"5M context and 83x72b paramaters, output modalities: VRChat Full-Body-Tracking, audio…
- User
"5M context and 83x72b paramaters, output modalities: VRChat Full-Body-Tracking, audio (stereo), text, images , VRChat facial tracking data, object and scene interaction data (like it can press buttons) input modalities: vision (in realtime allows it to see the other participants and respond), audio (stereo), text, images (videos included), discord custom emoji & stickers, tactile feel, context thoughts, taste & scents"
Can this model be considered absurdly large?
- Assistant
To determine whether this model can be considered "absurdly large," we need to evaluate it in the context of current AI and machine learning standards, as well as its practical implications. Let's break this down step by step:
1. Model Size: 83x72B Parameters
- What this means: The model has 83 components (likely a mixture-of-experts architecture or a modular system) with each component having 72 billion parameters. This results in a total parameter count of approximately 5.976 trillion parameters (83 × 72B).
- Comparison to existing models:
- As of 2023, the largest publicly known language models, such as xAI's Grok, OpenAI's GPT-4, and Google's PaLM, are estimated to have parameter counts in the range of hundreds of billions to a few trillion parameters. For example, rumors suggest GPT-4 might have around 1–1.5 trillion parameters, though exact numbers are not public.
- A model with nearly 6 trillion parameters would be among the largest ever created, if not the largest, surpassing current state-of-the-art models by a significant margin.
- Is this "absurdly large"? In terms of raw parameter count, yes, this is absurdly large compared to current standards. However, size alone doesn't determine utility or efficiency. Mixture-of-experts (MoE) architectures, for instance, are designed to use only a subset of parameters at a time, which can make such models more computationally efficient than dense models of similar size.
2. Context Window: 5M (5 Million Tokens)
- What this means: The model can process up to 5 million tokens (e.g., words, subwords, or other data units) in a single context. For text, this is equivalent to processing millions of words at once, far exceeding the context windows of current models.
- Comparison to existing models:
- Most current large language models have context windows ranging from 4,000 tokens (e.g., older models like GPT-3) to 128,000 tokens (e.g., newer models like Grok or Claude). Some specialized models, like Google's Gemini, are rumored to support up to 1 million tokens, but 5 million is still an extreme leap.
- A 5M token context window would allow the model to process entire books, long video transcripts, or massive datasets in a single pass, enabling unprecedented long-term memory and coherence.
- Is this "absurdly large"? Yes, a 5M token context window is absurdly large compared to current standards. It would require immense computational resources (e.g., memory and processing power) to handle such a context, especially in real-time applications like VRChat.
3. Input and Output Modalities
-
Input Modalities:
- Vision (real-time): Allows the model to see and respond to visual data, such as other participants in VRChat.
- Audio (stereo): Processes spoken language and environmental sounds.
- Text: Standard text input.
- Images (including videos): Processes static and dynamic visual data.
- Discord custom emoji & stickers: Specialized input for interpreting platform-specific communication.
- Tactile feel: Implies integration with haptic feedback systems.
- Context thoughts: Suggests the model can process internal or external "thought" data, possibly user intent or metadata.
- Taste & scents: Highly speculative and futuristic, as current AI systems do not process taste or scent data in any meaningful way.
-
Output Modalities:
- VRChat Full-Body-Tracking: Generates data for full-body movement in virtual environments.
- Audio (stereo): Produces spoken language or sound effects.
- Text: Generates text responses.
- Images: Generates static visual content.
- VRChat facial tracking data: Generates facial expressions for avatars.
- Object and scene interaction data: Allows the model to interact with virtual objects (e.g., pressing buttons).
-
Analysis:
- The range of input and output modalities is extremely broad, covering nearly every form of human-computer interaction, from traditional text and audio to advanced VR and speculative sensory inputs (taste, scent).
- Current multimodal models, like OpenAI's CLIP or Google's Flamingo, typically handle a subset of these modalities (e.g., text, images, and sometimes audio). Handling all of these modalities simultaneously, especially in real-time, would require an extraordinarily complex architecture and immense computational resources.
