Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash-lite-preview-06-17-thinking· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

How much would it cost to build a 129 story tall building in downtown Edmonton? Be…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-flash’s answer.
  1. User

    How much would it cost to build a 129 story tall building in downtown Edmonton? Be detailed

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, let's break down the potential cost of constructing a hypothetical 129-story skyscraper in downtown Edmonton. This is a highly speculative exercise, as such a building is significantly taller than anything currently built or planned there, presenting unique engineering, logistical, and economic challenges.

    1. Assumptions:

    • Building Height: 129 stories. Let's estimate a height of roughly 450-500 meters (approx. 1500-1650 ft), similar to supertall buildings globally.
    • Building Size: Assume a reasonably large floor plate for a supertall, averaging around 27,000 sq ft (approx. 2,500 sq m) per floor.
      • Total Gross Floor Area (GFA): 129 stories * 27,000 sq ft/story ≈ 3,483,000 sq ft (approx. 323,500 sq m).
    • Building Type: Mixed-use is typical for such heights, potentially including:
      • Retail/Lobby space (lower floors)
      • Office space (mid-levels)
      • Residential condominiums/apartments (upper-mid to high levels)
      • Hotel (potentially mid-levels)
      • Observation decks/restaurants (top levels)
    • Location: Prime downtown Edmonton site, requiring significant land purchase and potentially complex site preparation.
    • Cost Basis: Costs are estimated in Canadian Dollars (CAD) and reflect current (mid-2020s) construction market conditions, adjusted for the complexities of supertall construction. Note that supertall construction costs are significantly higher per square foot than standard high-rises.
    • Finishes: Assume high-quality, modern finishes suitable for office, luxury residential, and hotel components.

    2. Key Cost Components & Estimates:

    • A. Land Acquisition:

      • A site large enough for the foundation and support infrastructure of a 129-story building in downtown Edmonton would be premium.
      • Estimate: 75million−75 million - 200 million CAD (highly variable depending on specific block acquisition and zoning). Let's use $125 million as a mid-point.
    • B. Design, Engineering & Permitting (Soft Costs):

      • Architectural Design: Complex massing, facade design, wind engineering integration, seismic considerations (even if minor in Edmonton, factored into supertall design), vertical transportation strategy.
      • Structural Engineering: Critical for stability, wind sway mitigation, deep foundations, super-structure design. Requires specialists.
      • MEP Engineering: Mechanical (HVAC), Electrical, Plumbing systems scaled and designed for extreme height. Complex vertical risers, pressure control, high-capacity systems.
      • Geotechnical Engineering: Extensive soil analysis for deep foundations.
      • Other Consultants: Facade, wind tunnel testing, vertical transport, environmental, acoustical, fire safety, etc.
      • Permits & Municipal Fees: Significant for a project of this magnitude.
      • Estimate: Typically 8-15% of construction costs for complex projects. Let's estimate 12% of construction costs (detailed below).
    • C. Construction Costs (Hard Costs): This is the largest component, broken down further:

      • i. Site Preparation & Foundation:

        • Demolition (if needed), excavation, shoring.
        • Deep foundations (piles/caissons) extending potentially to bedrock, requiring specialized equipment and techniques. This is extremely costly for supertalls.
        • Estimate: 200−200 - 400 million CAD (due to depth and scale). Let's use $300 million.
      • ii. Superstructure (Core & Frame):

        • Likely a composite structure (steel frame with concrete core, potentially concrete structure).
        • High-strength materials, advanced structural connections, extensive wind bracing.
        • Specialized crane systems (climbing cranes) needed for erection.
        • Cost per sq ft for supertalls is much higher due to structural requirements. Estimate: 450−450 - 750 CAD/sq ft.
        • Calculation: 3,483,000 sq ft * 600/sqft(mid−point)=∗∗600/sq ft (mid-point) = **2,090 million CAD** (approx. $2.1 billion).
      • iii. Building Envelope (Facade):

        • High-performance curtain wall system, potentially double-skin facade elements for thermal/acoustic performance and wind mitigation.
        • Complex geometry, specialized glazing, robust weatherproofing and air sealing.
        • Estimate: 250−250 - 450 CAD/sq ft.
        • Calculation: 3,483,000 sq ft * 350/sqft(mid−point)=∗∗350/sq ft (mid-point) = **1,219 million CAD** (approx. $1.2 billion).
      • iv. Interior Fit-Out:

