If you were tasked with brainstorming foundational concepts for a framework to build a…
- User
If you were tasked with brainstorming foundational concepts for a framework to build a universal setting agnostic tabletop pen and paper role-playing game, where would you start?
- Assistant
If I were tasked with brainstorming foundational concepts for a framework to build a universal, setting-agnostic tabletop pen-and-paper RPG, I'd start by focusing on the most essential elements that make an RPG work across any genre or setting. The goal here is to create a flexible, modular system that can adapt to everything from high-fantasy quests to cyberpunk heists, steampunk adventures, or even historical dramas, without being bogged down by specific lore or rules. This approach draws from successful universal RPGs like GURPS, Fate, or Savage Worlds, but I'd aim for originality and simplicity to make it accessible for both designers and players.
I'd begin with a structured brainstorming process, starting from the abstract and moving toward concrete mechanics. Here's how I'd approach it step by step, based on my knowledge of game design principles:
1. Start with the Core Philosophy and Design Goals
Before diving into mechanics, I'd establish the foundational philosophy of the game. This sets the tone for all decisions and ensures the framework remains true to its universal nature. Brainstorming here would involve asking big-picture questions:
-
What makes an RPG universal and setting-agnostic? The system should prioritize adaptability, player agency, and storytelling over rigid rules. For example, mechanics should be modular, allowing users to swap in custom elements (e.g., a magic system for fantasy or hacking rules for sci-fi) without breaking the core engine.
-
Key design goals to brainstorm:
- Simplicity and Accessibility: Aim for rules that are easy to learn and teach, so new players can jump in quickly. This could mean using a small set of core dice or mechanics that scale with complexity.
- Flexibility: Ensure the system supports a wide range of playstyles, from narrative-driven roleplaying to tactical combat. For instance, mechanics should handle both gritty realism (e.g., detailed injury systems) and cinematic action (e.g., heroic feats).
- Replayability and Customization: Encourage players and GMs to modify the game. Brainstorm ways to include "building blocks" like trait cards, skill trees, or setting-specific modules that can be mixed and matched.
- Balance and Fairness: Focus on mechanics that promote balanced gameplay across settings, avoiding overpowered elements in one genre that don't translate well to others.
- Fun and Engagement: Core principles should emphasize collaboration, creativity, and emotional investment. For example, reward players for innovative problem-solving, not just combat prowess.
Brainstorming Tip: I'd use a mind map or a simple list to capture these goals. Start with a central node for "Universal RPG Framework" and branch out to sub-themes like "Core Mechanics," "Player Agency," and "Adaptability." This helps identify conflicts early, such as balancing simplicity with depth.
2. Define the Core Resolution System
Once the philosophy is set, I'd move to the heart of any RPG: how actions are resolved. This is the engine that drives the game, and for a universal system, it needs to be straightforward yet versatile. I'd brainstorm a resolution mechanic that's easy to adapt to different settings.
- Key Elements to Brainstorm:
-
Dice or Randomness Mechanic: Choose a base system for handling uncertainty. Options could include:
- A dice pool system (e.g., roll a number of dice based on skills and attributes, with successes determined by thresholds) for granularity.
- A single-die system (e.g., d20 or d100) for simplicity, with modifiers based on character traits.
- Narrative-driven alternatives, like using cards or tokens, to emphasize storytelling over math.
- Make it scalable: For example, a "core roll" formula like [Attribute + Skill + Modifiers] vs. a Difficulty Number, which can be flavored for any setting (e.g., Strength + Melee for sword fights, or Intelligence + Hacking for digital intrusions).
-
Success and Failure Mechanics: Brainstorm how outcomes are determined and what they mean. Include degrees of success (e.g., critical hits, partial successes) to add nuance. For universality, tie this to narrative consequences—e.g., a failed roll could lead to complications that drive the story, regardless of the setting.
-
Conflict Types: Cover all major types of interactions:
- Physical Conflicts: Combat, chases, or physical challenges.
- Social Conflicts: Persuasion, deception, or negotiation.
- Mental/Exploration Conflicts: Puzzle-solving, investigation, or survival.
- Ensure the system is agnostic by using generic terms (e.g., "Challenge Rating" instead of "Monster AC") that can be redefined per setting.
-
Brainstorming Tip: I'd prototype simple resolution examples for different scenarios. For instance, test a roll for a fantasy knight disarming a trap versus a sci-fi hacker bypassing security. This reveals how well the mechanic adapts and where adjustments are needed.