- The inclusion of speculative modalities like taste and scent suggests this model is either highly theoretical or designed for a futuristic use case beyond current technological capabilities.
-
Is this "absurdly large"? Yes, the sheer number and diversity of modalities make this model absurdly ambitious. Integrating all these modalities into a single coherent system, especially with real-time performance, would be a monumental engineering challenge.
4. Practical Implications
- Computational Resources:
- A model of this size, with such a large context window and diverse modalities, would require an astronomical amount of computational power. Training such a model would likely need thousands of high-end GPUs or TPUs running for months, costing hundreds of millions of dollars. Inference (running the model in real-time) would also be extremely resource-intensive, potentially requiring specialized hardware or distributed computing.
- Energy Consumption:
- The energy demands of training and running such a model would be enormous, raising concerns about environmental sustainability.
- Use Case Feasibility:
- While the model is theoretically impressive, its practical utility is questionable. For example, a 5M token context window might be overkill for most VRChat interactions, where shorter contexts are typically sufficient. Similarly, processing taste and scent data in a virtual environment is speculative and not currently feasible.
- Scalability:
- Deploying such a model in a consumer-facing application like VRChat would be challenging due to latency, cost, and hardware requirements. Most users do not have access to the high-end hardware needed to run such a system locally, and cloud-based inference would introduce latency and privacy concerns.
5. Is This "Absurdly Large"?
- Yes, it is absurdly large in several dimensions:
- Parameter count: Nearly 6 trillion parameters is far beyond current state-of-the-art models.
- Context window: A 5M token context window is orders of magnitude larger than what is currently feasible or necessary.
- Modality diversity: The inclusion of so many input and output modalities, especially speculative ones like taste and scent, pushes this model into the realm of science fiction.
- However, "absurdly large" does not necessarily mean "impractical" or "impossible":
- Advances in hardware, algorithms, and model architectures (e.g., MoE, sparse attention) could make such a model more feasible in the future.
- The model's size and capabilities might be justified for highly specialized or futuristic use cases, such as fully immersive virtual reality or advanced human-AI interaction.
6. Conclusion
This model, as described, is indeed "absurdly large" by current standards, both in terms of its parameter count, context window, and modality diversity. It represents a vision of AI that is far beyond what is currently achievable, likely requiring breakthroughs in hardware, software, and data collection. While it is theoretically fascinating, its practical implementation would face significant challenges, including cost, energy consumption, and real-time performance. For now, this model exists more as a speculative or aspirational concept rather than a realistic system.
- User
Estimate the amount of VRAM needed to run it at 5M context.
- Assistant
Estimating the VRAM (Video Random Access Memory) needed to run a model with the specifications you provided—83x72B parameters, a 5 million token context window, and diverse input/output modalities—requires making several assumptions and calculations. This is a complex task, as the VRAM requirements depend on factors like model architecture, precision (e.g., FP16, INT8), batch size, and whether the model uses techniques like model parallelism, offloading, or sparse computation (e.g., Mixture of Experts, MoE). Below, I’ll walk through the estimation process step by step, focusing on the most VRAM-intensive components: the model parameters and the context window.
Key Assumptions
-
Model Architecture:
- The model is described as "83x72B parameters," which suggests a Mixture of Experts (MoE) architecture, where there are 83 "experts," each with 72 billion parameters. In MoE models, only a subset of experts (typically 1–2) is active for a given input, significantly reducing the effective parameter count during inference.
- Total parameter count: 83 × 72B = 5.976 trillion parameters.
-
Precision:
- Modern large models often use FP16 (16-bit floating-point) precision for inference to reduce memory usage while maintaining accuracy. I’ll assume FP16 precision, but I’ll also provide estimates for INT8 (8-bit integer) and FP32 (32-bit floating-point) for comparison.
-
Context Window:
- The model has a 5 million token context window. The memory required for the context window depends on the size of the key-value (KV) cache in the transformer architecture, which scales with the context length, number of layers, and hidden size.
