prefix embedding to the same dimensionality as the pooled passage embedding using a linear layer. Then add them: final_embedding = pooled_passage_embedding + linear_prefix(prefix_embedding).
      • Rationale: Ensures the prefix information is always present, while allowing the model to learn modifications to it based on the passage.

    II. Attention-Based Injection of Prefix Knowledge

    • Prefix Embedding as Attention Bias:

      • Concept: Modify the attention weights in your custom attention pooling layer to be influenced by the prefix embedding.

      • Method: When calculating attention scores between each passage token embedding and the CLS embedding, add a value derived from the prefix embedding to each attention score.

        • For example:
          1. Calculate the attention score score_i between passage token i and the CLS embedding.
          2. Project the prefix embedding to a scalar: prefix_influence = linear_projection(prefix_embedding)
          3. Add this to the score: modified_score_i = score_i + prefix_influence
          4. Proceed with the softmax and weighted sum to calculate the pooled embedding.
        • Alternatively, project the prefix embedding to a vector the same length as the passage, and add each element to the corresponding attention scores.
      • Rationale: Guides the attention mechanism to focus on aspects of the passage that are relevant to the instruction specified in the prefix.

    • Prefix Embedding as Query Bias (for Attention Pooling):

      • Concept: Modify the query used in your attention pooling layer.
      • Method: Instead of just using the CLS embedding as the query, combine the CLS embedding and the prefix embedding.
        • Options:
          • query = CLS_embedding + linear_prefix(prefix_embedding)
          • query = torch.cat((CLS_embedding, prefix_embedding), dim=1) (and project to correct dimensionality if needed).
          • Use attention again: query = attention(CLS_embedding, prefix_embedding).
      • Rationale: Changes the perspective from which the passage embeddings are being viewed. If the prefix instructs "Summarize the following," this modified query might focus the attention on the key points for summarization.

    III. Multi-Task Learning/Auxiliary Loss

    • Reconstruction Loss:

      • Concept: Add an auxiliary task to predict the prefix embedding from the pooled passage embedding.

      • Method:

        1. Pool the passage embedding using your method.
        2. Add a linear layer to project the pooled embedding to the same dimensionality as the prefix embedding.
        3. Calculate a loss function (e.g., Mean Squared Error) between the predicted prefix embedding and the actual prefix embedding.
        4. Add this auxiliary loss to the main loss (contrastive/triplet loss).
      • Rationale: Forces the model to learn representations that contain information about the prefix, improving its ability to follow instructions.

    • Prefix Classification:

      • Concept: If you have a discrete set of prefixes (e.g., "Summarize", "Translate", "Question Answering"), treat it as a classification problem.

      • Method:

        1. Pool the passage embedding using your method.
        2. Add a classification layer to predict the prefix class.
        3. Calculate cross-entropy loss.
        4. Add this to your main loss.
      • Rationale: Encourages the model to create distinct representations for different instructions, which should improve performance on specific tasks.

    IV. Prefix as a Feature Vector

    • Learnable Prefix Vectors:
      • Concept: Instead of embedding the prefix text directly, maintain a learnable embedding vector for each prefix.
      • Method:
        • Create a dictionary mapping prefixes to embedding vectors.
        • During training, look up the prefix embedding and use it in one of the above methods (combination, attention bias, etc.).
        • The advantage here is that it becomes much easier to quickly test new prefix scenarios during runtime.

    Key Considerations and Implementation Tips:

    • Normalization: Before combining embeddings (e.g., concatenation or addition), consider normalizing them to have similar magnitudes. This can prevent one embedding from dominating the others. Layer Normalization or L2 Normalization are good choices.
    • Linear Projections: Use linear layers liberally to adjust the dimensionality of embeddings before combining them. This allows the model to learn the optimal way to represent the information.
    • Experimentation: The best approach will depend on your specific dataset and model architecture. Try different combinations of these techniques and carefully evaluate the results.
    • Hyperparameter Tuning: The weights for combining losses (e.g., the weight for the auxiliary loss) will need to be tuned.
    • Initialization: Consider initializing the linear layers with small weights to avoid instability at the beginning of training.
    • Debugging: Visualize the attention weights and embedding spaces to understand how the model is learning to use the prefix information.

    Which approach to try first?

    I would recommend starting with Concatenation/Weighted Sum or Prefix Embedding as Attention Bias. These are relatively straightforward to implement and can provide a good baseline for comparison. Then explore the more complex methods if needed. Remember to thoroughly evaluate each approach on your specific task. Good luck!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.