Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

What if when the gustav round was fired, after leaving the barrel after a second the…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Mistralmistral-medium-2505’s answer.
  1. User

    What if when the gustav round was fired, after leaving the barrel after a second the round magically became 100x bigger in each dimention. Remember the effect of air regarding drag and tumbling also decrease by 100x times due to huge sa vs mass ratio decrease (sa is 10k times more mass is 1 million times more, the force of air is negligable at this point). Velocity retained.

  2. Assistant

    Below is one plausible “physics-ish” walk-through of what would happen if, one second after leaving Schwerer Gustav’s barrel, the 7-ton 80 cm shell suddenly expanded so that every linear dimension was 100× larger while keeping the same density and velocity and while magically ignoring conservation-of-mass/energy issues.

    For clarity we’ll call the normal shell the “tiny round” and the post-magic monster the “mega round.”


    1. Basic numbers before and after the magical growth

    QuantityTiny roundMega round (×100 in every dimension)
    Diameter (assume 80 cm)0.80 m80 m
    Characteristic length L1×100×
    Volume ∝ L³1 V1 000 000 V
    Mass (ρ constant)7 100 kg7.1 × 10⁹ kg (≈7 million t)
    Surface area ∝ L²1 A10 000 A
    SA / Mass ratio11/100 (drag 100× less important)
    Muzzle velocity (v₀)≈800 m s⁻¹still ≈800 m s⁻¹
    Kinetic energy ½mv²2.3 × 10⁹ J (≈0.55 t TNT)2.3 × 10¹⁵ J (≈5.4 × 10⁵ t TNT ≈0.54 Mt)

    1. The “inflation” event at t = 1 s (~820 m from the gun)

    • A solid steel object the size of a football stadium (80 m diameter, maybe 250 m long) materialises inside ordinary air.
    • Roughly 1 million m³ of air (mass ≈1.2 million kg) is displaced outward essentially instantaneously.
    • That alone dumps ~7 × 10¹⁰ J into the atmosphere (comparable to a small conventional bomb), producing a violent spherical shock front and a deafening bang long before the shell ever hits anything.
    • The gun and its crew feel nothing new; the recoil happened a second earlier when the 7-ton round left the barrel.


    1. Flight after inflation

    Drag: SA/M ratio is 100 × lower than the original, and we already assumed drag magically decreases by the same factor, so aerodynamic braking is now negligible compared with gravity.

    Ballistics (no air resistance): • Using Gustav’s historical 52° elevation gives almost the ideal 45 ° vacuum trajectory.
    • Range R = v²/g · sin2θ ≈ (800² / 9.81) · sin(104°) ≈ 65 km.
    • Time of flight t ≈ 2 v sinθ / g ≈ 120 s.

    During those two minutes a city-block-sized projectile booms overhead at Mach ≈2.3, producing a monster continuous sonic boom.


    1. Impact on the ground

    Kinetic energy on arrival: 2.3 × 10¹⁵ J ≈ 0.54 megaton TNT
    (That is ~35 × Hiroshima yield, but delivered purely as kinetic energy.)

    Cratering (using empirical nuke/impact formula D ≈ 122 · Y⅓ metres for surface bursts):

    Y = 542 kt ⇒ D ≈ 122 · (542)⅓ ≈ 1 km

    • Expected crater ≈1 km across, ≈200–250 m deep (simple crater regime).
    • Severe ground shock (MM VIII–IX) out to a few km.
    • Lethal overpressure (≥5 psi) radius ~4–5 km, glass breakage tens of km.
    • Local ejecta blanket a few–10 m thick near rim, thinning with distance.

    Because the impact speed (0.8 km s⁻¹) is far below cosmic-impact speeds (11 km s⁻¹+), there is no vaporisation or global effects—just a very large conventional explosion.


    1. Side notes & curiosities

    • A 7-million-ton shell has the mass of a sizeable mountain; moving it at 800 m s⁻¹ means the projectile’s momentum is 5.7 × 10¹² kg m s⁻¹. Nothing short of a mountain range (or Earth itself) could stop it.
    • Even though the energy is “nuclear-scale,” fallout is zero—there’s no fission/fusion, only pulverised dirt and steel.
    • If it hit water instead, you’d get a 100-m-plus high spray curtain and a small tsunami in the near field, but not an ocean-wide catastrophe.
    • In space this thing would be a terrifying kinetic-kill weapon, but inside atmosphere its speed is too low to do extinction-level damage.