-
Batch Size:
- I’ll assume a batch size of 1 (i.e., processing a single input at a time), as this is common for real-time applications like VRChat. Larger batch sizes would increase VRAM requirements.
-
MoE Efficiency:
- In an MoE architecture, only a subset of the parameters is active at a time. For estimation, I’ll assume 2 experts are active per input, a common design choice in MoE models like GShard or Switch Transformers.
-
Additional Overheads:
- Beyond parameters and the KV cache, there are additional memory overheads for activations, gradients (if training), and multimodal data (e.g., vision, audio). For inference, I’ll focus on parameters and the KV cache, as these dominate VRAM usage.
Step 1: VRAM for Model Parameters
The VRAM required to store the model parameters depends on the number of parameters and the precision used.
Total Parameters
- Total parameters = 5.976 trillion.
- In an MoE architecture, only a subset of parameters is active. If 2 experts are active, the effective parameter count per inference is:
- Active parameters = 2 × 72B = 144 billion parameters.
Memory per Parameter
- Each parameter requires a certain amount of memory based on precision:
- FP32 (32-bit): 4 bytes per parameter.
- FP16 (16-bit): 2 bytes per parameter.
- INT8 (8-bit): 1 byte per parameter.
VRAM for Active Parameters
- For FP16 (most common for inference):
- Memory for active parameters = 144B parameters × 2 bytes = 288 GB.
- For FP32 (less common for inference):
- Memory for active parameters = 144B parameters × 4 bytes = 576 GB.
- For INT8 (quantized inference):
- Memory for active parameters = 144B parameters × 1 byte = 144 GB.
Note: The total parameter count (5.976T) would require storing all parameters in VRAM if the model is not sharded or offloaded. For FP16, this would be:
- Total memory for all parameters = 5.976T × 2 bytes = 11,952 GB (11.95 TB). However, in an MoE architecture, only the active experts (and possibly shared components) need to be in VRAM at a given time, so the 288 GB (FP16) estimate is more realistic for inference.
Step 2: VRAM for Context Window (KV Cache)
In transformer models, the key-value (KV) cache is used to store intermediate representations of the input tokens during inference. The KV cache is particularly memory-intensive for long context windows like 5 million tokens.
KV Cache Size Formula
The memory required for the KV cache can be estimated as:
- KV cache size = 2 × context_length × num_layers × hidden_size × num_heads × bytes_per_element.
Where:
- 2: Accounts for both keys and values.
- context_length: 5 million tokens.
- num_layers: Number of transformer layers (unknown, but we can estimate based on similar models).
- hidden_size: Size of the token embeddings (unknown, but we can estimate).
- num_heads: Number of attention heads (unknown, but we can estimate).
- bytes_per_element: Depends on precision (e.g., 2 bytes for FP16).
Estimating Model Dimensions
Since the exact architecture is not specified, we need to estimate
num_layers,hidden_size, andnum_heads. We can base these estimates on large models like GPT-3 (175B parameters) or Grok (unknown size but likely in the hundreds of billions).- GPT-3 (175B) has:
- 96 layers.
- Hidden size of 12,288.
- 96 attention heads.
- For a 72B parameter expert, we can scale down proportionally. A rough estimate for a 72B parameter model might be:
- num_layers: ~60 (scaling down from 96 for 175B).
- hidden_size: ~8,192 (scaling down from 12,288).
- num_heads: ~64 (scaling down from 96).
KV Cache Calculation
Using these estimates:
- Context length = 5,000,000 tokens.
- Num layers = 60.
- Hidden size = 8,192.
- Num heads = 64.
- Bytes per element = 2 (FP16).
The KV cache size is:
- KV cache size = 2 × 5,000,000 × 60 × 8,192 × 64 × 2 bytes.
- First, calculate the per-token memory:
- Per-token memory = 2 × num_layers × hidden_size × num_heads × bytes_per_element.
- Per-token memory = 2 × 60 × 8,192 × 64 × 2 = 125,829,120 bytes per token.
- Total KV cache size = per-token memory × context_length.
