what does onu say about it
- User
what does onu say about it
Assistant
The United Nations (UN) does not have a single, unified official position declaring Israel an “apartheid state,” but multiple UN bodies and officials—especially human-rights mechanisms—have repeatedly concluded that some Israeli laws and practices meet the legal definition of apartheid under international law. Below is a concise map of what the UN system has actually said.
-
UN Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory (OPT), incl. East Jerusalem, and Israel (established 2021, renewed 2022 & 2023)
• March 2022 interim report: “There are reasonable grounds to conclude that the Israeli occupation of Palestinian territory is now indefinite and amounts to de facto annexation, and that laws, policies and practices in Israel and the OPT perpetuate a single repressive regime that constitutes the crime of apartheid under the Rome Statute and the Apartheid Convention.”
• September 2022 follow-up: reiterated that apartheid is ongoing and called on states to cease aiding or assisting its maintenance.
• March 2023 report to the Human Rights Council: documented systematic racial discrimination and domination and recommended referral to the International Criminal Court (ICC). -
UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the OPT
• Michael Lynk (2017-2022) and his successor Francesca Albanese (2022-present) have both stated that Israeli rule over Palestinians satisfies the three pillars of apartheid:- an intent to maintain domination by one racial group over another;
- systematic oppression;
- inhumane acts.
• 2022 report to the General Assembly: “Israeli laws and practices in Israel and the OPT cumulatively amount to the crime of apartheid.”
-
UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD)
• December 2019 “early-warning and urgent-action” letter to Israel: expressed alarm that Israeli policies in the OPT “may amount to racial segregation and apartheid.”
• 2022 review: urged Israel to dismantle the regime of systematic racial discrimination. -
UN Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia (ESCWA)
• March 2017 report “Israeli Practices towards the Palestinian People and the Question of Apartheid” (authored by Prof. Richard Falk & Prof. Virginia Tilley): concluded that Israel has established an apartheid regime that dominates the Palestinian people as a whole.
• The report was removed from the ESCWA website under political pressure, but its findings were not retracted by the authors or by ESCWA’s Executive Secretary at the time. -
UN General Assembly resolutions
• No GA resolution has formally declared Israel an “apartheid state,” but annual resolutions (e.g., A/RES/77/25) continue to condemn “all forms of racial discrimination” and reaffirm the applicability of the Apartheid Convention to the OPT. -
UN Secretary-General
• António Guterres has not used the word “apartheid” in official statements, but his annual reports on the OPT increasingly echo the language of the Commission of Inquiry and Special Rapporteur, noting “perpetual occupation,” “discriminatory laws,” and “domination by one group over another.”
Key takeaway
While the UN as a whole has not passed a single binding resolution labeling Israel an “apartheid state,” multiple authoritative UN human-rights mechanisms—including the Commission of Inquiry, the Special Rapporteur, and treaty bodies—have formally concluded that Israeli laws and practices constitute the crime of apartheid under international law.-
- User
alors est ce que israel commet un aparteid
Assistant
En droit international, la réponse la plus rigoureuse est :
Oui, selon plusieurs organes onusiens et experts indépendants, Israël commet le crime d’apartheid tel que défini par le droit international (Convention de 1973 et Statut de Rome de la CPI).
Cette conclusion n’est pas une simple opinion politique : elle repose sur des rapports officiels de mécanismes onusiens dotés d’un mandat juridique précis :
-
Commission d’enquête de l’ONU sur la Palestine (2022-2023)
« Il existe des motifs raisonnables de conclure que le régime israélien dans les territoires palestiniens occupés constitue le crime d’apartheid » (rapports mars 2022, sept. 2022, mars 2023). -
Rapporteur spécial de l’ONU sur les droits humains dans les TPO
Michael Lynk (2022) et Francesca Albanese (2023) ont tous deux conclu que les lois et pratiques israéliennes satisfont aux trois critères juridiques de l’apartheid : domination intentionnelle d’un groupe racial sur un autre, oppression systémique et actes inhumains. -
Comité onusien pour l’élimination de la discrimination raciale (CERD)
Lettre d’alerte rapide de 2019 et examen de 2022 : les politiques israéliennes « peuvent constituer une ségrégation raciale et l’apartheid ». -
Rapport ESCWA (2017)
Bien que retiré sous pression politique, il reste un document onusien officiel concluant qu’Israël a établi « un régime d’apartheid » sur l’ensemble du peuple palestinien.
En résumé
- D’un point de vue juridique onusien, la réponse est oui : des organes compétents de l’ONU ont constaté que le crime d’apartheid est commis.
- D’un point de vue politique, l’Assemblée générale et le Conseil de sécurité n’ont pas adopté de résolution utilisant explicitement le mot « apartheid » ; la question reste donc controversée au niveau intergouvernemental.
Donc, au regard du droit international tel qu’interprété par les experts onusiens mandatés, Israël commet le crime d’apartheid.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.