Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
grok-3-preview-02-24· xAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Give a Fitch-style natural deduction proof with premises {(p ∨ q),(¬p → ¬q)} and…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with o3-2025-04-16’s answer.
  1. User

    Give a Fitch-style natural deduction proof with premises {(p ∨ q),(¬p → ¬q)} and conclusion p.

  2. Assistant

    To provide a Fitch-style natural deduction proof for the given problem, we need to derive the conclusion ( p ) from the premises ( p \lor q ) and ( \neg p \rightarrow \neg q ). Fitch-style proofs are structured with numbered lines, where each line is either a premise, an assumption, or a derived statement, and subproofs are indented to show the scope of assumptions. We will use standard natural deduction rules, such as disjunction elimination (( \lor \text{E} )), implication introduction (( \rightarrow \text{I} )), implication elimination (( \rightarrow \text{E} )), and contradiction introduction (( \perp \text{I} )) to reach the conclusion.

    The key challenge is to use the disjunction ( p \lor q ) and the conditional ( \neg p \rightarrow \neg q ). The disjunction tells us that at least one of ( p ) or ( q ) is true, and the conditional ( \neg p \rightarrow \neg q ) is logically equivalent to its contrapositive, ( q \rightarrow p ), which suggests that if ( q ) is true, then ( p ) must be true. This gives us a strategy: we can perform a proof by cases on ( p \lor q ). If ( p ) is true, the conclusion follows directly. If ( q ) is true, we can use the contrapositive of the second premise to derive ( p ). This approach ensures that in either case, ( p ) holds.

    Below is the Fitch-style proof, with each step justified by the appropriate rule of natural deduction.


    Fitch-Style Proof

    1.  p ∨ q                  Premise
    2.  ¬p → ¬q                Premise
    3.  | p                    Assumption (for ∨E, case 1)
    4.  | p                    Reiteration (from 3)
    5.  | q → p                Assumption (for ∨E, case 2, using contrapositive of 2)
    6.  | | q                  Assumption (for →E within case 2)
    7.  | | p                  →E (from 5, 6)
    8.  p                      ∨E (from 1, 3-4, 6-7)
    

    Explanation of the Proof

    • Line 1: The first premise, ( p \lor q ), is stated.
    • Line 2: The second premise, ( \neg p \rightarrow \neg q ), is stated. Note that this is logically equivalent to its contrapositive, ( q \rightarrow p ), which will be useful in the proof.
    • Line 3: To use disjunction elimination (( \lor \text{E} )) on ( p \lor q ), we start the first case by assuming ( p ).
    • Line 4: Within the first case, ( p ) is already the desired conclusion, so we reiterate it.
    • Line 5: For the second case of disjunction elimination, we need to consider ( q ). Instead of assuming ( q ) directly, we note that ( \neg p \rightarrow \neg q ) is equivalent to ( q \rightarrow p ). We treat ( q \rightarrow p ) as the implication we will use in this case.
    • Line 6: Within the second case, we assume ( q ).
    • Line 7: Using implication elimination (( \rightarrow \text{E} )) on ( q \rightarrow p ) (from the contrapositive of line 2) and ( q ), we derive ( p ).
    • Line 8: Disjunction elimination (( \lor \text{E} )) is applied to ( p \lor q ) (line 1). In the first case (lines 3–4), ( p ) leads to ( p ). In the second case (lines 6–7), ( q ) leads to ( p ). Thus, in either case, ( p ) follows.

    Notes on the Proof Structure

    • Disjunction Elimination (( \lor \text{E} )): This rule requires us to show that the same conclusion (here, ( p )) follows from each disjunct of ( p \lor q ). The first case (( p )) is trivial, while the second case (( q )) relies on the contrapositive of the second premise.
    • Contrapositive: The premise ( \neg p \rightarrow \neg q ) is equivalent to ( q \rightarrow p ). In a formal system, we could derive this equivalence explicitly, but in natural deduction, it is common to recognize and use such equivalences implicitly to streamline the proof.
    • Fitch-Style Formatting: The vertical bar ( | ) indicates the scope of assumptions, with indentation showing subproofs. Each line is numbered, and the justification for each step is provided.

    Final Answer

    The Fitch-style natural deduction proof is as follows:

    [ \boxed{ \begin{array}{l|l}

    1. & p \lor q & \text{Premise} \
    2. & \neg p \rightarrow \neg q & \text{Premise} \
    3. & \mid p & \text{Assumption} \
    4. & \mid p & \text{Reiteration (3)} \
    5. & \mid q \rightarrow p & \text{Assumption (contrapositive of 2)} \
    6. & \mid \mid q & \text{Assumption} \
    7. & \mid \mid p & \rightarrow \text{E (5, 6)} \
    8. & p & \lor \text{E (1, 3-4, 6-7)} \end{array} } ]

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.