3. Develop a Flexible Character Creation System
Characters are the heart of any RPG, so the framework needs a character system that's generic enough to fit any setting but robust enough to allow for personalization. I'd brainstorm ways to make this modular and scalable.
- Key Elements to Brainstorm:
-
Attributes and Stats: Start with a small set of core attributes (e.g., Physical, Mental, Social) that can be interpreted broadly. For example:
- Physical could cover strength, agility, or endurance.
- Mental could include intelligence, perception, or willpower.
- Social could handle charisma, empathy, or leadership.
- Make them setting-agnostic by using descriptive names or allowing players to rename them (e.g., "Brawn" in fantasy vs. "Augmented Strength" in cyberpunk).
-
Skills and Abilities: Use a skill list that's broad and customizable. Brainstorm categories like Combat, Knowledge, Craft, and Social, with skills that can be flavored (e.g., "Weapon Proficiency" could be swords in medieval settings or firearms in modern ones). Include a point-buy or template system for character creation to allow for quick builds.
-
Traits and Backgrounds: Incorporate traits that add flavor and mechanical benefits. For universality, make traits modular—e.g., a "Heroic Background" trait could give bonuses in high-stakes situations, whether it's a knight's code or a spy's training. Brainstorm ways to include advantages and disadvantages that tie into the narrative.
-
Progression System: Decide how characters improve over time. Options could include experience points, milestone advancements, or narrative triggers. Ensure it's flexible so that progression feels rewarding in any setting (e.g., leveling up skills after a space battle or a diplomatic intrigue).
-
Brainstorming Tip: I'd create character archetypes as test cases, like a "Warrior," "Scholar," or "Diplomat," and adapt them to multiple settings. This helps ensure the system is versatile and highlights areas where more customization is needed, such as adding genre-specific perks.
4. Incorporate Modularity for Setting Adaptation
Since the RPG is setting-agnostic, I'd focus on making the framework highly modular. This means designing it so that GMs and players can easily add or remove elements without overhauling the core system.
- Key Elements to Brainstorm:
-
Setting Modules: Create "plug-and-play" components, such as:
- World-Building Tools: Generic rules for creating settings, like economy systems, technology levels, or magic frameworks that can be toggled on or off.
- Genre-Specific Rules: Brainstorm optional subsystems, e.g., a sanity mechanic for horror, vehicle combat rules for sci-fi, or divine intervention for fantasy. These should integrate seamlessly with the core resolution system.
- Custom Content Creation: Include guidelines for users to design their own elements, like new skills, items, or adversaries. For example, a "Threat Builder" tool that scales enemy difficulty based on the core stats.
-
Narrative Integration: Ensure mechanics support storytelling. Brainstorm ways to blend mechanics with narrative, such as fate points or story tokens that players can use to influence outcomes, adapting to any genre's tone.
-
Scalability: Address different game scales, from one-on-one duels to massive battles or world-spanning events. Use abstract mechanics for larger conflicts to keep things manageable.
-
Brainstorming Tip: I'd draw inspiration from existing modular systems (e.g., Fate's aspects or Savage Worlds' edges) but innovate by creating a "toolkit" approach. Organize ideas into categories like "Core Engine," "Add-Ons," and "Custom Rules," and sketch out how they interconnect.
5. Consider Playtesting and Iteration Early
Even in the brainstorming phase, I'd think about how these concepts would be tested in practice. This ensures the framework is playable and fun, not just theoretically sound.
- Brainstorming Tip: Outline a simple playtest scenario, like a short adventure in a generic setting (e.g., a heist that could be in a castle or a spaceship). Use this to identify pain points, such as overly complex rules or gaps in adaptability.
- Community Involvement: Since this is a universal framework, I'd brainstorm ways to make it collaborative, like open-sourcing elements or creating a community hub for user-generated content. This could involve online tools for sharing custom modules.
Why Start Here?
Beginning with philosophy, core mechanics, character systems, and modularity ensures that the framework is built on a solid foundation. This approach avoids common pitfalls, like overcomplicating rules early on or creating a system that's too tied to one genre. From there, I could expand into advanced topics like GM tools, balance mechanics, or digital integration (e.g., apps for character sheets).
If you're actually building this, I'd recommend starting with a small group brainstorm session—perhaps using index cards for ideas or a digital tool like Miro for mind mapping. Once the foundational concepts are sketched out, iterate through prototypes and feedback. If you'd like, I can dive deeper into any of these areas or help refine specific ideas!
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.