Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

For the following method: [code] Why do I get the following warning if I can assure that…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-5-sonnet-20241022’s answer.
  1. User

    For the following method:

        def _load_model(self) -> Model:
            model: Model = {"vertices": [], "texture_coord": [], "faces": []}
            material: str | None = None
    
            for line in open(f"src/objects/{self._name}/model.obj", "r"):
                if line.startswith("#"):
                    continue
                values = line.split()
                match values[0]:
                    case "v":  # recovering vertices
                        model["vertices"].append(
                            tuple([float(x) for x in values[1:4]])
                        )
                    case "vt":  # recovering texture coordinates
                        model["texture_coord"].append(
                            tuple([float(x) for x in values[1:3]])
                        )
                    case "f":
                        face: list[int] = []
                        face_texture: list[int] = []
                        for v in values[1:]:
                            w: list[str] = v.split("/")
                            face.append(int(w[0]))
                            if len(w) >= 2 and len(w[1]) > 0:
                                face_texture.append(int(w[1]))
                            else:
                                face_texture.append(0)
                        model["faces"].append((face, face_texture, material))
                    case "usemtl" | "usemat":
                        material = values[1]
                    case _:
                        pass
            return model
    

    Why do I get the following warning if I can assure that the list will have the precise amount of elements?

       │ └╴  object.py  2 
       │   ├╴ Argument of type "tuple[float, ...]" cannot be assigned to parameter "object" of type "tuple[float, float, float]" in function "append"
       │   │     "tuple[float, ...]" is not assignable to "tuple[float, float, float]"
       │   │       Tuple size mismatch; expected 3 but received indeterminate basedpyright (reportArgumentType) [142, 25]
       │   └╴ Argument of type "tuple[float, ...]" cannot be assigned to parameter "object" of type "tuple[float, float]" in function "append"
       │         "tuple[float, ...]" is not assignable to "tuple[float, float]"
       │           Tuple size mismatch; expected 2 but received indeterminate basedpyright (reportArgumentType) [146, 25]
    
  2. Assistant

    The warning you are seeing comes from type checking (likely from mypy or Pyright) and is related to how you are constructing tuples with a list comprehension and then passing them to append().

    The core issue:

    tuple([float(x) for x in values[1:4]])
    

    Here, the type checker infers the type as tuple[float, ...] (a tuple of floats of unknown length), because the list comprehension produces a List[float] of variable length, and then tuple() converts it to a tuple of unknown length.

    However, your model dictionary is typed as:

    model: Model = {"vertices": [], "texture_coord": [], "faces": []}
    

    and presumably, Model is defined such that:

    • vertices is a list of tuple[float, float, float]
    • texture_coord is a list of tuple[float, float]

    The type checker expects fixed-length tuples of exactly 3 or 2 floats, but it sees a tuple of variable length (tuple[float, ...]), so it complains about a size mismatch.


    Why does this happen?

    • tuple([float(x) for x in values[1:4]]) creates a tuple from a list, but the type checker cannot guarantee the length is exactly 3 at type-check time.
    • The slice values[1:4] should always have length 3, but the type checker does not analyze the slice length precisely.
    • So it treats the result as tuple[float, ...] (variable length tuple), which is incompatible with tuple[float, float, float].

    How to fix it?

    You need to help the type checker understand the fixed length of the tuple. Here are some ways:

    1. Use explicit tuple construction

    Instead of a list comprehension, explicitly construct the tuple:

    model["vertices"].append((
        float(values[1]),
        float(values[2]),
        float(values[3])
    ))
    

    Similarly for texture coordinates:

    model["texture_coord"].append((
        float(values[1]),
        float(values[2])
    ))
    

    This way, the type checker knows the tuple length is exactly 3 or 2.


    2. Use a cast (less recommended)

    If you want to keep the list comprehension, you can cast:

    from typing import cast
    
    model["vertices"].append(
        cast(tuple[float, float, float], tuple(float(x) for x in values[1:4]))
    )
    

    But this is less clean and bypasses type safety.


    3. Define helper functions

    You can define a helper function that returns a fixed-length tuple:

    from typing import Tuple
    
    def to_vec3(values: list[str]) -> Tuple[float, float, float]:
        return (float(values[0]), float(values[1]), float(values[2]))
    
    def to_vec2(values: list[str]) -> Tuple[float, float]:
        return (float(values[0]), float(values[1]))
    
    # Then use:
    model["vertices"].append(to_vec3(values[1:4]))
    model["texture_coord"].append(to_vec2(values[1:3]))
    

    Summary

    The warning is because the type checker cannot verify the tuple length when you create it from a list comprehension and then convert to a tuple. To fix it, explicitly construct the tuple with fixed length, so the type checker can confirm the exact tuple size.


    If you want, I can help you rewrite the method with these fixes!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.