my supplier wants to remove this clause from my contract "The CONTRACTOR shall release,…
- User
my supplier wants to remove this clause from my contract "The CONTRACTOR shall release, protect, indemnify and hold harmless the COMPANY, from and against any claims, demands, causes of action, liabilities or losses arising from or connected with termination by the COMPANY under this ARTICLE 23.1." what's the risk to me?
Assistant
This clause is a very important protection for your company (the COMPANY). If your supplier (the CONTRACTOR) wants to remove it, it significantly increases your risk.
Let's break down what the clause does and what its removal means for you:
What the Clause Currently Does (Your Protection):
This clause is an indemnification and hold harmless provision. In simple terms, it means that if you terminate the contract with the supplier under Article 23.1, and that termination leads to any kind of legal or financial trouble for your company, the supplier promises to:
- Release: Give up their own right to sue you for issues related to that termination.
- Protect/Hold Harmless: Shield your company from any claims, lawsuits, or liabilities that might arise from other parties (e.g., their subcontractors, employees, or customers) because of that termination.
- Indemnify: Reimburse you for any losses, damages, legal fees, or costs you might incur if you are sued or suffer financial harm because of that termination.
Essentially, it's a "no fault" or "no liability" clause for you when you exercise your specific right to terminate under Article 23.1. It ensures that the act of termination itself (when done under that article) doesn't become a financial or legal burden on your company.
The Risk of Removing This Clause (What you lose):
If this clause is removed, you lose this crucial protection. Here are the specific risks:
-
Supplier Can Sue You for Termination-Related Damages:
- Even if you believe your termination under Article 23.1 is perfectly valid and justified, the supplier could claim "wrongful termination," "breach of contract," "lost profits," or other damages directly related to the termination.
- Without this clause, you would have to defend against such lawsuits, bear all legal costs (lawyers, court fees), and potentially be liable for significant damages if a court rules in the supplier's favor (or even if you settle to avoid prolonged litigation).
-
Exposure to Third-Party Claims:
- If the termination disrupts the supplier's operations and impacts their subcontractors, employees, or other third parties, those parties might try to sue your company directly for damages.
- Without the "protect, indemnify and hold harmless" language, the supplier is no longer obligated to defend you against these claims or cover any losses you incur as a result.
-
Increased Legal Costs and Uncertainty:
- Every termination carries some inherent risk of dispute. This clause helps to mitigate that risk significantly. Removing it means that exercising your right to terminate under Article 23.1 becomes much riskier and potentially more expensive, as you'd be responsible for all costs and liabilities arising from the termination process.
- It creates a chilling effect: you might be more hesitant to terminate, even when justified, due to the potential legal fallout and costs.
Why the Supplier Wants it Removed:
The supplier wants to remove it because they want to preserve their right to sue you or seek compensation if you terminate the contract under Article 23.1. They don't want to waive their claims, and they don't want to be responsible for your legal costs or liabilities if your termination causes them (or others) harm. They are trying to shift the risk from themselves to your company.
Recommendation:
- Do not agree to remove this clause easily. It represents a significant transfer of risk from the supplier to your company.
- Understand their reasons: Ask the supplier why they want to remove it. Their answer might shed light on their intentions.
- Negotiate Alternatives: If they insist, consider negotiating specific carve-outs or limitations rather than outright removal. For example, perhaps they are only willing to indemnify for certain types of claims, or up to a certain monetary limit. However, the current clause is quite strong protection for you.
- Consult Legal Counsel: Before making any changes to your contract, especially concerning liability and termination clauses, it is highly advisable to consult with a legal professional. They can assess the specific context of your contract and business relationship and advise on the best course of action.
In summary, removing this clause would expose your company to significant financial and legal risks should you ever need to terminate the contract under Article 23.1.
- User
They're really hung up about needing to indemnify us even after termination without cause, how can I explain I need to keep this clause in?
Assistant
You're right to be firm on this. It's a critical protection. Here's how you can explain why you need to keep that clause, even for a termination without cause, focusing on the purpose from your company's perspective rather than blaming them.
Key Message: "This clause is about our ability to manage unforeseen liabilities that can arise even from a legitimate termination, not about holding you responsible for our decision to end the contract."
