Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Mistralmistral-small-2506· Mistral AIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

//@version=4 // 'resolution' argument removed to allow functions with side effects like…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-7-sonnet-20250219-thinking-32k’s answer.
  1. User

    //@version=4 // 'resolution' argument removed to allow functions with side effects like 'label.new' study(title="Moon's Volume Based Price Trend (with Disparity)", shorttitle="MVBPT_Disparity", format=format.volume)

    // --- Original MVBPT Logic --- sumd(series, distance) => sumd_val = 0.0 for i = 0 to distance sumd_val := sumd_val + series[i] sumd_val

    ldistance_level = input(title="long distance level", type=input.integer, defval=50, minval=1) sdistance_level = input(title="short distance level", type=input.integer, defval=5, minval=1)

    // Original lsumV calculation based on the provided code // This calculates the sum of volume over (ldistance_level + sdistance_level) and then subtracts ssumV. lsumV_total = sumd(volume, ldistance_level + sdistance_level) ssumV = sumd(volume, sdistance_level) lsumV_diff = lsumV_total - ssumV // This is the 'lsumV' used in the original vrate calculation

    // Calculate vrate, handling potential division by zero vrate = lsumV_diff != 0 ? ssumV / lsumV_diff : 0.0

    vrate_level = input(title="vrate level", type=input.float, defval=0.3, minval=0.0)

    vt = close * (vrate > vrate_level ? 1 : 0)

    // If vt becomes 0 (condition not met), it holds its previous value. // Use nz(vt[1], close) to handle the very first bar where vt[1] would be NaN, // in which case it defaults to 'close' for a more meaningful start. if (vt == 0) vt := nz(vt[1], close)

    // Plot original MPT and PRICE plot(vt, color=color.blue, title="MPT") plot(close, color=color.red, title="PRICE")

    // --- New Price Disparity Logic ---

    // Input options for displaying disparity show_disparity_on_chart = input(false, title="Show Price Disparity (%) on Chart?", type=input.bool) show_disparity_on_label = input(false, title="Show Price Disparity (%) as Label?", type=input.bool)

    // Calculate percentage disparity: ((PRICE - MPT) / MPT) * 100 // MPT (vt)가 0인 경우, 나눗셈 오류를 피하고 'na' (Not a Number)를 반환하여 플로팅되지 않도록 합니다. price_disparity_percent = 0.0 if vt != 0 // Avoid division by zero price_disparity_percent := ((close - vt) / vt) * 100 else price_disparity_percent := na // Set to 'na' if MPT is 0, so it doesn't plot / calculated.

    // 1. Plot for Data Window (always available in indicator settings/data window) // 'display=display.none'을 사용하여 차트에는 직접 표시되지 않고, 지표 설정의 '데이터 값' 탭에서 확인 가능합니다. plot(price_disparity_percent, title="Price Disparity (%) (Data Window)", display=display.none)

    // 2. Plot for Chart (optional, as a line) // 이 plot 함수는 'show_disparity_on_chart' 옵션이 true일 때만 차트에 선으로 표시됩니다. // 선 스타일 (plot.style_line) 또는 막대 스타일 (plot.style_columns)로 변경할 수 있습니다. plot(show_disparity_on_chart ? price_disparity_percent : na, title="Price Disparity (%) Plot", color=color.purple, style=plot.style_line, linewidth=1)

    // 3. Display as a label on the chart (optional, on the last bar) // 'show_disparity_on_label' 옵션이 true일 때만 가장 최근 캔들 위에 라벨로 표시됩니다. if show_disparity_on_label and barstate.islast var label disparityLabel = na // Declare a variable label to manage the label object label.delete(disparityLabel) // Delete the previous label to avoid accumulation

    string labelText = "Price Disparity: " + tostring(price_disparity_percent, "#.##") + "%"
    
    // Set background color based on positive/negative disparity
    color bgColor = na
    if not na(price_disparity_percent) // Only set color if disparity is not 'na'
        bgColor := price_disparity_percent > 0 ? color.new(color.green, 80) : color.new(color.red, 80)
    else
        bgColor := color.gray // Or any default color if MPT is 0
    
    if not na(price_disparity_percent) // Only create label if disparity is a valid number
        disparityLabel := label.new(bar_index, high, text=labelText, 
                                 xloc=xloc.bar_index, yloc=yloc.abovebar, 
                                 color=bgColor, textcolor=color.white, 
                                 style=label.style_label_down, size=size.normal)
    

    이 소스코드는 너가 수정해준 트레이딩뷰 인디케이터 소스코드야 여기서 패널 레이블과 프라이스 스케일 라벨을 체크하면 %값이 우측에 나오게끔 바꿔줘

  2. Mistral Assistant

    아래는 패널 레이블과 프라이스 스케일 라벨을 체크하면 우측에 %값이 표시되도록 수정한 코드입니다. var 변수를 사용해 라벨을 관리하고, barstate.islast 조건을 추가해 마지막 바에만 표시되도록 했습니다.

