Skip to content
The Chat Archive
gemini-2.5-flash· Google LMArena Human Preference 140K

Who would agree? Communism is a stateless, moneyless and classless society where each…

  1. User

    Who would agree?

    Communism is a stateless, moneyless and classless society where each contributes according to their ability and each receives according to their need. It is in its non primitive form is the historical necessity which follows from the struggle of the oppressed and in their number more powerful, i.e. proletarians, against the bourgeoisie resulting in a solution of the antagonism between those who have and those have not. It is in its highest phase the moment where humanity comes to unity, where everyone shares one fundamental social relation, working together not against each other. It is a point further down in collective development, one step closer to truth and one step further from delusion. As the so termed natural order of kings and queens died, so shall the perceived natural order of the capitalist fall and any present justification for it be absurd one day.

  2. Assistant

    This text presents a classic, almost textbook, Marxist-Leninist understanding of communism. Therefore, the people who would most strongly agree with it are:

    1. Orthodox Marxists and Communists (e.g., Marxists-Leninists, Trotskyists, Maoists): This group would agree with virtually every statement, as it aligns directly with core tenets of their ideology:

      • Definition: "stateless, moneyless and classless society where each contributes according to their ability and each receives according to their need."
      • Historical Materialism/Necessity: "historical necessity which follows from the struggle of the oppressed... against the bourgeoisie."
      • Class Struggle: The focus on "proletarians against the bourgeoisie" and the "solution of the antagonism."
      • Utopian Vision (Highest Phase): "highest phase the moment where humanity comes to unity, where everyone shares one fundamental social relation, working together not against each other."
      • Critique of Capitalism: The comparison to feudalism and the prediction that "the capitalist fall and any present justification for it be absurd one day."
      • Epistemological Claim: "one step closer to truth and one step further from delusion."
    2. Revolutionary Socialists: Many socialists who believe in fundamental, systemic change (rather than gradual reform within capitalism) would find much to agree with, especially the critique of capitalism and the vision of a classless, cooperative society. They might not use the exact same terminology or agree on all the specific historical interpretations, but the overall thrust would resonate.

    3. Anarcho-Communists: They would strongly agree with the ultimate goal of a "stateless, moneyless and classless society" and the rejection of capitalist justifications. While they might differ on the means (emphasizing decentralization and direct action over a vanguard party, for instance), the end goal described is highly compatible with their vision.

    In essence, anyone deeply aligned with Marxist theory and revolutionary anti-capitalist thought would find this description highly agreeable.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.