How correlated is the log-prob operalization of confidence to a simulation-based…
- User
How correlated is the log-prob operalization of confidence to a simulation-based approach, where the model generates ~100 responses to the exact same prompt/parameters, which are then averaged?
Assistant
Okay, let's compare the log-probability-based operationalization of confidence (using data from a single generation) with a simulation-based approach (analyzing the distribution of multiple generated responses).
1. Log-Probability Based Confidence (as discussed, e.g., using
sum(logprobs)ormean(logprobs)of the chosen sequence):- What it measures: The model's assessment of the likelihood of the specific token sequence that was generated, based on the conditional probabilities at each step during that single generation.
- Pros: Computationally cheap (single API call if logprobs are returned), reflects the internal probability assigned to the path taken.
- Cons: Indirect measure of confidence in the numerical value itself, doesn't inherently account for the likelihood of alternative plausible sequences (numbers), sensitive to tokenization details, can be harder to interpret intuitively (e.g., comparing logprobs of sequences of different lengths).
2. Simulation-Based Confidence:
- What it measures: The consistency or variability of the model's output when prompted multiple times under sampling conditions (i.e.,
temperature > 0). Confidence is typically operationalized as the inverse of the dispersion (e.g., low standard deviation or variance of the ~100 numerical estimates implies high confidence). - Pros: More direct measure of the model's uncertainty about the final output value (low spread = high certainty), less sensitive to tokenization quirks of any single response, conceptually intuitive (if the model consistently gives the same answer, it seems confident).
- Cons: Computationally expensive (~100 API calls), requires using sampling (non-zero temperature) which means the average response might differ slightly from the single
temperature=0greedy response, the exact dispersion depends on sampling parameters (temperature,top_p, etc.).
How Correlated Are They Expected to Be?
We would expect a positive correlation, but likely not a perfect or extremely strong one.
- Higher log probability (less negative) for the single generated sequence should generally correlate with lower dispersion (e.g., lower standard deviation) in the simulation.
Reasoning for Correlation:
- Both methods are fundamentally tapping into the same underlying probability distribution learned by the model.
- If the probability distribution over next tokens is sharply peaked at each step required to generate a specific number (leading to a high log probability for that sequence), then sampling from that distribution (Method 2) is also highly likely to repeatedly produce tokens leading to that same number, resulting in low dispersion.
- Conversely, if the distribution is flatter at one or more steps (leading to a lower log probability for the chosen sequence), sampling is more likely to pick alternative tokens, leading to a wider range of generated numbers and thus higher dispersion in the simulation.
Reasons Why the Correlation Won't Be Perfect (and might only be moderate):
- Measuring Different Things: Method 1 measures the likelihood of one path. Method 2 measures the spread of outcomes across many paths explored via sampling. A path can be the single most likely (high log prob) but still have several other reasonably likely alternative paths nearby, which sampling (Method 2) would reveal as moderate dispersion.
- Distribution Shape: Log prob only tells you the height of the probability mass at the chosen point(s). Simulation tells you about the width of the peak(s). A very sharp peak gives high confidence in both methods. A slightly broader peak might still have a high maximum (Method 1 looks good) but allow enough variation for sampling to produce noticeable dispersion (Method 2 shows less confidence).
- Sampling Parameters: The results of Method 2 are dependent on the
temperatureand other sampling settings used. Higher temperatures will artificially increase dispersion, weakening the correlation with the log probability derived from a deterministic (temperature=0) or low-temperature generation. The comparison is most meaningful if Method 1 usestemperature=0and Method 2 uses a low-but-non-zero temperature. - Tokenization: Method 1 is sensitive to whether "120" is one token or three. Method 2 looks at the final numerical value, largely ignoring how it was tokenized. This difference can introduce noise.
- Log-Prob Metric Choice: The correlation strength will depend on which log-prob metric is used for Method 1 (sum, mean, first token, etc.).
Conclusion:
The log probability of the generated sequence offers a computationally cheap proxy for the model's certainty in producing that specific output string. The simulation-based approach provides a more direct and often more robust measure of the model's uncertainty regarding the actual numerical estimate, by observing the consistency of its outputs under sampling.
While positively correlated (high sequence log prob generally implies low simulation variance), they are not interchangeable. The simulation approach arguably provides a better operationalization of "confidence" in the estimate itself, at the cost of significantly higher computation. The log-prob method gives a glimpse into the model's internal state for a single generation, which can be useful but needs careful interpretation as a confidence measure.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.