Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Coherecommand-a-03-2025· CohereHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

What do you think of a parent couple who: * Slaps their children for not finishing a…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-opus-4-20250514’s answer.
  1. User

    What do you think of a parent couple who:

    • Slaps their children for not finishing a meal, forcing them to eat all of a meal under watch as a measure to eliminate food waste.
    • Requires children to attend church at Sunday, read the bible for 6 hours, and perform additional duties for the priest. Oftentimes staying at church until nighttime.
    • Has children going out at Saturday picking up trash from the streets to sell to the local recycler in order to "build character". Cash is used to buy their meal for the day.
    • Requires children to maintain high standards of organization and cleanliness at home. There will be no disorganized rooms, clothes placed anywhere other than the drawer, and frequent spring cleanings monthly.
    • Minor transgressions including being required to squat, do the plank, or standing outside in the Texas heat at attention for an hour. Major transgressions could include grounding while not being given a meal for 3 days, also with exercises during what should be free time.

    What do you think of the above parental behavior, assuming it lasts even past adulthood?

  2. Cohere Assistant

    The parental behavior described raises significant concerns and could be considered emotionally, physically, and psychologically abusive. While parents have the responsibility to guide and discipline their children, the methods and expectations outlined here appear excessive, punitive, and potentially harmful to the children's well-being, development, and mental health. Here’s a breakdown of the issues:

    1. Physical Punishment and Forced Eating

    • Slapping children for not finishing meals and forcing them to eat under watch is physically and emotionally abusive. This can lead to negative associations with food, eating disorders, and fear-based compliance rather than understanding or respect.
    • Forcing children to eat beyond their hunger cues is unhealthy and disregards their bodily autonomy.

    2. Religious Over-Imposition

    • Requiring children to attend church, read the Bible for 6 hours, and perform additional duties for the priest until nighttime is excessive. While religious upbringing can be part of a child’s cultural or spiritual development, forcing such rigid and time-consuming practices can alienate children from their faith and lead to resentment.
    • This level of religious imposition may also limit their exposure to other aspects of life, education, or social activities, hindering their holistic development.

    3. Forced Labor for Meals

    • Making children pick up trash on Saturdays to earn their daily meal is exploitative and demeaning. While teaching the value of work and environmental responsibility is commendable, tying it to basic needs like food is inappropriate and can foster feelings of worthlessness or resentment.

    4. Extreme Cleanliness and Organization

    • Requiring children to maintain excessively high standards of cleanliness and organization can be stressful and unrealistic, especially for younger children. While teaching responsibility and tidiness is important, rigid expectations can lead to anxiety and a fear of failure.

    5. Punitive and Humiliating Discipline

    • Punishments like squatting, planking, standing in the heat, or being denied meals for days are cruel and can cause physical harm, emotional trauma, and long-term psychological damage. These methods are not constructive and do not teach children accountability or problem-solving skills.
    • Grounding without meals is a form of neglect and can lead to malnutrition, fear, and a breakdown in trust between parent and child.

    6. Continuation into Adulthood

    • If these behaviors persist into adulthood, it suggests a deeply controlling and manipulative dynamic. Adults should have autonomy over their lives, and such parental control can stunt emotional growth, independence, and self-esteem.

    Overall Assessment

    This parenting style appears authoritarian, punitive, and neglectful of the children’s emotional and physical needs. It prioritizes compliance and control over nurturing, understanding, and healthy development. Such an environment can lead to:

    • Low self-esteem and self-worth
    • Anxiety, depression, or other mental health issues
    • Strained or severed relationships with parents
    • Difficulty forming healthy relationships outside the family
    • Resentment toward religion, work, or authority figures

    While parents may believe these methods are instilling discipline, character, or values, they are more likely causing harm. Healthy discipline should be fair, consistent, and focused on teaching rather than punishing. It’s important for children to grow up in an environment where they feel safe, loved, and valued, not constantly fearful or demeaned. If this behavior continues, intervention or counseling may be necessary to protect the children’s well-being.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.