That seemed to evaporate a bit faster than the soil with water. hence I started to add…
- User
That seemed to evaporate a bit faster than the soil with water. hence I started to add dead leaves (because I collect them once I overwater) and put them into the water. The water got like brownish and started to evaporate much slower. That is closing the gap between evaporation (or drying) time between the vessels with soil and vessels without soil.
Do you have other suggestions to simulate the evaporation rate of a vessel with soil? I don't want to add soil to the water vessel though
- Assistant
Here are a few alternative tricks you can try to slow down / “buffer” the evaporation of your plain-water vessel—without having to dump actual soil in it. Each works by one of three basic principles: lowering the water’s vapor pressure, reducing its exposed surface area (or creating a boundary layer), or physically holding onto (adsorbing) the water:
-
Monolayer or oil “skin”
• Drop a very thin layer of food-grade mineral oil (or a few mg of stearic acid powder) on the water surface.
• That immiscible film drastically cuts evaporation by blocking direct air–water exchange.
• You can fine-tune the slowdown by varying the oil amount. -
Dissolved solutes (vapor-pressure lowering)
• Salt (NaCl) or sugar: raising osmotic pressure lowers the water’s vapor pressure.
• Glycerol (or propylene glycol): widely used in fog machines—mix in low % to get a predictable drop in evaporation rate.
• Polyethylene glycol (PEG 200–400): same idea, but even more hygroscopic. -
Porous/membrane “lid”
• Float a disk or swatch of highly wettable material—coffee-filter paper, unglazed ceramic (pumice-type) or a pebble layer—just touching the surface.
• Water wicks into the pores/fibers, but the extra boundary layer slows the net flux.
• Unlike soil, it’s easy to lift out, weigh, and dry separately. -
Bulk adsorbents (but not soil)
• Hydrogel beads (sodium polyacrylate): soak them in advance—then drop them in. They’ll lock up water and release it slowly.
• Coconut-coir fibers or shredded cellulose (e.g. fine paper pulp): these hold moisture like a sponge and reduce the free water surface. -
Partial covers / shields
• Laminate a ring of thin plastic-mesh or insect-screen over the top (raised so it doesn’t pond), creating a still-air gap.
• A “vented lid” fashioned from 3D-printed ring + mesh slows wind-driven evaporation without fully sealing the vessel.
How to proceed
- Pick one approach at a time so you can quantify its effect.
- Run your standard evaporation test (same T, RH, airflow).
- Compare mass loss curves and adjust additive-or-barrier thickness until the plain-water curve overlaps your soil-water curve.
That should let you mimic the soil’s drying profile pretty closely—no dirt required! 🚰🌱
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.