Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

name some games that the consensus would rate about a 7.5 in ign terms but would be…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with DeepSeekdeepseek-r1-0528’s answer.
  1. User

    name some games that the consensus would rate about a 7.5 in ign terms but would be rated about a 3.0 by ign staff itself. this is inspired by ign rating imagine babyz a 7.5 and god hand, 3.0.

  2. Gemini Assistant

    This is a fun and challenging thought experiment, perfectly encapsulating the idea that critical reception and player reception can diverge wildly, especially with games that are niche, experimental, or technically flawed but conceptually brilliant.

    The "IGN gives it a 3.0" part is tough because IGN rarely gives scores that low unless a game is utterly broken, unplayable, or hilariously bad (like Ride to Hell: Retribution). The examples you gave (God Hand and Imagine Babyz) are legendary for this discrepancy.

    Here are some games that fit the spirit of what you're asking for, where IGN (or similar major outlets) gave a surprisingly low score, while the game garnered a significant cult following and a much higher player consensus:

    1. Deadly Premonition

      • IGN/Major Critic Score: Famously low. GameSpot gave it a 2.0/10, IGN gave it a 7.0 (for the director's cut, the original had lower scores in other outlets). This is the poster child for this phenomenon.
      • Player Consensus (IGN 7.5 equivalent): Often seen as a beloved cult classic, with user scores frequently in the 7.5-8.5 range. Players adore its bizarre story, unique characters, and unparalleled atmosphere, forgiving its atrocious graphics, janky controls, and technical issues.
    2. Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines

      • IGN/Major Critic Score: IGN gave it a 6.0/10. Many critics dinged it heavily for its extremely buggy launch, lack of polish, and performance issues.
      • Player Consensus (IGN 7.5 equivalent): Rose to become one of the most beloved PC RPGs of all time. Players embraced its incredibly rich writing, deep role-playing, atmosphere, and meaningful choices, often fixing the bugs themselves with community patches. It's regularly cited as a masterpiece of narrative design, easily in the 8.5-9.0 range for those who stuck with it (or played it post-patch).
    3. Killer7

      • IGN/Major Critic Score: IGN gave the GameCube version a 6.0/10, citing repetitive gameplay and a confusing story.
      • Player Consensus (IGN 7.5 equivalent): Another Suda51 game known for being highly divisive. It's praised by its fans for its unique art style, avant-garde narrative, bold themes, and distinct atmosphere. While its on-rails shooting and puzzles aren't for everyone, those who "get" it rate it much higher, often in the 7.0-8.0 range.
    4. Mount & Blade: Warband (or the original Mount & Blade)

      • IGN/Major Critic Score: IGN gave Warband an 8.0, which is higher than your requested 3.0, but the original Mount & Blade often received lower scores (around 7.0-7.5 from critics) for its primitive graphics, janky animations, and lack of polish.
      • Player Consensus (IGN 7.5 equivalent): Players, however, saw past the rough exterior to its revolutionary sandbox gameplay, deep strategy, and unparalleled freedom in a medieval setting. It's often cited as one of the most replayable and unique PC games ever, with user scores often in the 8.5-9.0 range. The disparity isn't as dramatic as God Hand or Deadly Premonition, but it's a good example of players appreciating gameplay depth over graphical polish.
    5. Dark Messiah of Might and Magic

      • IGN/Major Critic Score: IGN gave the PC version a 6.7/10, praising its combat but criticizing its linearity and short length.
      • Player Consensus (IGN 7.5 equivalent): This game's first-person combat, particularly its physics-based environmental interactions (kicking enemies into spikes, off ledges, onto fire, etc.), was revolutionary and deeply satisfying. Players absolutely loved the core gameplay loop, forgiving its other flaws. It's often remembered fondly and celebrated for its visceral combat, putting it in the 7.5-8.0 range for many fans.

    Finding games that genuinely received a 3.0 from IGN but are widely beloved is extremely rare, as that score usually signifies a fundamentally broken or terrible game. The examples above lean into games that were either:

    • Technically flawed at launch (Bloodlines, Deadly Premonition)
    • Highly experimental or niche (Killer7, God Hand)
    • Prioritized unique gameplay over polish (Mount & Blade, Dark Messiah)

    These are the types of games where traditional review metrics often miss the forest for the trees, while a dedicated player base sees the underlying genius.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.