Please review my hyperparameter sweep (using it to optimize finetuning a Mask2Former on…
- User
Please review my hyperparameter sweep (using it to optimize finetuning a Mask2Former on a custom dataset). rom optuna.pruners import MedianPruner from transformers import Trainer, EarlyStoppingCallback, TrainerCallback
prune bad trials early, but let a few warm up pruner = MedianPruner( n_startup_trials=5, # allow 5 random trials before pruning n_warmup_steps=3, # wait 3 epochs before pruning interval_steps=1 # check every epoch )
model init for sweep (no model= passed to Trainer) def model_init(): return AutoModelForUniversalSegmentation.from_pretrained( CONFIG["pretrained_model"], id2label=CONFIG["id2label"], label2id=CONFIG["label2id"], ignore_mismatched_sizes=True, )
hyperparameter space def hp_space(trial): scheduler = trial.suggest_categorical( "lr_scheduler_type", ["linear", "constant", "cosine_with_restarts", "reduce_lr_on_plateau"] ) space = { "learning_rate": trial.suggest_float("learning_rate", 1e-7, 1e-4, log=True), "weight_decay": trial.suggest_float("weight_decay", 1e-6, 1e-2, log=True), "lr_scheduler_type": scheduler, } if scheduler == "reduce_lr_on_plateau": space["lr_scheduler_patience"] = trial.suggest_int("lr_scheduler_patience", 1, 5) space["lr_scheduler_threshold"] = trial.suggest_float("lr_scheduler_threshold", 1e-4, 1e-2, log=True) return space
callback to log LR class LogLearningRateCallback(TrainerCallback): def on_log(self, args, state, control, logs=None, **kwargs): optimizer = kwargs.get("optimizer", None) if optimizer is None or logs is None: return current_lr = optimizer.param_groups[0]["lr"] logs["lr"] = f"{current_lr:.2e}" # e.g., 3.20e-05
trainer setup trainer = Trainer( model_init=model_init, args=training_args, train_dataset=train_dataset, eval_dataset=val_dataset, data_collator=collate_fn, compute_metrics=compute_metrics_filtered, callbacks=[ EarlyStoppingCallback(early_stopping_patience=CONFIG["early_stopping_patience"]), LogLearningRateCallback(), ], )
run sweep def compute_objective(metrics): loss = metrics.get("eval_loss")
return loss if loss is not None else float("inf") best_run = trainer.hyperparameter_search( direction="minimize", # minimize eval_loss compute_objective=compute_objective, hp_space=hp_space, # search space n_trials=50, # trial count backend="optuna", # use Optuna pruner=pruner, # prune )
print("Best hyperparameters found:", best_run.hyperparameters)
study = trainer.hp_search_backend.study
- Assistant
Your hyperparameter sweep setup for finetuning Mask2Former on a custom dataset looks quite solid and well-structured. Below is a detailed review with some suggestions and clarifications to help you ensure the sweep runs smoothly and efficiently:
1. Pruner Setup
pruner = MedianPruner( n_startup_trials=5, # allow 5 random trials before pruning n_warmup_steps=3, # wait 3 epochs before pruning interval_steps=1 # check every epoch )- Good: Using
MedianPruneris a good choice for early stopping bad trials. - Note:
n_warmup_stepsis in terms of steps, but you mention epochs. Make sure your training loop steps correspond to epochs or adjust accordingly. - Suggestion: If your dataset is large and epochs are long, consider increasing
interval_stepsto avoid overhead.
2. Model Initialization
def model_init(): return AutoModelForUniversalSegmentation.from_pretrained( CONFIG["pretrained_model"], id2label=CONFIG["id2label"], label2id=CONFIG["label2id"], ignore_mismatched_sizes=True, )- Good: Using
model_initallows fresh model initialization for each trial, which is essential for hyperparameter search. - Check: Ensure
AutoModelForUniversalSegmentationis the correct class for Mask2Former or your custom segmentation model. - Tip: If your model is large, this can be slow. Consider caching or using smaller models for initial sweeps.
3. Hyperparameter Space
def hp_space(trial): scheduler = trial.suggest_categorical( "lr_scheduler_type", ["linear", "constant", "cosine_with_restarts", "reduce_lr_on_plateau"] ) space = { "learning_rate": trial.suggest_float("learning_rate", 1e-7, 1e-4, log=True), "weight_decay": trial.suggest_float("weight_decay", 1e-6, 1e-2, log=True), "lr_scheduler_type": scheduler, } if scheduler == "reduce_lr_on_plateau": space["lr_scheduler_patience"] = trial.suggest_int("lr_scheduler_patience", 1, 5) space["lr_scheduler_threshold"] = trial.suggest_float("lr_scheduler_threshold", 1e-4, 1e-2, log=True) return space- Good: Covers key hyperparameters well.
- Suggestion: You might want to add
per_device_train_batch_sizeornum_train_epochsif you want to tune those as well. - Note: Make sure your
training_argscan accept these scheduler parameters dynamically or you handle them in your training loop.
4. Learning Rate Logging Callback
class LogLearningRateCallback(TrainerCallback): def on_log(self, args, state, control, logs=None, **kwargs): optimizer = kwargs.get("optimizer", None) if optimizer is None or logs is None: return current_lr = optimizer.param_groups[0]["lr"] logs["lr"] = f"{current_lr:.2e}" # e.g., 3.20e-05- Good: Useful for tracking learning rate changes during training.
- Note:
on_logis called whenTrainerlogs metrics, so this will add"lr"to your logs. - Suggestion: If you want to track LR per step, consider
on_step_endoron_epoch_end.
5. Trainer Setup
trainer = Trainer( model_init=model_init, args=training_args, train_dataset=train_dataset, eval_dataset=val_dataset, data_collator=collate_fn, compute_metrics=compute_metrics_filtered, callbacks=[ EarlyStoppingCallback(early_stopping_patience=CONFIG["early_stopping_patience"]), LogLearningRateCallback(), ], )- Good: Proper use of callbacks and passing
model_initfor hyperparameter search. - Check: Ensure
training_argsis configured to save checkpoints and evaluate frequently enough for pruning to work well. - Tip: Set
evaluation_strategy="epoch"or"steps"with a reasonable interval.
6. Running the Sweep
def compute_objective(metrics): loss = metrics.get("eval_loss") return loss if loss is not None else float("inf") best_run = trainer.hyperparameter_search( direction="minimize", # minimize eval_loss compute_objective=compute_objective, hp_space=hp_space, # search space n_trials=50, # trial count backend="optuna", # use Optuna pruner=pruner, # prune ) print("Best hyperparameters found:", best_run.hyperparameters) study = trainer.hp_search_backend.study- Good: Custom objective function to minimize validation loss.
- Suggestion: You might want to add some logging or checkpointing inside the sweep to monitor progress.
- Note:
trainer.hp_search_backend.studygives you access to the Optuna study for further analysis.
Additional Recommendations
- Seed Control: Set seeds for reproducibility (
set_seed()fromtransformersorrandom.seed()). - Resource Management: If running on GPUs, monitor VRAM usage to avoid OOM errors during trials.
- Early Stopping: Your early stopping callback and pruner might interact; ensure they complement each other.
- Evaluation Frequency: Make sure evaluation happens often enough for pruning to be effective but not too often to slow down training.
Summary
Your hyperparameter sweep is well-constructed and should work effectively for tuning Mask2Former. Just double-check the scheduler parameters integration, evaluation frequency, and pruning step units. Adding batch size or epoch tuning could further improve your search.
If you want, I can help you write a minimal example or troubleshoot specific issues during the sweep!
- Good: Using
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.