Here are several ways to explain it, choose the ones that resonate most with your relationship and the supplier's understanding:
1. Focus on the Nature of "Termination Without Cause" and Risk Mitigation:
"I understand your concern about indemnifying us when we choose to terminate without cause. From your perspective, you might feel you haven't done anything wrong, and we're simply exercising our right to end the relationship.
However, the purpose of this clause isn't to assign blame for the termination itself. Instead, it's about providing us with essential protection against unforeseen liabilities that can arise from the act of termination, regardless of cause.
Think of it this way: Even a perfectly legitimate termination, exercised under our contractual rights, can sometimes lead to unexpected claims. For example, if your own subcontractors or employees try to pursue claims against us directly, arguing that our termination indirectly affected them. This clause ensures that the primary responsibility for managing the fallout of your operations, relationships, and employees remains with you, the CONTRACTOR, even if the trigger was our 'without cause' termination."
2. Emphasize Clean Breaks and Predictability:
"For us, the ability to terminate 'without cause' is a vital business right, allowing us flexibility to adapt to changing market conditions or strategic needs. When we exercise that right, we need to do so with predictability and a clean break.
This indemnification clause is what ensures that a 'without cause' termination truly is clean for us. Without it, even if we follow all contractual procedures, we could still face unexpected and costly legal challenges or third-party claims. This clause is not about your performance; it's about our ability to manage our business without inadvertently inheriting your operational risks post-termination."
3. It's About Managing Third-Party Exposure, Not Supplier Fault:
"We appreciate your hard work and don't intend to imply fault on your part. The challenge with any contract termination, even a 'without cause' one, is the potential for third-party claims. Your company has its own employees, subcontractors, and possibly suppliers who might feel aggrieved by the contract ending.
This clause ensures that if those parties attempt to pursue claims against our company (even if those claims are ultimately your responsibility), you would step in to protect us. It's about protecting us from being dragged into disputes that originate from your operations, not about punishing you for our decision."
4. Standard Commercial Practice & Risk Allocation:
"While I appreciate your point, this type of indemnification for termination is a standard commercial protection in many complex contracts. It serves to allocate risks appropriately. As the CONTRACTOR, you are in the best position to understand, manage, and mitigate the direct and indirect impacts of your own business operations and employee/subcontractor relationships. We need this assurance that the costs and legal burdens associated with those relationships won't transfer to us simply because we exercised a contractual right."
5. Clarify What "Indemnify" Means in This Context (Reassurance, Not Blame):
"Perhaps there's a misunderstanding of 'indemnify' in this specific context. It doesn't mean we are blaming you for our decision to terminate. What it means is that if, because of our termination, any third party (e.g., your staff, your suppliers) were to sue us, or if you were to make a claim against us for things like lost profit, this clause prevents that. It ensures that our act of termination under Article 23.1 doesn't open us up to new liabilities. It's protection for our decision-making, not a judgment on your performance."
In Summary - How to Deliver the Message:
- Acknowledge their concern first. "I understand why you'd be hesitant..." or "I hear your point about..."
- Pivot to your company's need. "However, from our perspective, this clause is vital because..."
- Focus on risk mitigation, third-party claims, and clean breaks. These are the strongest arguments for "without cause" termination.
- Emphasize it's not about fault. "This isn't about blaming you, but about protecting ourselves from unforeseen legal exposure."
- Be firm but collaborative. "We really need to keep this protection in place for our own operational security and risk management."
Don't back down on this. It's a fundamental clause for your protection. If they insist, it might be a red flag about their understanding of risk or their intentions should you ever need to terminate.
- User
I have this clause "19.12 Maximum Aggregate Liability 19.12.1 The PARTIES herein agree that the CONTRACTOR’s maximum aggregate liability to the COMPANY arising in connection with the CONTRACT or its implementation shall be limited to three (3) times of [(total contract value) or (award value)]. 19.12.2 The limit of liability as set out in Article 19.12.1 above shall not apply to the CONTRACTOR’s liability, of which the CONTRACTOR shall assume unlimited liability: a) Damages to negligence and gross negligence: b) Personal Injury; c) Damage to property: d) Breach of Confidentiality; e) Breach of IPR; f) Breach of Privacy; g) Breach of Article 43 (or applicable law).” COMPANY seeks bidder agreement and acceptance of the above proposal." but my supplier wants to put a super cap on privacy, I don't want this. Help me formulate a negotiation strategy
Assistant
This is a critical point of negotiation. Your supplier wants to limit their exposure to potentially massive damages, while you, as the COMPANY, need to protect yourself from the catastrophic consequences of a data privacy breach.