    1. TL;DR

    The magically enlarged Gustav shell quickly becomes a flying 80-m-wide, 7-million-ton slug still moving at Mach 2. It would:

    1. create a huge mid-air shock when it pops into existence,
    2. glide ~65 km almost un-braked, roaring like a continuous sonic boom, and
    3. on impact, deliver ~0.5 megaton of kinetic energy—blowing a kilometre-wide crater and leveling everything within several kilometres, but stopping well short of civilisation-ending havoc.

    In short: you’ve turned a super-artillery shot into a small nuclear-sized kinetic strike, without the radiation. Pretty grim for anyone at the impact point, but the planet will shrug it off.

  3. User

    Would it miss its target and what happens if this happened during the war

  4. Assistant

    Short answer
    ‣ The first shot would almost certainly overshoot the aim point by ~20 km, so yes—it would “miss.”
    ‣ Everyone on the battlefield would still know something unbelievable had happened, because a 7-million-ton stadium-sized slug would gouge a ~1 km crater wherever it finally landed and the shock wave of its mid-air materialisation would be heard for dozens of kilometres.
    ‣ After one or two such rounds the gun crew could re-zero their tables and start landing these half-megaton impacts more or less where they wanted, turning Schwerer Gustav into a quasi-nuclear siege gun years before the real A-bombs appeared.

    Below is the longer “how and what-if” breakdown.

    ────────────────────────────────────────

    1. Would the very first shot hit? ──────────────────────────────────────── The WWII firing tables for Gustav already included aerodynamic drag.
      • Historic trajectory (52° elevation, 820 m/s): ≈47 km range.
      • Same numbers in a vacuum (≈no drag):

    R = v² / g · sin 2θ = 820² / 9.81 · sin 104° ≈ 66 km

    That’s ~19 km farther than intended—about a 40 % overshoot.

    Even with an 80 m-wide projectile, a 19 km range error is colossal, so the shell would miss any normal-size fort, battery, or rail yard it had been aimed at.

    ──────────────────────────────────────── 2. Would subsequent shots miss? ──────────────────────────────────────── No—artillerymen are good at bracketing.

    • Spotters would see where this impossible new crater appeared.
    • The difference between “aim point” and “hit point” would be measured.
    • New range tables would be scratched out in minutes (or you simply lower elevation by ~5–6°).

    Result: by round two or three they’re on target, now laying down 0.5 Mt-equivalent kinetic strikes every few minutes.

    ──────────────────────────────────────── 3. Battlefield consequences in, say, 1942 ──────────────────────────────────────── Local physical effects of each impact (we worked these out in the first answer):
    • ≈1 km wide, 200 m deep crater.
    • 5 psi over-pressure out to 4–5 km (total annihilation of any surface fortifications, ammo dumps, or troop concentrations).
    • Debris & ejecta blanket several kilometres wide.
    • No radiation, no long-term fallout—just kinetic devastation.

    Operational / strategic fallout:

    1. Defensive positions like Sevastopol’s concrete batteries would be obliterated in ones and twos instead of requiring thousands of conventional shells.
    2. Morale impact on both sides would be off the charts; the thing is practically a “nuclear gun” in 1942.
    3. Counter-battery fire? The Allies/Russians could hit the gun, but a Gustav already took massive effort to hide, and the first time the enemy saw a 1 km crater simply appear, every spy plane in range would be hunting it.
    4. Logistics: Gustav needed a special twin-track rail line. With only 7-ton shells physically transported, ammo supply is still feasible; the magic does the impossible mass multiplication after launch.

    ──────────────────────────────────────── 4. Could anything stop the projectile? ──────────────────────────────────────── Not really. At ~7 billion kg and 800 m/s the momentum is 5.7 × 10¹² kg m/s. No bunker, warship, or mountain of reasonable size will shrug that off; it simply bores a crater.

    ──────────────────────────────────────── 5. Bottom line ──────────────────────────────────────── • First round: huge miss, even huger surprise.
    • Within a few rounds: dialled-in accuracy ≈ conventional artillery, damage ≈ small nuclear bomb per shell.
    • In a WWII context the side owning this “magic Gustav” now possesses the world’s first strategic-range, non-nuclear mega-weapon—decisive in any siege, terrifying in open warfare, and likely to become top-priority target number one for every bomber squadron the enemy can scrape together.

    Magic wins wars.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.