Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-30b-a3b· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

teach me travelling salesman problem in branch and bound step by step using a very…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.0-flash-001’s answer.
  1. User

    teach me travelling salesman problem in branch and bound step by step using a very indepth step by step example with a state space tree for each node visited thank you

  2. Qwen Assistant

    Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) with Branch and Bound: Step-by-Step Example

    We will solve the TSP for 4 cities (A, B, C, D) with the following symmetric distance matrix:

    ABCD
    A0101520
    B1003525
    C1535030
    D2025300

    Step 1: Initialize the Root Node

    • Path: [A] (start at city A)
    • Cost: 0
    • Lower Bound (LB): Calculated manually as 27.5 (sum of row minima / 2).
      • Row minima: A: 10, B: 10, C: 15, D: 20 → Total = 55 → 55/2 = 27.5

    Step 2: Generate Children of Root Node

    From the root node [A], we branch to the next possible cities (B, C, D):

    Child 1: [A, B]

    • Path: [A, B]
    • Cost: 10 (A→B)
    • LB: 10 + (min cost to visit C, D and return to A) = 10 + 70 = 80
      • Example: B→D→C→A (25 + 30 + 15 = 70)

    Child 2: [A, C]

    • Path: [A, C]
    • Cost: 15 (A→C)
    • LB: 15 + (min cost to visit B, D and return to A) = 15 + 65 = 80
      • Example: C→D→B→A (30 + 25 + 10 = 65)

    Child 3: [A, D]

    • Path: [A, D]
    • Cost: 20 (A→D)
    • LB: 20 + (min cost to visit B, C and return to A) = 20 + 75 = 95
      • Example: D→B→C→A (25 + 35 + 15 = 75)

    State Space Tree:

    Root (LB=27.5)
    ├── [A,B] (LB=80)
    ├── [A,C] (LB=80)
    └── [A,D] (LB=95)
    

    Step 3: Explore [A,B] (LB=80)

    From [A,B], the remaining cities are C and D.

    Child 1: [A,B,C]

    • Path: [A,B,C]
    • Cost: 10 + 35 = 45 (B→C)
    • LB: 45 + (C→D→A) = 45 + 30 + 20 = 95
      • Prune (LB=95 > current best 80)

    Child 2: [A,B,D]

    • Path: [A,B,D]
    • Cost: 10 + 25 = 35 (B→D)
    • LB: 35 + (D→C→A) = 35 + 30 + 15 = 80
      • Valid tour: [A,B,D,C,A] (10 + 25 + 30 + 15 = 80)
      • Update Best Solution: 80

    State Space Tree:

    Root (LB=27.5)
    ├── [A,B] (LB=80)
    │   ├── [A,B,C] (LB=95) [Pruned]
    │   └── [A,B,D] (LB=80) [Solution Found]
    ├── [A,C] (LB=80)
    └── [A,D] (LB=95) [Pruned]
    

    Step 4: Explore [A,C] (LB=80)

    From [A,C], the remaining cities are B and D.

    Child 1: [A,C,B]

    • Path: [A,C,B]
    • Cost: 15 + 35 = 50 (C→B)
    • LB: 50 + (B→D→A) = 50 + 25 + 20 = 95
      • Prune (LB=95 > 80)

    Child 2: [A,C,D]

    • Path: [A,C,D]
    • Cost: 15 + 30 = 45 (C→D)
    • LB: 45 + (D→B→A) = 45 + 25 + 10 = 80
      • Valid tour: [A,C,D,B,A] (15 + 30 + 25 + 10 = 80)
      • Update Best Solution: 80 (same as before)

    State Space Tree:

    Root (LB=27.5)
    ├── [A,B] (LB=80)
    │   ├── [A,B,C] (LB=95) [Pruned]
    │   └── [A,B,D] (LB=80) [Solution Found]
    ├── [A,C] (LB=80)
    │   ├── [A,C,B] (LB=95) [Pruned]
    │   └── [A,C,D] (LB=80) [Solution Found]
    └── [A,D] (LB=95) [Pruned]
    

    Step 5: Explore [A,D] (LB=95)

    • Path: [A,D]
    • Cost: 20 (A→D)
    • LB: 95 > 80 → Prune

    Final State Space Tree

    All nodes are explored. The optimal solution is 80, achieved by two tours:

    1. [A,B,D,C,A]: 10 + 25 + 30 + 15 = 80
    2. [A,C,D,B,A]: 15 + 30 + 25 + 10 = 80

    Key Concepts in Branch and Bound

    1. Branching: Generate children by visiting unvisited cities.
    2. Bounding: Calculate a lower bound for each node to prune suboptimal paths.
    3. Pruning: Eliminate nodes with LB > current best solution.
    4. Optimality: The first solution found may not be optimal, but the algorithm ensures the best solution is found.

    Summary of Nodes Visited

    NodePathCostLBStatus
    Root[A]027.5
    [A,B][A,B]1080
    [A,B,C][A,B,C]4595Pruned
    [A,B,D][A,B,D]3580Solution
    [A,C][A,C]1580
    [A,C,B][A,C,B]5095Pruned
    [A,C,D][A,C,D]4580Solution
    [A,D][A,D]2095Pruned

    This example illustrates how Branch and Bound efficiently explores the TSP solution space, pruning non-optimal paths to find the minimal tour.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.