Here's a breakdown of why you need to maintain unlimited liability for privacy and a strategy to negotiate this:
Why You Need Unlimited Liability for Privacy Breaches:
-
Regulatory Fines are Unlimited (from a contractual cap perspective):
- Laws like GDPR (EU), CCPA/CPRA (California), and other global privacy regulations impose severe, statutory fines for breaches. These fines are often calculated as a percentage of global turnover (e.g., 4% under GDPR) or a fixed high amount (€20 million for GDPR), whichever is higher.
- No contractual cap will protect your company from these regulatory fines. If a breach occurs on the supplier's watch, but involves your customer data, regulators will still come after you (the data controller). If your supplier's liability is capped at 3x contract value (which could be minor compared to fines), you'll be left holding the bag for the difference.
-
Third-Party Lawsuits and Class Actions:
- Beyond regulatory fines, data breaches inevitably lead to lawsuits from affected individuals (customers, employees). These can be class-action lawsuits with potentially billions in damages.
- Again, a contractual cap on your supplier's liability won't limit what a court can award against your company. You need the supplier to indemnify you fully for these, as they are directly responsible for the security failure.
-
Reputational Damage is Unquantifiable:
- A significant data breach can severely damage your brand, erode customer trust, and lead to lost business for years. While not directly indemnified by the clause, the full liability acts as a stronger deterrent for the supplier to prevent such breaches.
-
Deterrent Effect & Incentive for Security:
- Unlimited liability provides the strongest possible incentive for your supplier to invest in robust cybersecurity measures, employee training, and ongoing compliance. A cap, even a high one, can inadvertently reduce this critical focus, as they know their maximum financial exposure.
-
Ultimate Responsibility Lies with You (as Data Controller):
- As the entity that collects and determines the use of the data, you (the COMPANY) bear the ultimate legal and ethical responsibility for that data. You're entrusting this critical asset to your supplier. You cannot afford for them to fail in protecting it without full recourse.
-
It's an Insurability Issue for Them, Not a Risk for You to Absorb:
- The supplier's concern is almost certainly about their ability to get insurance coverage for unlimited liability. This is a common challenge, but it's their operational risk, not yours. They must ensure they have adequate cyber liability insurance.
Negotiation Strategy:
Your goal is to be firm but collaborative. You need to educate them on why this is non-negotiable for you, rather than just stating "no."
Phase 1: Acknowledge & Empathize (but don't concede)
- "I understand your concern about unlimited liability, especially regarding privacy. Data breaches are a significant risk for any company, and we appreciate you raising this."
- "We recognize that ensuring full coverage for such liabilities can be a challenge from an insurance perspective."
Phase 2: State Your Firm Position and Justify (The "Why")
- "However, for us, retaining unlimited liability for privacy breaches is absolutely non-negotiable and a fundamental requirement for this contract."
- Leverage Regulatory & Third-Party Risk: "The reason for this is critical: contractual caps simply do not apply to the regulatory fines and third-party liabilities we could face. If a privacy breach occurs while the data is in your care, we as the data controller would be subjected to potentially massive fines from regulators (e.g., GDPR fines can be up to 4% of global annual turnover or €20M, whichever is higher), as well as class-action lawsuits from affected individuals. These figures can easily far exceed any contractual cap, even 3x the contract value."
- Emphasize Your Company's Exposure: "We cannot absorb that difference. The ultimate responsibility for data protection lies with us, and we must ensure that any party handling our sensitive data is fully accountable for the consequences of a breach."
- Highlight Deterrent/Incentive: "Furthermore, unlimited liability ensures the necessary incentive for you to invest fully in robust security measures and compliance, which is paramount when handling sensitive data."
