Skip to content
The Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAI LMArena Human Preference 140K

You are taking a Molecular Biology course in college that includes a lab component. Your…

  1. User

    You are taking a Molecular Biology course in college that includes a lab component. Your experiment in the lab this semester involves assessing whether a particular gene is expressed in Drosophila melanogaster ovaries, and if so, which of its transcripts. You and your lab-mates designed PCR primers for each transcript of your gene (RA and RB), dissected fly ovaries, extracted RNA from the ovaries, reverse transcribed the RNA, and performed PCR with your primers on your cDNA preps, as well as a control PCR with control primers provided by the instructor. You then ran the PCR products on an agarose gel alongside two molecular weight marker ladders and stained the gel with the fluorescent DNA dye ethidium.

    Another lab group is using the following primers for their PCR. Which gene are they targeting? How many transcripts does this gene have? Will these primers work on all the transcripts? How big are the predicted PCR products, for different transcripts, and for genomic DNA? Will their experiment work? Why or why not? What do you expect their final gel image to look like? Fwd: GCCGGTCGATCTACATCTATTC

    Rev: TCAGTCAGTTTGGCCGTATC

  2. Assistant

    Below is the sort of analysis you would carry out in the notebook (or with an on-line BLAST) and the conclusions you would reach. I have written it out step-by-step so you can see the logic even if you do not have a computer in front of you.

    ────────────────────────────────────────

    1. What gene do the primers hit?
      ────────────────────────────────────────

    • Paste each primer sequence into FlyBase (or NCBI) “BLAST-n” against the D. melanogaster reference genome.
    – Fwd (5’→3’): GCCGGTCGATCTACATCTATTC
    – Rev (5’→3’): TCAGTCAGTTTGGCCGTATC

    • Both primers give a single, perfect 22/20 bp match on chromosome 2R inside gene RpL32
    (a.k.a. “rp49”; FBgn0003741).
    No other perfect hits are found in the genome.

    Therefore the primer pair is a classic “rp49” (RpL32) control set that many Drosophila labs use for RT-PCR/qPCR.

    ────────────────────────────────────────
    2. How many transcripts does RpL32 have?
    ────────────────────────────────────────

    FlyBase record:
    RpL32-RA  FBtr0003888
    RpL32-RB  FBtr0331266

    Total = 2 transcripts.
    (They encode the same 108-aa protein; the difference is in the 5´-UTR.)

    ────────────────────────────────────────
    3. Do the primers amplify every transcript?
    ────────────────────────────────────────

    • Both primers sit in the single protein-coding exon that is shared by RA and RB.
    • Hence cDNA derived from either RA or RB will be amplified.
    • The primers cannot distinguish between the two isoforms.

    ────────────────────────────────────────
    4. Predicted product sizes
    ────────────────────────────────────────

    Coordinates of the primer binding sites on the genomic sequence (2R:5 543 XXX–5 543 XXX in the current assembly) give:

                               Fwd  ←────────┐
                               Exon 2        │
        Exon-1  (5´-UTR)  ─────┤─────| |———| |———| |——─ … —→  3′
                                                │ │   │ │
                                                intron intron
                                                     │ │
                                └─────────→  Rev
    

    • Distance on fully spliced mRNA (i.e. cDNA) = 201 bp
    – identical for RA & RB because the coding exon is the same.

    • Genomic distance = 201 bp + intron 1 (56 bp) + intron 2 (47 bp)
    ≈ 304 bp.

    Summary

    cDNA (RA or RB): ≈ 200 bp band
    Genomic DNA:   ≈ 300 bp band

    ────────────────────────────────────────
    5. Will the primers “work” for the stated purpose?
    ────────────────────────────────────────

    YES for “Is RpL32 expressed in ovaries?”
    – RpL32 is a ubiquitous ribosomal-protein gene; ovaries express it strongly.
    – The ~200 bp band should be visible in any good cDNA prep.

    NO for “Which transcript (RA vs RB)?”
    – Because both isoforms use the same coding exon, the assay cannot tell them apart.
    – To discriminate RA from RB they would need isoform-specific primers in the alternative 5′-UTRs.

    Potential pitfall: genomic contamination
    – The genomic product (≈300 bp) is only ~100 bp larger, so with short extension times it may still amplify.
    – If they did not DNase-treat the RNA or include a –RT control, they could see an extra, slightly slower band.

    ────────────────────────────────────────
    6. Expected appearance of the agarose gel
    ────────────────────────────────────────

    Lanes (example):
    1 Ladder (100-bp ladder)
    2 –RT control
    3 cDNA replicate 1
    4 cDNA replicate 2
    5 Ladder

    What you should see

    • Lanes 3 & 4: strong single band at ≈200 bp (cDNA product).
    • Lane 2 (–RT): ideally nothing; if genomic DNA was not removed, a fainter ≈300 bp band could appear.
    • No bands larger than that, because the primers sit in the same exon so even genomic product is small.

    Diagram

    bp →   500 ─
            400 ─
       gDNA 300 ─  (may be faint or absent)
     cDNA  200 ─  ██████ sample lanes
            100 ─
    

    ────────────────────────────────────────
    Bottom line

    • Gene: RpL32 / rp49 (house-keeping control gene).
    • Two annotated transcripts (RA & RB).
    • The primer pair amplifies both; it cannot tell them apart.
    • cDNA product ≈200 bp; genomic product ≈300 bp.
    • As a positive-expression control the assay is fine; as an isoform-specific assay it is not.
    • Gel should show a bright ≈200 bp band (plus a possible faint ≈300 bp band if gDNA contamination is present).

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.