Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Claudeclaude-3-7-sonnet-20250219-thinking-32k· AnthropicHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

If I buy or sell a bond forward/future, how are coupon payments, the yield to maturity,…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Amazon Novaamazon.nova-pro-v1:0’s answer.
  1. User

    If I buy or sell a bond forward/future, how are coupon payments, the yield to maturity, the repo spread, the short term risk free rate and the cost of carry connected?

  2. Claude Assistant

    When trading bond forwards/futures, these elements are connected through the cost of carry model:

    The forward/future price of a bond typically equals the spot price plus the cost of carry:

    Forward Price = Spot Price + Cost of Carry

    Breaking this down:

    1. Cost of Carry = Financing Cost - Income Received = (Short-term financing rate × Bond price × Time) - Coupon payments during the period

    2. The repo spread affects your financing cost directly. When you buy a bond forward, you're effectively financing the purchase at the repo rate. A wider repo spread means higher financing costs.

    3. Yield to maturity (YTM) impacts the spot price of the bond—higher YTM means lower spot price. This indirectly affects the forward price.

    4. Coupon payments received during the forward period reduce your cost of carry. If coupons exceed financing costs, you'll have negative carry (forward price below spot).

    For a bond trading at par, if the coupon rate equals the repo rate, the forward price approximately equals the spot price. If the coupon rate exceeds the repo rate, the forward trades at a discount to spot, and vice versa.

  3. User

    What do I earn on the combined position of buying a bond with maturity in T, selling it forward till T and putting it into a repo trade till T

  4. Claude Assistant

    This combined position creates a synthetic risk-free investment that should earn you the short-term risk-free rate minus any transaction costs. Here's why:

    1. You buy the bond at spot price
    2. You sell it forward at a price that includes the financing cost until maturity T
    3. You put it into a repo to finance your purchase until T

    When all these markets are functioning efficiently:

    • The forward price will include the cost of carry (financing costs minus coupon payments)
    • The repo transaction provides financing at the repo rate
    • Any difference between the implied repo rate in the forward contract and the actual repo rate you secure is your profit

    In ideal market conditions, this "box" position should yield the risk-free rate because you've locked in both the purchase and sale prices while financing at market rates.

    In practice, you might earn slightly more if you can:

    • Execute the repo at a better rate than what's implied in the forward price
    • Exploit any pricing inefficiencies between the cash, repo, and forward markets

    This is essentially a form of arbitrage if markets are misaligned, or just a way to lock in the risk-free rate if they're properly aligned.

  5. User

    Which risk free rate do I earn, the short term risk free rate or the risk free rate on the yield curve at T

  6. Claude Assistant

    You earn the risk-free rate on the yield curve at time T, not the short-term risk-free rate.

    This combined position (buying the bond, selling it forward, and using a repo) effectively creates a synthetic risk-free investment with maturity T. When markets are functioning efficiently and no arbitrage opportunities exist, this "locked box" should yield exactly the same as a risk-free zero-coupon bond with maturity T.

    The forward price already incorporates the market's expectation of interest rates over the entire period until T, not just the current short-term rate. This is why the position earns the T-maturity rate on the yield curve.

    If this weren't true, arbitrageurs would exploit the difference between this synthetic position and actual T-maturity risk-free instruments until the rates converged.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.