- "This is Your Risk to Manage": "This is fundamentally a risk management and insurance issue for your company. You are best placed to manage and insure against the risks inherent in processing sensitive data."
Phase 3: Propose Alternatives (if any, focusing on mitigation, not capping liability)
- Mandatory Cyber Liability Insurance: "Instead of capping your liability, our requirement is that you secure and maintain a robust Cyber Liability Insurance policy, naming [Your Company Name] as an additional insured party. We would need to review the policy details to ensure it covers these types of privacy-related liabilities and meets an adequate coverage threshold (e.g., X million EUR/USD per incident, and Y million EUR/USD aggregate). This is the industry standard for managing this specific type of risk."
- Why this works: This addresses their core concern (insurability) without reducing your protection. It shifts the financial burden to an insurer, which is precisely what liability clauses are meant to do.
- Enhanced Security Audits/SLA: "To further mitigate this risk for both parties, we are open to strengthening the security requirements in the contract, perhaps including more frequent security audits, penetration testing requirements, or stricter data handling SLAs. Our goal is to prevent breaches from happening in the first place."
- Why this works: Shows you're willing to collaborate on prevention, which is better than dealing with consequences, but doesn't compromise on the liability for those consequences.
- No Other Concessions: (Use this if they are being very difficult) "Given the critical nature of data privacy, our position on unlimited liability for privacy breaches is firm. This means we will not be able to offer concessions on this point, or trade it for other clauses in the contract."
Phase 4: Conclude Firmly
- "We value this partnership, but this is a critical protection for our business and our customers. We cannot proceed with a contract that places our company at unacceptable risk for privacy breaches."
- "We are confident that a reputable contractor like yours, which handles sensitive data, would have, or be able to obtain, the necessary insurance coverage for this standard level of liability."
Key Talking Points Summary:
- "Regulatory fines are not capped by contracts."
- "Third-party lawsuits are not capped by contracts."
- "This is about your insurance and risk management, not our willingness to absorb your risk."
- "Unlimited liability drives necessary security investment."
- "Our brand and customer trust depend on this."
Be prepared to walk away if they absolutely refuse. The risk of uncapped privacy breach liability to your company is immense, potentially existential, and far outweighs any benefit of working with this specific supplier if they are unwilling to accept full accountability for data they process on your behalf.
-
- User
Am I covered for indirect losses?
Assistant
Based on the clauses you've provided, the answer is: You are not explicitly covered for indirect losses in a general sense, but for certain specific breaches (like privacy, confidentiality, and IPR), the supplier's liability is unlimited (meaning if indirect losses are proven, they would not be capped).
Let's break down why:
1. The General Rule for Indirect/Consequential Damages:
- In contract law, "indirect losses" (also known as "consequential damages," "special damages," or "loss of profits/revenue/goodwill") are typically not recoverable unless they are explicitly stated as recoverable in the contract, or if they were reasonably foreseeable by both parties at the time the contract was made.
- Conversely, many contracts will include a clause explicitly excluding liability for indirect or consequential damages for both parties.
- Your contract does NOT have a clause explicitly stating that indirect/consequential damages ARE recoverable from the supplier.
2. Analysis of Your Clauses:
- 19.12.1 (Maximum Aggregate Liability): This clause simply sets a cap (3x contract value) on the total amount of liability the CONTRACTOR has to you. It doesn't define what types of damages (direct or indirect) are included in that liability. If indirect losses were generally recoverable under the contract, this cap would apply to them.
- 19.12.2 (Unlimited Liability Exceptions): This is the crucial part for your question. For the specific breaches listed (a-g), the CONTRACTOR assumes unlimited liability.
- d) Breach of Confidentiality: Breaches of confidentiality often lead to indirect losses (e.g., loss of competitive advantage, loss of market share, loss of future revenue due to leaked trade secrets).
- e) Breach of IPR (Intellectual Property Rights): IPR breaches frequently result in indirect losses (e.g., lost royalties, lost sales from knock-offs, damage to brand value).
- f) Breach of Privacy: As we discussed, privacy breaches almost exclusively lead to massive indirect losses (regulatory fines, class-action lawsuits, reputational damage, loss of customer trust and future business).