    //@version=4
    // 'resolution' argument removed to allow functions with side effects like 'label.new'
    study(title="Moon's Volume Based Price Trend (with Disparity)", shorttitle="MVBPT_Disparity", format=format.volume)
    
    // --- Original MVBPT Logic ---
    sumd(series, distance) =>
        sumd_val = 0.0
        for i = 0 to distance
            sumd_val := sumd_val + series[i]
        sumd_val
    
    ldistance_level = input(title="long distance level", type=input.integer, defval=50, minval=1)
    sdistance_level = input(title="short distance level", type=input.integer, defval=5, minval=1)
    
    lsumV_total = sumd(volume, ldistance_level + sdistance_level)
    ssumV = sumd(volume, sdistance_level)
    lsumV_diff = lsumV_total - ssumV
    
    vrate = lsumV_diff != 0 ? ssumV / lsumV_diff : 0.0
    vrate_level = input(title="vrate level", type=input.float, defval=0.3, minval=0.0)
    
    vt = close * (vrate > vrate_level ? 1 : 0)
    
    if (vt == 0)
        vt := nz(vt[1], close)
    
    plot(vt, color=color.blue, title="MPT")
    plot(close, color=color.red, title="PRICE")
    
    // --- New Price Disparity Logic ---
    show_disparity_on_chart = input(false, title="Show Price Disparity (%) on Chart?", type=input.bool)
    show_disparity_on_label = input(false, title="Show Price Disparity (%) as Label?", type=input.bool)
    show_panel_label = input(false, title="Show Price Disparity (%) in Panel Label", type=input.bool)
    show_price_scale_label = input(false, title="Show Price Disparity (%) on Price Scale", type=input.bool)
    
    price_disparity_percent = 0.0
    if vt != 0
        price_disparity_percent := ((close - vt) / vt) * 100
    else
        price_disparity_percent := na
    
    plot(price_disparity_percent, title="Price Disparity (%) (Data Window)", display=display.none)
    plot(show_disparity_on_chart ? price_disparity_percent : na,
         title="Price Disparity (%) Plot",
         color=color.purple,
         style=plot.style_line,
         linewidth=1)
    
    // Panel Label (bottom of the chart)
    if show_panel_label and barstate.islast
        var label panelLabel = na
        label.delete(panelLabel)
        string labelText = "Disparity: " + tostring(price_disparity_percent, "#.##") + "%"
        color bgColor = price_disparity_percent > 0 ? color.new(color.green, 80) : color.new(color.red, 80)
        panelLabel := label.new(bar_index, low, text=labelText,
                              xloc=xloc.bar_index, yloc=yloc.price,
                              color=bgColor, textcolor=color.white,
                              style=label.style_label_down, size=size.normal)
    
    // Price Scale Label (right side of the chart)
    if show_price_scale_label and barstate.islast
        var label priceScaleLabel = na
        label.delete(priceScaleLabel)
        string labelText = tostring(price_disparity_percent, "#.##") + "%"
        color bgColor = price_disparity_percent > 0 ? color.new(color.green, 80) : color.new(color.red, 80)
        priceScaleLabel := label.new(bar_index, high, text=labelText,
                                   xloc=xloc.bar_index, yloc=yloc.price,
                                   color=bgColor, textcolor=color.white,
                                   style=label.style_label_right, size=size.normal)
    

    주요 변경 사항:

    1. 패널 레이블 추가:

      • show_panel_label 입력 옵션 추가
      • yloc=yloc.price로 설정해 차트 하단에 표시
      • label.style_label_down 스타일 사용
    2. 프라이스 스케일 레이블 추가:

      • show_price_scale_label 입력 옵션 추가
      • yloc=yloc.price로 설정해 우측에 표시
      • label.style_label_right 스타일 사용
    3. 라벨 관리 개선:

      • var 변수로 라벨 객체 관리
      • barstate.islast 조건으로 마지막 바에만 표시
      • 이전 라벨 삭제 로직 추가

    이제 인디케이터 설정에서 "Show Price Disparity (%) in Panel Label"과 "Show Price Disparity (%) on Price Scale" 옵션을 체크하면 각각 차트 하단과 우측에 %값이 표시됩니다.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.