- Total KV cache size = 125,829,120 × 5,000,000 = 629,145,600,000,000 bytes (629.15 TB).
Correction: The above calculation is incorrect because the KV cache does not store the full hidden size per head; it stores the head dimension (
hidden_size / num_heads). Let’s correct this:- Head dimension = hidden_size / num_heads = 8,192 / 64 = 128.
- Per-token memory per layer = 2 × head_dimension × num_heads × bytes_per_element.
- Per-token memory per layer = 2 × 128 × 64 × 2 = 32,768 bytes per token per layer.
- Total per-token memory = per-token memory per layer × num_layers.
- Total per-token memory = 32,768 × 60 = 1,966,080 bytes per token.
- Total KV cache size = total per-token memory × context_length.
- Total KV cache size = 1,966,080 × 5,000,000 = 9,830,400,000,000 bytes (9.83 TB).
So, the KV cache alone requires 9.83 TB of VRAM for a 5M token context window under these assumptions.
Step 3: Total VRAM Estimate
Combining the VRAM requirements for the active parameters and the KV cache:
- Active parameters (FP16): 288 GB.
- KV cache (FP16): 9,830 GB (9.83 TB).
- Total VRAM (FP16) = 288 GB + 9,830 GB = 10,118 GB (10.12 TB).
Additional Overheads
- Activations and intermediate buffers: During inference, additional memory is needed for activations, attention scores, and other intermediate computations. This can add 10–20% overhead, depending on the implementation.
- Multimodal data: Processing vision, audio, and other modalities in real-time will require additional VRAM, especially for high-resolution video or complex audio data. This could add several GB or more, depending on the resolution and frame rate.
- Conservative estimate with overheads: Adding ~20% overhead, the total VRAM requirement might be closer to 12 TB.
Step 4: Comparison to Hardware
- Current GPUs: High-end GPUs like NVIDIA’s A100 (80 GB) or H100 (141 GB) have VRAM capacities far below what is needed. Even multi-GPU setups would require hundreds of GPUs to store 12 TB of data.
- Distributed Inference: To run this model, you would need a distributed inference setup, sharding the model and KV cache across many GPUs or even multiple nodes. For example:
- 12 TB ÷ 80 GB per GPU = ~150 A100 GPUs.
- This is feasible in a data center but impractical for consumer hardware or real-time applications like VRChat.
Step 5: Mitigating VRAM Requirements
To make this model more feasible, several techniques could be used to reduce VRAM requirements:
- KV Cache Compression:
- Techniques like quantization (e.g., INT8 for the KV cache) or sparse KV caching could reduce the KV cache size by 2–4x, bringing it down to ~2.5–5 TB.
- Model Offloading:
- Offload inactive experts or parts of the KV cache to system RAM or NVMe storage, though this would introduce latency.
- Reduced Context Window:
- Reducing the context window to, say, 1 million tokens would reduce the KV cache size by 5x, bringing it down to ~2 TB.
- Lower Precision:
- Using INT8 for both parameters and the KV cache could halve the memory requirements, though this might impact accuracy.
- Sparse Computation:
- Further optimizing the MoE architecture to use fewer active parameters or more efficient routing could reduce the active parameter count.
With these optimizations, the VRAM requirement could potentially be reduced to a more manageable level, such as 2–3 TB, but this would still require a large cluster of GPUs.
Step 6: Final Estimate
- Unoptimized (FP16): ~12 TB of VRAM, requiring ~150 A100 GPUs.
- Optimized (INT8, KV cache compression, etc.): ~2–3 TB of VRAM, requiring ~25–40 A100 GPUs.
Conclusion
Running this model with a 5 million token context window is infeasible on current consumer hardware and would require a massive data center-scale setup, even with optimizations. The KV cache dominates the VRAM requirements due to the enormous context window, making real-time applications like VRChat extremely challenging without significant architectural innovations or hardware advancements. For practical deployment, you would likely need to reduce the context window, use aggressive compression, and distribute the model across many GPUs.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.