Skip to content
The Chat Archive
gemini-2.5-pro-preview-05-06· Google LMArena Human Preference 140K

do i need to change any settings in windows color management, or just leave it all…

  1. User

    do i need to change any settings in windows color management, or just leave it all default and let displaycal profile loader handle stuff?

  2. Assistant

    Okay, good question! This is where it can get a little confusing, but the modern approach is actually simpler.

    Here's the breakdown:

    1. DisplayCAL Profile Loader (DPL):

      • Its primary job is to load the "calibration" part of your profile (the VCGT data – Video Card Gamma Table) into your graphics card's lookup table (LUT) when Windows starts. This corrects the gamma, white point, and sometimes basic color balance before the OS or applications even see the signal.
      • You should ensure DPL is set to run at startup and loads your most recent calibration. DisplayCAL usually sets this up automatically when you "Install profile & loader."
    2. Windows Color Management (WCM) - The ICC Profile:

      • When DisplayCAL "installs" the profile, it also sets your newly created .ICC or .ICM file as the default color profile for that specific monitor in Windows.
      • You can verify this:
        • Modern way (Windows 11): Settings > System > Display > (select your monitor) > "Color profile". Your DisplayCAL profile (e.g., ASUS_XG27AQDMG_YYYY-MM-DD_D65.icc) should be selected.
        • Classic way (still works): Search for "Color Management" in Windows. Go to the "Devices" tab, select your monitor from the "Device" dropdown. Check "Use my settings for this device." Your DisplayCAL profile should be listed and marked as "(default)".
      • This default ICC profile is what:
        • Color-managed applications (Photoshop, Lightroom, Chrome/Edge in some modes, Firefox, video editors) will use to understand your monitor's color capabilities and display colors accurately.
        • "Automatically manage color for apps (SDR)" (ACM) will use (when it's ON) to convert sRGB content from non-color-managed apps to your monitor's native gamut.
    3. "Automatically manage color for apps (SDR)" (ACM):

      • For daily use: Keep this ON. It's Microsoft's system-level color management for non-HDR, non-color-aware apps. It uses the default ICC profile you set (or DisplayCAL set) to make sRGB content look correct on your wide-gamut display.
      • For profiling/measuring with DisplayCAL: Turn this OFF temporarily. (As you've already done with good results).

    What to "Leave Default" / Not Touch in Classic Color Management:

    • "Advanced" Tab in Color Management: Generally, leave these settings at their system defaults unless you have a very specific, advanced workflow need (which is rare for most users).
      • Device profile: System default (sRGB IEC61966-2.1)
      • Viewing conditions profile: System default (WCS profile for sRGB viewing conditions) These settings are more for legacy compatibility and how Windows internally handles profiles when no specific one is assigned or when converting between different color spaces for non-display devices. For display rendering, the assigned device profile and ACM (if on) are what matter most.

    In summary:

    • Yes, let DisplayCAL Profile Loader handle loading the VCGT calibration at startup.
    • Ensure DisplayCAL has set your generated ICC profile as the default for your monitor in Windows. (It usually does this automatically upon "Install profile").
    • For daily use, keep "Automatically manage color for apps (SDR)" set to ON.
    • You generally don't need to change other settings within the old "Color Management" control panel's "Advanced" tab. The per-device profile assignment is the key.

    So, your intuition is mostly correct: DisplayCAL handles the important bits, and you just need to ensure the ACM switch is used appropriately for daily viewing vs. profiling.

  3. User

    ok so i think colors are slightly more saturated than with the color management on. but not as crazy as before. should i still turn that auto optiono n?

  4. Assistant

    Yes, for most day-to-day use, you should turn "Automatically manage color for apps (SDR)" back ON.

    Here's why what you're seeing makes sense:

    1. What "Automatically manage color for apps (SDR)" (ACM) does:

      • When ON: Windows takes SDR content from non-color-managed apps (which it assumes is sRGB) and converts it to your monitor's native (wide) gamut, using the ICC profile DisplayCAL created. This makes sRGB content look correctly saturated (i.e., not overly saturated) on your wide-gamut display.
      • When OFF: Windows sends the sRGB color values from non-color-managed apps directly to your monitor. Your wide-gamut monitor then displays those sRGB numbers using its wider, more saturated native primaries. This results in sRGB content looking more saturated than it should.
    2. Your Current Observation (ACM OFF after correct profiling):

      • You've now correctly profiled your monitor in its wide gamut mode with ACM OFF. So, DisplayCAL has an accurate understanding of your monitor's full capabilities.
      • With ACM still OFF, when you view sRGB content (like most websites, your desktop, standard apps), it will naturally look more saturated than it would on a standard sRGB monitor, or on your monitor with ACM ON. This is the expected behavior.
      • It's "not as crazy as before" because previously, you might have had a profile that was itself confused (measured with ACM ON), leading to even weirder results when ACM was then turned OFF. Now, the profile is accurate, so the oversaturation is just the "normal" effect of unmanaged sRGB on a wide-gamut display.

    The Correct Workflow Recap:

    • During Profiling with DisplayCAL:

      1. Monitor OSD: Wide Gamut
      2. Windows "Automatically manage color for apps (SDR)": OFF
      3. Run DisplayCAL calibration and profiling.
      4. Install profile (DisplayCAL sets it as default and sets up its loader).
    • For Daily Use (Viewing Content, General Use):

      1. Monitor OSD: Wide Gamut
      2. Windows "Automatically manage color for apps (SDR)": ON
      3. DisplayCAL Profile Loader: Running in the background, loading your VCGT calibration.
      4. Your DisplayCAL ICC profile: Set as the default for the monitor in Windows.

    So, yes, turn "Automatically manage color for apps (SDR)" back ON now.

    This will ensure:

    • Non-color-managed SDR applications (most of what you use daily) look correctly saturated.
    • Fully color-managed applications (Photoshop, Lightroom, DaVinci Resolve, Firefox with color management enabled, etc.) will continue to use the ICC profile directly and display colors accurately, regardless of the ACM switch's state. They "know" your monitor is wide gamut from the ICC profile.

    The slight oversaturation you're seeing with ACM OFF is precisely what ACM is designed to correct for everyday SDR content.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.