Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

should i buy pixel pro 9 xl if i have samsung s22 but it had used up battery and…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b’s answer.
  1. User

    should i buy pixel pro 9 xl if i have samsung s22 but it had used up battery and charging port?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    That's a classic tech dilemma! Your Samsung S22 with a dying battery and charging port is definitely signaling it's time for a change. The Pixel 9 Pro XL (assuming you mean the upcoming larger Pixel 9 series phone) would be a massive upgrade.

    Let's break down the decision:

    First, Consider Repairing Your S22

    Before jumping to a new phone, get a quote for repairing your S22.

    • Cost: A battery replacement is usually 70−70-100. A charging port replacement might be similar, or slightly more. You could potentially fix both for 150−150-250.
    • Pros of Repair: Much cheaper than a new phone, you keep a familiar device, less e-waste.
    • Cons of Repair: Even with a new battery and port, it's still an S22 – an older phone with an older processor, potentially slower software updates than new Pixels, and a camera that's been surpassed. It won't feel "new" again.

    If the repair cost is significant (e.g., more than $300) or you simply want a new phone, then let's look at the Pixel 9 Pro XL.

    Why the Pixel 9 Pro XL Would Be a Significant Upgrade from the S22

    Assuming the Pixel 9 Pro XL follows the expected trajectory of Pixel flagships and is a direct successor to the 8 Pro, it will be a substantial leap:

    1. Performance: The S22 uses the Snapdragon 8 Gen 1 (or Exynos equivalent). The Pixel 9 Pro XL will feature Google's next-gen Tensor chip (likely Tensor G4). This means:

      • Significantly faster processing: Apps will open faster, multitasking will be smoother, and intensive tasks (like gaming or video editing) will be much more fluid.
      • Improved AI capabilities: Google's Tensor chips are built for on-device AI, powering features like Call Screen, improved speech recognition, Magic Eraser, and more advanced photo/video editing.
      • Better power efficiency: Leading to better battery life, even with the same size battery.
    2. Battery Life: This will be a huge difference. The S22 has a 3700mAh battery, which was never its strong suit, and yours is degraded. The Pixel 9 Pro XL is expected to have a much larger battery (the 8 Pro had 5050mAh), combined with the more efficient Tensor G4. You can expect all-day-plus battery life with ease.

    3. Camera System: While the S22's camera was good for its time, the Pixel 9 Pro XL will be a major upgrade.

      • Hardware: Expect larger sensors, improved ultrawide, and a potentially better telephoto lens (the 8 Pro had 5x optical zoom).
      • Computational Photography: Google's strength. Features like Magic Eraser, Best Take, Photo Unblur, Video Boost, and superior low-light performance (Night Sight) will be significantly better than on your S22.
      • Pro Controls: The Pixel 8 Pro introduced manual controls, which should carry over and improve.
    4. Software Experience:

      • Stock Android: Clean, fluid, and bloatware-free.
      • Fast Updates: Pixels get Android version updates and security patches directly from Google, first.
      • Pixel-Exclusive Features: Google continues to add unique AI and smart features to Pixel phones.
      • Longer Support: Google is now offering 7 years of software and security updates for its flagship Pixels, far beyond what the S22 will receive.
    5. Display: Expect a brighter, potentially higher resolution, and more color-accurate LTPO AMOLED display with a smooth 120Hz refresh rate.

    6. Charging: Faster wired and wireless charging speeds.

    Reasons to Hesitate (Slightly)

    • Cost: Flagship Pixels are expensive. The 9 Pro XL will likely be over $1000 USD.
    • Release Date: The Pixel 9 Pro XL isn't out yet (expected Fall 2024). If you need a phone now, you'd have to consider the Pixel 8 Pro or another option.
    • Samsung vs. Google Ecosystem: If you're deeply ingrained in the Samsung ecosystem (DeX, SmartThings integration, Samsung Pay features, etc.), the switch might require some adjustment.

    Conclusion and Recommendation

    Given your S22's critical issues and the desire for a significant upgrade:

    1. Get a repair quote for your S22. If it's very cheap and you just need a functional phone for a few more months, it's an option.
    2. If you're looking for a substantial upgrade and are willing to spend flagship money, then YES, the Pixel 9 Pro XL would be an excellent choice. It addresses all your S22's current weaknesses (battery, performance) and brings a host of cutting-edge features, especially in camera, AI, and software support.

    It will feel like a night-and-day difference in performance, battery life, and overall user experience compared to your aging S22.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.