        • Varies greatly by use (office vs. residential vs. hotel). Assumes high-end finishes for residential/hotel. Includes drywall, ceilings, flooring, millwork, basic MEP distribution within floors. Core washrooms/lobbies included.
        • Estimate: 300−300 - 600 CAD/sq ft.
        • Calculation: 3,483,000 sq ft * 450/sqft(mid−point)=∗∗450/sq ft (mid-point) = **1,567 million CAD** (approx. $1.6 billion).
      • v. Mechanical, Electrical, Plumbing (MEP) & Vertical Transportation:

        • Extensive HVAC systems, high-voltage distribution, complex plumbing risers.
        • Multiple high-speed elevator banks, potentially destination dispatch and sky lobbies. This is a massive cost center in supertalls.
        • Estimate: 350−350 - 700 CAD/sq ft.
        • Calculation: 3,483,000 sq ft * 525/sqft(mid−point)=∗∗525/sq ft (mid-point) = **1,829 million CAD** (approx. $1.8 billion).
      • vi. Specialized Systems:

        • Fire protection (sprinklers, alarms, standpipes), Building Management System (BMS), security systems, IT infrastructure backbone.
        • Estimate: 75−75 - 150 CAD/sq ft.
        • Calculation: 3,483,000 sq ft * 110/sqft(mid−point)=∗∗110/sq ft (mid-point) = **383 million CAD** (approx. $0.4 billion).
      • Total Estimated Construction Cost (Hard Costs):

        • Foundation: $300M
        • Structure: $2,090M
        • Envelope: $1,219M
        • Fit-Out: $1,567M
        • MEP/Elevators: $1,829M
        • Specialty Systems: $383M
        • Subtotal Hard Costs: ~7,388millionCAD(approx.∗∗7,388 million CAD (approx. **7.4 billion**)
    • D. Contingency:

      • Essential for a project of this scale and novelty in Edmonton. Covers unforeseen conditions, design changes, cost overruns. Given the scale, 15-25% is appropriate.
      • Estimate: 20% of Hard Costs.
      • Calculation: 7.4billion∗0.20=∗∗7.4 billion * 0.20 = **1.48 billion CAD**.
    • E. Financing Costs (Interest During Construction):

      • Construction takes several years (likely 5-7 years for a building this size). Interest on the vast sums borrowed adds significantly.
      • Estimate: 10-20% of total costs (Land + Soft + Hard + Contingency). Let's estimate 15%.
      • Calculation: (125M+(0.12∗125M + (0.12 * 7.4B) + 7.4B+7.4B + 1.48B) * 0.15 = (125M+125M + 888M + 7.4B+7.4B + 1.48B) * 0.15 = 9.89B∗0.15=∗∗9.89B * 0.15 = **1.48 billion CAD**.
    • F. Developer Overhead & Profit:

      • The developer's costs for managing the project and their expected profit margin. Typically 15-25% on top of total costs.
      • Estimate: 20% of (Total Costs before Profit).
      • Calculation: (125M+125M + 888M + 7.4B+7.4B + 1.48B + 1.48B)∗0.20=1.48B) * 0.20 = 11.37B * 0.20 = $2.27 billion CAD.

    3. Total Estimated Cost Calculation:

    • Land: $0.125 Billion
    • Soft Costs (Design/Permits @ 12%): $0.888 Billion
    • Hard Costs (Construction): $7.400 Billion
    • Contingency (20%): $1.480 Billion
    • Financing Costs (15%): $1.480 Billion
    • Developer Overhead & Profit (20%): $2.270 Billion
    • Estimated Total Project Cost: ~$13.643 Billion CAD

    4. Refining the Range:

    Given the huge uncertainties and potential cost variations (e.g., actual GFA, specific structural system, market fluctuations over the multi-year build, economic conditions), a reasonable estimated range would be:

    • Low End Estimate: ~$11 Billion CAD
    • High End Estimate: ~$17 Billion CAD

    Therefore, a highly speculative cost estimate for building a 129-story, ~3.5 million sq ft mixed-use skyscraper in downtown Edmonton would likely fall in the range of 11billionto11 billion to 17 billion Canadian dollars.

    Factors Causing Variation:

    • Edmonton Specifics: Lack of existing supertall expertise might increase costs for specialized labour and logistics. City infrastructure upgrades needed to support such a large building.
    • Economic Climate: Inflation, material costs (steel, concrete, glass), and labour costs during the extended construction period.
    • Design Choices: Specific architectural features, facade complexity, interior finish levels.
    • Foundation Conditions: Unexpected geological challenges.
    • Financing Environment: Interest rate fluctuations.
    • Tenant Fit-Outs: If tenants require extensive customisation beyond the base estimate.

    This figure is astronomical compared to typical Edmonton construction projects and would require extraordinary market demand, significant investment, and major approvals to even consider.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.