What This Means for You:
- For breaches not listed in 19.12.2 (e.g., general service failure, delays that don't fall into negligence): You would likely struggle to recover indirect losses because the contract doesn't explicitly state they are recoverable. Your recovery would generally be limited to direct damages (and then capped at 3x contract value).
- For breaches listed in 19.12.2 (e.g., Privacy, Confidentiality, IPR):
- If you can prove that these breaches caused you indirect losses (e.g., lost profits, regulatory fines, reputational damage, costs of managing class action lawsuits), then the CONTRACTOR's liability for these specific indirect losses would be unlimited.
- This is a strong position to be in for these critical areas. It means the supplier can't simply pay out 3x the contract value and walk away from a multi-million dollar privacy fine or a devastating loss of market share due to a confidential data leak.
The Missing Piece / Potential Risk:
The primary "risk" here is the ambiguity for non-excepted breaches. The contract doesn't clearly state whether indirect losses are recoverable at all. While courts might interpret "losses" broadly in some contexts, relying on interpretation is less secure than explicit language.
How to Improve Your Coverage (If you want general indirect loss coverage):
If you want to ensure you can recover indirect losses for any breach of the contract (not just the ones in 19.12.2), you would need to add a clause that explicitly states something like:
- "The CONTRACTOR shall be liable for all direct and indirect losses suffered by the COMPANY arising out of or in connection with any breach of this CONTRACT by the CONTRACTOR."
- However, if you add this, then the 3x cap in 19.12.1 would also apply to these indirect losses (unless you also added this general "all breaches" indirect loss recovery to the unlimited list in 19.12.2, which is unlikely to be accepted by the supplier).
Conclusion for Your Current Situation:
You have good, unlimited coverage for indirect losses arising from Privacy, Confidentiality, and IPR breaches, which are arguably the most financially devastating types of indirect losses. This is a significant strength.
For other, more "standard" breaches, your ability to recover indirect losses is less certain due to the lack of explicit contractual language permitting their recovery in the first place. You would have to argue they were foreseeable, or covered by the general term "losses," which is less robust.
- User
I have this original clause "Liquidated Ascertained Damages (Article 45) Fixed Price Based • One (1%) percent of the WO value calculated based on number of days delayed from committed date of delivery by milestones / outcome due to issues from the Contractor. LAD shall not exceed ten (10%) percent of the total WO value." , my supplier wants this instead "“Fixed Price Based • One (1%) percent of the WO value calculated based on the number of days delayed from committed date of delivery by milestones / outcome due to issues from the Contractor. LAD for each milestone or outcome shall not exceed ten (10%) percent of the total WO value and the total cumulative LAD under each WO shall be capped at twenty (20) percent of the total WO value.” what's the risk to me?
Assistant
This change proposed by your supplier carries a significant risk to your company (the COMPANY), primarily by doubling the maximum allowable delay period (in terms of LAD payout) before the supplier hits their cap, thus increasing your uncompensated losses and diluting their incentive for on-time delivery.
Let's break down the original clause, the proposed changes, and the associated risks:
Original Clause (Your Position):
- Daily LAD Rate: 1% of the Work Order (WO) value per day of delay.
- Trigger: Delays caused by the Contractor's issues, based on committed milestone/outcome delivery dates.
- Maximum Cap: LAD for the entire Work Order (WO) cannot exceed 10% of the total WO value.
What this means: This clause provides a clear, strong incentive for the Contractor to deliver on time. If they delay, they pay 1% per day up to a maximum of 10% of the WO value. After that 10% cap is hit, you can no longer claim LAD for further delays on that WO. The 10% cap usually represents about 10 days of delay (for a single 10% max delay).
Proposed Clause (Supplier's Position):
- Daily LAD Rate: Same (1% of WO value per day).
- Trigger: Same (Contractor's issues).
- New Caps:
- "LAD for each milestone or outcome shall not exceed ten (10%) percent of the total WO value."
- "and the total cumulative LAD under each WO shall be capped at twenty (20) percent of the total WO value.”
The Risks to You with the Proposed Clause:
-
Doubled Maximum Delay Tolerance (before cap is hit):
- The most significant change is the increase of the total cumulative LAD cap from 10% to 20% of the WO value.
