Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Looks like this is malfunction of this card since it was working fine before and without…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-flash-preview-04-17’s answer.
  1. User

    Looks like this is malfunction of this card since it was working fine before and without any changes to bios or hardware it apparently stopped. Two identical HDDs are connected to this card and they are arranged in RAID to mirror one another - RAID 1 I believe. Can I just connect those drives to motherboard SATA ports without a risk of loosing data? Would it be possible to recreate the RAID? WHat would be the steps to do it? This PC has SCU.

  2. Qwen Assistant

    If your LSI RAID card has failed or stopped working, you can connect the RAID 1 drives directly to the motherboard's SATA ports without losing data, but there are critical caveats. Here's a step-by-step guide to recover the data and recreate the RAID array:


    Important Notes Before Proceeding

    1. RAID Metadata: LSI RAID cards store metadata on the drives themselves. If you move the drives to a different controller (e.g., the motherboard's SATA controller), the new controller may not recognize the RAID metadata unless it’s the same type (e.g., another LSI card).
    2. Motherboard RAID vs. LSI RAID:
      • If your motherboard uses Intel RST or similar "fake RAID" (common in consumer PCs), it cannot read LSI RAID metadata. The drives will appear as raw disks, and the RAID array will not be recognized.
      • If your motherboard has a hardware RAID controller (rare in consumer systems), it may support importing the existing RAID array.
    3. Data Safety: As long as you do not initialize the drives or create a new array, the data should remain intact. However, proceed with caution.

    Step-by-Step Recovery Plan

    1. Connect Drives to Motherboard SATA Ports

    • Power down the PC and disconnect the LSI card.
    • Connect both RAID 1 drives to the motherboard's SATA ports (use separate ports for each drive).
    • Power on the PC and enter the BIOS/UEFI.

    2. Check BIOS/UEFI for Drive Detection

    • In the BIOS/UEFI, check if both drives are detected.
    • If the motherboard supports RAID (e.g., Intel RST), enable RAID mode in the SATA settings. Otherwise, leave it in AHCI mode.
    • Save changes and exit.

    3. Boot into the Operating System

    • If the OS boots successfully:
      • Check Disk Management (Windows) or lsblk (Linux) to see if the drives are listed.
      • If the RAID array is not recognized, the OS will see the two drives as separate, uninitialized disks.
    • If the OS fails to boot:
      • This likely means the OS was installed on the RAID array managed by the LSI card. You’ll need to recover the data manually.

    4. Recover Data Without RAID Controller

    If the motherboard cannot recognize the LSI RAID array:

    • Use a Linux Live USB (e.g., Ubuntu):
      1. Boot from the Linux Live USB.
      2. Open a terminal and run sudo fdisk -l or lsblk to list all drives.
      3. If the drives show partitions with LSI metadata (e.g., Linux RAID or LSI MegaRAID), you may need to assemble the array manually:
        sudo mdadm --assemble --scan
        
      4. If successful, mount the RAID array and copy the data to a backup drive.
      5. If not, use tools like testdisk to recover partitions or files directly from the drives.

    5. Recreate RAID on the Motherboard (Optional)

    If you want to recreate RAID 1 using the motherboard's controller:

    • Warning: This will erase all data on the drives unless you first back up the data using the Linux Live USB method above.
    • Steps:
      1. Enter the motherboard's RAID BIOS (usually accessible via Ctrl+I for Intel RST or Ctrl+R for AMD StoreMI).
      2. Create a new RAID 1 array using the two drives.
      3. Reinstall the OS or restore data from backup.

    Alternative: Replace the LSI RAID Card

    If the LSI card is faulty:

    1. Replace it with an identical or compatible LSI card (e.g., same model or one with compatible firmware).
    2. Install the replacement card and reconnect the drives.
    3. Boot into the LSI RAID BIOS to verify the existing RAID 1 array is detected.
    4. If the array is degraded, replace the faulty drive and rebuild the mirror.

    Summary of Risks

    ScenarioRisk
    Moving drives to motherboardRAID array may not be recognized; data inaccessible without manual recovery.
    Recreating RAID on motherboardData loss unless you back up first.
    Replacing LSI cardRequires identical hardware; rebuilding array may take hours.

    Recommended Approach

    1. Back up data first using a Linux Live USB or external enclosure.
    2. If you need to keep the RAID array:
      • Replace the LSI card.
      • Rebuild the array using the existing drives.
    3. If you abandon RAID:
      • Connect one drive to the motherboard (since RAID 1 mirrors both drives).
      • Reformat the second drive and use it as a standalone backup.

    If the LSI card is confirmed dead and you cannot replace it, focus on recovering the data first, then decide whether to use motherboard RAID or switch to a single drive setup.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.