- This effectively means the supplier can delay for twice as long (approximately 20 days instead of 10 days, assuming 1% per day) before they reach their maximum financial penalty.
- Risk: This directly increases the maximum potential delay period you will experience before the LAD ceases to accrue.
-
Increased Uncompensated Losses:
- Liquidated Ascertained Damages (LADs) are typically a pre-agreed estimate of your losses due to delay, designed to avoid the difficulty of proving actual damages in court. However, LADs very rarely cover your entire loss from a delay (e.g., lost revenue, missed market opportunities, extended internal project costs, penalties from your own customers).
- Risk: If the supplier can delay for twice as long before hitting their cap, your actual losses incurred due to the extended delay will be significantly higher, and a larger portion of those losses will be uncompensated by the LAD. The gap between your actual losses and the LAD collected will widen considerably.
-
Weakened Incentive for Timely Delivery:
- The primary purpose of LAD is to serve as a strong financial incentive for the Contractor to perform on schedule.
- Risk: By doubling the cap, the supplier's financial incentive to avoid delays is significantly diluted. They might view a longer delay as more "acceptable" or less financially punitive, potentially impacting their project planning, resource allocation, and overall commitment to the original timeline. They might calculate that paying 20% LAD is still more profitable than investing more to prevent severe delays.
-
Complexity of "Per Milestone" Cap (Minor Risk/Benefit):
- The "LAD for each milestone or outcome shall not exceed ten (10%) percent of the total WO value" is a secondary cap. This means that even if the overall 20% cap hasn't been hit, a single, severely delayed milestone can't accrue more than 10% of the total WO value in LAD.
- Risk: This part is generally less impactful than the overall cap. In some scenarios, if a very small milestone causes massive, prolonged delays, this might cap the LAD for that specific milestone, but it would then still allow other delayed milestones to contribute to the overall 20% cap. It's more of a clarification to prevent a single component from consuming the entire LAD pool, but the overall cap is the critical number.
Summary of Risk:
The supplier's proposed change shifts a significant amount of delay risk and financial burden onto your company. While you would theoretically collect more LAD if delays are severe enough to hit the 20% cap, the trade-off is that your projects could be delayed for much longer, leading to greater overall disruption and uncompensated actual losses for your business.
Negotiation Strategy:
-
Be Firm on the 10% Overall Cap:
- Reiterate the purpose of LAD: "The purpose of LAD is to provide a clear and strong incentive for on-time delivery and to offer a reasonable pre-estimate of damages, not a full compensation for all losses. A 10% cap provides that necessary incentive without being punitive."
- Highlight the impact on your business: "Increasing the cap to 20% significantly extends the period of acceptable delay for you, but for us, it means prolonged project timelines, increased internal costs, and a greater risk of missing our own deadlines or market opportunities. The financial impact on us from extended delays goes far beyond the LAD."
- Emphasize your actual losses: "While LAD is helpful, it never fully compensates us for the true cost of delays. Doubling your cap means we will absorb a much larger portion of those uncompensated losses."
- Standard industry practice: "A 10% LAD cap is a widely accepted industry standard that balances the need for accountability with commercial reasonableness."
-
Challenge their rationale:
- Ask why they need a 20% cap. Are they anticipating significant delays? Is their project planning unreliable? This can reveal their underlying concerns.
-
Avoid Compromise if Possible:
- Given that 10% is already a standard and usually adequate deterrent, moving to 20% is a very large leap. Try to hold the line at 10%.
- If you absolutely must compromise: Could you meet somewhere in the middle (e.g., 12-15%) only if you get something else significant in return (e.g., tighter reporting, stronger performance incentives, a commitment to specific remediation for delays, or a higher performance bond)? Do not give up 10% easily.
-
Focus on Project Success:
- Frame the discussion around successful project delivery for both parties. "Our shared goal is to complete this project on time. A robust LAD clause, with a clear and reasonable cap, helps ensure we both stay aligned on that goal."
Your current 10% cap is a valuable protection. Do not concede to a 20% cap lightly, as it significantly increases your exposure to costly delays.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.